https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

IAS Rohini vs IPS D Roopa Case: SC Bench Asks Their Lawyers to Amicably Explore a Settlement

"Both of them are young officers, their career will be affected if this fight goes on," said the SC Bench
Indian Masterminds Stories

After more than a year of mud-slinging and a barrage of allegations between IAS officer Rohini Sindhuri (2009-batch) and IPS officer D Roopa Moudgil (2009-batch), a Bench of Justices Abhay S Oka and Pankaj Mithal of the Supreme Court of India ordered the two bureaucrats to explore a settlement reminding them that they were “public functionaries” and should refrain from such conduct. 

The Bench observed, “Both of them are young officers, their career will be affected if this fight goes on.” They further said, “To help the situation, if both of you agree (speaking to the lawyers of the bureaucrats), we can record in the order that since allegations are withdrawn, the State should not precipitate the matter by starting something on the basis of allegations made (by them) against each other.”

The contentious issue arose after they failed to resolve differences arising from allegedly defamatory remarks made by the women officers against each other. On February 21st (2023), Ms. Sindhuri issued a legal notice to Ms. Moudgil and demanded an unconditional apology and Rs. 1 crore in damages for “the loss of her reputation and mental agony.”

On March 24th, a Bengaluru court, that was hearing the private suit filed by Ms. Sindhuri, ordered the initiation of a criminal defamation case against Ms. Moudgil, who then moved the High Court to have the same quashed. On August 21st, the Karnataka High Court rejected her plea.

High Court judge Justice Sachin Shankar Magadum observed that Officer Moudgil’s statements on her social media account and print media warranted a criminal trial. She then approached the apex court.

IAS officer Ms. Rohini Sindhuri was represented by senior advocate Sidharth Luthra, who told the court that attempts to resolve the conflict between the two female officers have failed. Additionally, advocate Sidharth Luthra told the court that the IPS officer makes press statements criticizing the IAS officer on a daily basis.

The Supreme Court had previously expressed its opinion on the matter, stating that such issues between public servants were best resolved between themselves and directing the IAS and IPS officers “to work out a solution which will be in the interest of both of them.”


Indian Masterminds Stories
Related Stories
NEWS
IRTS logo
IRTS Gopinath Kaiwara Venkateshappa Appointed As Director In Ministry of Tourism
IRS Officers ndian revenue Services
IRS Rashmita Jha Given Additional Charge as CVO, Rural Electrification Corporation Limited
IRSME_resized
IRSME Anshul Kumar Pushkar to Officiate in JA Grade on Notional and Actual Basis
NCB-narcotics-control-bureau-reszd
IRS Shashank Seohare Made Assistant Director At NCB
IAS Sanjay Kumar
IAS Sanjay Kumar Made Interim Secretary for the Department of Higher Education
IRS Sameer Wankhede
IRS Sameer Wankhede Seeks CBI Probe in Atrocities Case Against Nawab Malik
Haryana police-resized
Haryana: Police Leadership Gets a Shake-Up, Saurabh Singh Appointed Commissioner of Police, Faridabad
IAS Mona Khandhar
IAS Mona Khandhar Takes Charge as Chairperson of Gujarat Panchayat Service Selection Board
Videos
WhatsApp Image 2024-11-20 at 18.06
Hyderabad's Transformation From The City of Pearls to Cyberabad
IMG-20241118-WA0002
The Journey Behind Kathakar Ki Diary | Video Interview 
GP Singh
They Aren’t Criminals, But IPS Officers, Standing Up To Political Pressure
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
IRTS logo
IRTS Gopinath Kaiwara Venkateshappa Appointed As Director In Ministry of Tourism
IRS Officers ndian revenue Services
IRS Rashmita Jha Given Additional Charge as CVO, Rural Electrification Corporation Limited
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
WhatsApp Image 2024-11-20 at 18.06
IMG-20241118-WA0002
GP Singh
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT