https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

EVMs Fail to Meet Democratic Standards, Claims Former IAS Officer

Retired IAS officer MG Devasahayam, coordinator for the Citizen Commission on Elections (CCE), states that political parties' criticism of the EVM-VVPAT system is often based on convenience rather than scientific evidence. The CCE's study concludes that EVMs do not comply with fundamental democratic principles.
MG Devasahayam
Indian Masterminds Stories

The 2024 General Election of India has concluded, with the BJP-led NDA forming the government and Narendra Modi becoming Prime Minister for the third consecutive term. However, this election brought some surprises. For the first time since 2014, the BJP fell short of a majority, winning only 240 seats. Meanwhile, the opposition alliance, I.N.D.I.A, saw significant growth, securing 234 seats in total.

Unlike previous elections, there was less talk or criticism about the efficiency of Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs). However, the debate is far from over. Retired IAS officer Mr. MG Devasahayam, who is also the coordinator for the Citizen Commission on Elections (CCE), asserts that political parties criticize the EVM-VVPAT system based on their convenience rather than scientific evidence. The CCE, formed after the 2019 general elections, conducted a scientific study with experts from around the world and concluded that EVMs do not comply with the basic principles of democracy.

This finding suggests that the debate over the reliability of EVMs is ongoing and remains a critical issue for ensuring democratic integrity in India.

In an exclusive interview with Indian Masterminds, retired officer and columnist Mr. Devasahayam shared his concerns. He said, “As a civil servant, I’ve conducted many elections, from local to general. To the public, voting might seem straightforward, but we know what happens behind the scenes. In our commission, we studied different voting methods and found that EVMs lack complete verifiability. There are serious concerns that can’t be ignored. We have submitted our report to the Election Commission of India, but they are not open to any debate or discussion.”

END TO END VERIFIABILTY 

In any democracy, citizens should be able to confirm that their vote was cast as intended, recorded correctly, and counted accurately. The EVM-VVPAT system fails to ensure this. VVPAT only verifies that the vote was cast as intended. Mr. Devasahayam claims there have been reports of discrepancies where something different is recorded than what was shown. Additionally, the VVPAT slips are not counted. “Many senior citizens and those unfamiliar with the system may not be able to verify the slips. They count what voters haven’t seen; they don’t actually count the slips,” says the retired officer.

In a democracy, voting is not merely a routine exercise to elect a leader. “Every eligible citizen has the right to vote, and through their votes, they transfer their sovereignty. Therefore, they have the right to ensure their vote is counted accurately and without any manipulation,” adds the officer.

ONLY HUMAN ERROR IS POSSIBLE 

Mr. Devasahayam argues that the time taken to count votes using ballot papers and EVMs is almost the same, so efficiency is not a concern. “All advanced democracies with advanced technology still use ballot papers because they are the gold standard,” he says.

Addressing concerns about vote manipulation and human error, he explains that with ballot papers, errors are limited to tens or hundreds and are only human mistakes. However, with EVMs, there is room for both human and mechanical errors, potentially affecting millions of votes. “With ballot papers, we can trace where an error happened, but EVMs increase the scope for manipulation. We can’t determine who tampered with the system or from where,” he explains.

He also mentions that the issue of booth capturing is outdated. “In the past, we lacked good transportation, communication, or security, but now we have ultra-modern technology. Communication is instantaneous, and any mishap can be investigated. This isn’t possible with the EVM-VVPAT system,” Mr. Devasahayam points out.

In essence, he believes that the traditional ballot paper system is more transparent and reliable. Despite technological advancements, the potential for manipulation and error in EVMs remains a significant concern, making ballot papers the preferred choice in many advanced democracies.


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
Hindustan Shipyard Limited HSL
PESB Declines to Recommend CMD for Hindustan Shipyard; Ministry May Extend Current Chief’s Tenure
IAS Ajitabh Sharma
“80% of Time Spent on Non-Core Tasks”: Rajasthan Principal Secretary Ajitabh Sharma Questions IAS Work Culture, Calls for Reform
Nitin Gadkari
India to Become Net Energy Exporter in 6-7 Years, Highlights Hydrogen and Biofuels: Union Minister Nitin Gadkari
Bank of India - BOI
Bank of India Plans to Raise Rs 20,000 Crore via Infrastructure Bonds in FY 2025-26
BEML Limited
For Operational Excellence, BEML Lays Foundation of State-of-the-Art Central Warehousing Centre in Bilaspur
rec-logo
Green Energy Boost: REC Forms New Subsidiary for 3GW Ananthapuram-II REZ Transmission Project
Bhupendra Patel CM Gujarat
CM Bhupendra Patel’s Pro-People Move: Uniform House Tax of ₹200 Annually for Rural Government-Assisted Homes in Gujarat
CM Nitish Kumar
Bihar: Gaya to Become Bihar’s Largest Industrial Township Under AKIC; ₹16,524 Cr Investment Expected
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
WhatsApp Image 2025-06-25 at 5.07
Why Has the DGCA Fined Air India Rs 5 Crore Since Privatisation?
Former Diplomat Ashok Sajjanhar
Iran Is Weakest Now, Needs a Face-Saver
WhatsApp Image 2025-06-23 at 12.39
Retired Officers Lead 7-Day Mission to Revive Betwa River with 55 Check Dams | Video Interview
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
Sanish Kumar Singh
“If you want it badly enough, you’ll find a way,” Sanish Kumar Singh AIR 8, UPSC IFS 2024 
The real interview, he says, was much more humane. “The board was conversational. The chairman opened...
Raju Wagh
When the Battlefield Became a Study Room and a Dream Took Flight
Amid IED blasts and anti-Maoist operations in Bastar, CRPF Commando Raju Wagh taught village kids, studied...
WhatsApp Image 2025-06-18 at 10.31
"I Just Wanted to Breathe Again": The Man Who Fought Death and Made It to UPSC
Struck by COVID at the peak of his UPSC prep, Devanand Telgote spent months on ECMO, unsure he'd live,...
Social Media
Shailaja Chandra
“Nanis & Dadis Have a Brain”: Former IAS Officer Shailaja Chandra Weighs in on 1970s vs 2025 Life Debate - “This Generation Has It Better”
Responding to Viral Post on Middle-Class Struggles, Ex-Bureaucrat Offers Candid Reflection on Then and...
Tigress Arrowhead
The End of an Era: A Queen Falls - Ranthambore’s Iconic Tigress Arrowhead (T-84) Passes Away at 14, Hours After Daughter’s Relocation
Ranthambore mourns the loss of one of its fiercest and most beloved tigers, Arrowhead, the granddaughter...
Screenshot 2025-06-13 194001
Wild Elephant Disrupts Riverside Picnic, Sparks Debate on Human Encroachment; IFS Parveen Kumar Shares the Video - Watch Here!
Mr. Kaswan used the viral video, which has garnered over 1.5 lakh views, to highlight the risks of human...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
678341a1754f9-ias-prashant-kumar-singh-appointed-as-manipur-chief-secretary-12142054-16x9
IAS Prashant Kumar Singh: Taking Charge of Manipur in Its Toughest Hour
Hindustan Shipyard Limited HSL
PESB Declines to Recommend CMD for Hindustan Shipyard; Ministry May Extend Current Chief’s Tenure
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
WhatsApp Image 2025-06-25 at 5.07
Former Diplomat Ashok Sajjanhar
WhatsApp Image 2025-06-23 at 12.39
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT