https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

From Shanties to Schools: How 1991 Economic Reforms Powered an Education Revolution in India

The 1991 economic liberalization empowered Delhi’s migrant families, fostering belief in education as the key to escaping poverty. This shift enabled children from JJ clusters to access public schooling and aspire toward better livelihoods. Read the full book review...
Indian Masterminds Stories

When the British left India in 1947, we were an impoverished nation. Our poverty ratio was an abysmal eighty percent, and not more than twelve percent of our people, predominantly upper caste males living in urban centres, had some modicum of literacy. From then to now, there has been a sea change. While governments, denominational institutions, civil society organizations and corporates have made significant contributions to the spread of literacy, the core argument of Manimala Roy’s excellent study From Shanties to Schools: A Silent Movement is that the main driver of this change has been the economic liberalization of 1991.

The Metropolis of Delhi

Taking the metropolis of Delhi as an exemplar, where she has done extensive field work, she argues that the Narasimha Rao – Manmohan Singh led reforms not only generated opportunities and resources for children of migrants living in the Jhuggi-Jhopri (JJ)clusters of Delhi, but also convinced their parents that education was the one and only way out of this morass. Her study of the lives of migrant workers and their children in the shanty towns of Delhi reveals the ‘migrant’ view point about education as the harbinger of social respect, empowerment and employment. Interestingly, as incomes rose, the middle class of Delhi moved their children to private schools, thereby creating the space for children of JJ clusters to enroll in state government, municipal and NDMC schools.

The decade of nineties: micro reality and the global perceptions

At the end of the first decade of liberalisation, I found myself as a Guest scholar at The Brookings Institution in Washington, DC. Stephen Cohen, the profound scholar on the political economies and strategic policies of Indian and Pakistan headed the South Asia desk at this prestigious think tank. These were pre RTI days, when governments held information close to their chests. He asked me to exercise my clout as a (then) serving civil servant to help him collect information from state governments about the Sarva Shikhsa Abhiyan (SSA, Education for All) under the New Policy on Education (NPE) 1992 for his forthcoming book – India: Emerging Power. Earlier in that decade, based on nudges from Jagdish Bhagwati, Jean Dreze and Amartya Sen, the Planning Commission and Ministry of Human Resource Development had adopted the SSA as a ‘nation as a whole’ approach to education. This translated into the Government of India providing additional resources to state governments to ensure that ‘no child was left out of school’, and that adult literacy centres came up within ‘walkable distance’. With Kottayam and Ernakulum districts in Kerala becoming fully literate in 1989, every other District Magistrate in the country started looking upon cent percent enrolment and ‘full literacy’ as achievable milestones.

However, the point that I wish to recall is that one fine morning – probably in June of 2000 – Prof Cohen told me and Gen Jahangir Karamat (an Ex-Army chief of Pakistan, who was also at Brookings as a senior Fellow at the same time) over coffee that finally, India had crossed the hump – more people were now literate, than illiterate. This was certainly not the case with Pakistan, and he inferred – with great prescience that India would leave Pakistan behind in every field – be it economic power, military might, or political stability. This then is the power of education – for nations, communities, families and of course, individuals. He mentioned this Domestic Dimension – the fourth chapter of his book INDIA : Emerging Power.

Education as the Driver for Change

If today, India has indeed emerged as the third largest and the fastest growing economy of the world, substantial part of the credit goes to the passionate commitment of all castes and all classes in the country to provide their next generation with the best quality education they can scout for their wards. Roy has painstakingly studied the lived reality of students, parents and educators of children living in seven JJ clusters – in seven of the eleven revenue districts of Delhi. These range from the absolutely dilapidated ones in Govindpuri to the cleaner and better organized SIM (South Indian Madrasi ) Basti near the Delhi university, and the relatively better off slum behind the NSCI in the NDMC area, each slum has its own demographics, and history, but what unites them all is the commitment of the parents and the children together to transform their lives through education. Another very important finding is that educational and occupational aspirations of migrant children are not gender specific. They receive support from their parents in their quest to improve their lives – and by implication that of their parents.

However, perhaps because of lack of awareness, and absence of opportunities for vocational training in the school system, most students were keen on settling down early to positions in retail, hospitality, nursing, pharma and clerical positions – which is also reflective of the changing character of the city as the hub of services. Delhi offers miniscule opportunities in agriculture, and the base of organized manufacturing is also limited. So in many ways, the choices exercised by the students and their parents collectively are defined by ‘bounded rationality’. However, one thing is certain – the scale and scope that is open to them is far greater than that of the country cousins who are still eking out a paltry existence from the parched fields in their native villages.

But if they are better off than their cousins they have left behind, as first generation learners, they face a challenge from those whose parents have had the benefit of having a settled job in the metropolis. They cannot seek the support of their parents or grandparents, are unable to afford private tuition in the STEM stream, and even if some families have the resources, quality tuition teachers are not available in their immediate vicinity.

The author also draws our attention to the enrolment of children from JJ clusters into public schools as part of the RTE initiative. However, this has had its own share of externalities. Her research findings show that nearly 63% of the students from these clusters had a sense of an inferiority complex in the company of children from wealthier households. They led a kind of a double life – for while uniforms made them look alike – everything else – the gadgets, the mobiles, the social spaces, the lunch boxes, birthday parties and parental profiles – all aggravated the sense of deprivation. Schools had not given adequate attention to this very important aspect, and this was proving to be traumatic for impressionable young minds.

In fine, this is a book which must be read not just by educators and policy professionals, but by all those who believe, in the words of Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, the author of Little Prince, ‘as for the future, your task is not to foresee it but to enable it’. Manimala Roy has taken the first step in this direction. Let us follow her example to contribute in whatever way we can to create a more equitable India with education as the principal driver of change.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Dr Sanjeev Chopra, is a 1985-batch IAS Officer of West Bengal cadre. He retired from the service on March 31, 2021 as Director, Lal Bahadur Shastri National Academy of Administration (LBSNAA), Mussoorie.


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
Indian Police Services IPS Officer
Delhi Govt Transfers Joint CP Security to ACB, Telangana’s NP Reddy Appointed DIG in CISF
Delhi Police Transfers
Delhi Govt Reshuffles 11 IPS & DANIPS Officers Across Key Police Divisions; Rajesh Khurana Posted as Spl. CP (MD), DPHCL
Maharashtra govt-logo
Maharashtra: 12 State Civil Services Officers Promoted to IAS Cadre from 2024 Select List - Check Order & Details Here
President Droupadi Murmu resized
President Droupadi Murmu Appoints New Governors for Goa, Haryana, and Ladakh - Check Details Here
IPS Officer Indian Police Services
Centre Files Review Petition Against Supreme Court Ruling on IPS Deputation to CAPFs - Details Inside
Mohan Yadav CM MP
Madhya Pradesh Semiconductor Policy Spurs Rs 352 Crore Investment in Bhopal
ODOP-AWARDS-14-10-2023
Madhya Pradesh Clinches 2nd Place in National ODOP Award 2024; CM Mohan Yadav Extends Congratulations
Mohan Yadav textile investment Dubai
MP CM Dr. Mohan Yadav Courts Textile Investment in Dubai, Showcases Madhya Pradesh as Emerging Global Hub
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
AI 171 CRASH
AAIB Initial Probe In AI-171 Crash Questioned By Aviation Experts
Ravi Kapoor
Why Ex-IRS Officer Ravi Kapoor Walked Away from Power
WhatsApp Image 2025-07-07 at 3.15
The Martial Artist IRS Officer Who Conquered North East India on a Cycle
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
WhatsApp Image 2025-07-14 at 15.58
The Economist Who Became an IFS Officer
How Abhimanyu Gahlaut balanced global economics and civil services dreams to crack UPSC with AIR 38
Disha Dwivedi UPSC
How Disha Dwivedi Conquered UPSC on Her Sixth Attempt
Disha Dwivedi’s UPSC journey from five prelims failures to securing AIR 672 in 2024 showcases strategic...
Sushmitha and Ishwarya Ramanathan
Their Home Was Washed Away — Sushmitha & Ishwarya Built a Legacy Instead
Sushmitha and Ishwarya lost their home to the 2004 tsunami. But with books, belief, and each other, they...
Social Media
Standing Leopard
Leopard Stuns Internet by Standing on Two Legs Like a Meerkat
A rare video of a leopard standing on two legs in Kruger Park stuns viewers and goes viral across social...
G S Roshni
Kerala’s Fearless Forest Officer G.S. Roshni Rescues 16-Foot King Cobra with Bare Hands, Garners Praise & Critique
Beat Forest Officer G.S. Roshni’s first-ever king cobra rescue goes viral, earning her the title of ‘Green...
Kaziranga Baby Elephant
Chotu the Baby Elephant Reunited with Mother in Kaziranga: Retired IFS Officer’s Post Goes Viral
A baby elephant's emotional reunion with its mother in Kaziranga, shared by retired IFS officer Susanta...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
Indian Police Services IPS Officer
Delhi Govt Transfers Joint CP Security to ACB, Telangana’s NP Reddy Appointed DIG in CISF
Delhi Police Transfers
Delhi Govt Reshuffles 11 IPS & DANIPS Officers Across Key Police Divisions; Rajesh Khurana Posted as Spl. CP (MD), DPHCL
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
AI 171 CRASH
Ravi Kapoor
WhatsApp Image 2025-07-07 at 3.15
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT