https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Former CJIs Endorse ‘One Nation, One Election’ but Flag Concerns Over EC’s Powers

Simultaneous Polls Constitutional, Say Ex-CJIs - But With Legal Caveats. Constitutional Validity Affirmed, But Caution Advised on Implementation and Electoral Fairness
Indian Masterminds Stories

New Delhi: Former Chief Justices of India (CJIs) have broadly endorsed the constitutional validity of the ‘One Nation, One Election’ concept in their submissions to the Joint Parliamentary Committee, but also flagged serious concerns over the sweeping powers proposed for the Election Commission of India (ECI) and potential risks to electoral fairness.

In written opinions and during appearances before the committee, former CJIs including Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justice Ranjan Gogoi, Justice J.S. Khehar, and Justice U.U. Lalit provided legal insight into the proposed Constitutional Amendment Bill that seeks to synchronize Lok Sabha and state assembly elections.

Chandrachud Rejects Basic Structure Argument Against Simultaneous Polls

In his written opinion, Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, who recently retired as Chief Justice of India, rejected the opposition’s argument that simultaneous elections would violate the basic structure of the Constitution, stating:

“Nowhere does the Constitution mandate that national and state elections must be held separately… the staggered timing of elections is not an immutable constitutional feature.”

He emphasized that voters’ rights are not infringed by simultaneous elections, and that arguments assuming Indian voters are easily misled undermine the democratic process itself.

Concerns Over ‘Unlimited Powers’ to Election Commission

However, Justice Chandrachud joined Justice Ranjan Gogoi in questioning the proposed “sweeping and undefined powers” given to the Election Commission under the draft bill. He warned that such powers, without explicit constitutional safeguards, could allow the poll body to alter or extend the tenure of state assemblies, potentially eroding federal principles.

“The Constitution should define, delineate, and structure the circumstances under which the ECI can exercise such power,” he noted.

Both Justices Chandrachud and Khehar are scheduled to appear before the committee chaired by BJP MP P.P. Choudhary on July 11 to answer member queries.

Also Read: MP High Court Halts Reservation-in-Promotion Policy Pending Clarification from State Government

Gogoi, Lalit Caution Against Electoral Imbalance and Legal Pitfalls

Justice Ranjan Gogoi, during an earlier interaction with the committee, also expressed concern about the excessive authority proposed for the Election Commission, aligning with concerns raised by several committee members.

Meanwhile, Justice U.U. Lalit suggested that if simultaneous elections are implemented, they should be held in a phased and calibrated manner. He argued that forcing state assemblies to shorten their terms for synchronization could open the law to legal challenges on constitutional grounds.

Need for a Level Playing Field: Smaller Parties at Risk

Justice Chandrachud also raised concerns about electoral fairness, especially for smaller or regional parties. He pointed out that simultaneous elections could amplify the dominance of national parties with larger financial and organizational resources.

He proposed stronger regulation of election expenditure, particularly the spending by political parties, which currently falls outside the legal cap imposed on individual candidates.

“This regulatory imbalance favors financially stronger parties. To ensure a level playing field, campaign finance rules must be legislatively strengthened,” he stated.

Key Takeaways from Former CJIs’ Opinions

  • All four former CJIs agree that simultaneous elections do not violate the Constitution.
  • Major concern: Undefined discretionary powers for the Election Commission.
  • Justice Chandrachud and Gogoi: Urge guidelines and limitations for ECI authority.
  • Justice Lalit: Warns against curtailing assembly terms; suggests phased synchronization.
  • Concerns raised about regional party marginalization and financial imbalance in elections.

Also Read: Advocates’ Association Urges CJI Gavai to Expedite Judges’ Appointments to Karnataka High Court


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
Delhi Metro Rail
DMRC Advances Phase 4 Expansion: Achieves Key Tunnel Breakthrough on Golden Line at Tughlakabad
RLDA
PAC Flags RLDA Over Delayed Land Development: Just 3 of 17 Sites See Progress Despite Decade-Old Handover
Madhya-Pradesh-High-Court-reszd
MP High Court Welcomes 10 New Judges, Strength Rises to 44 Amid Push for Balanced Judicial Appointments
ACV
India Launches Construction of Homegrown ACVs for High-Speed Maritime Response
S 500
India-Russia S-500 Deal May Redefine Global Air Defence Supply Chains With Indigenous Production and Re-Export Clause
CAQM
CAQM’s New Mohali Cell to Oversee Stubble Control, Biomass Co-firing, and Pollution in Punjab-Haryana NCR
IPS Officer Indian Police Services
35 IPS Officers from 1993 & 1994 Batches Empanelled for DG and DG-Equivalent Posts - Details Inside
GAIL PSU
GAIL & RVUNL Form Joint Venture to Integrate Gas-Based Power with Renewable Energy in Rajasthan
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Ananth Rupanagudi IRAS
IRAS Ananth Rupanagudi’s Take on Corruption, Reform, and Duty
WhatsApp Image 2025-07-26 at 13.16
What Most Indians Don't Know About Jim Corbett
WhatsApp Image 2025-07-24 at 18.24
How Fireflies and Butterflies Returned In Corbett’s Homeland
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
BPSC Bihar police
From Lantern Light to Police Uniform: How Praveen Kumar from a Small Bihar Village Cracked BPSC to Become SDPO
From a lantern-lit village in Bihar to becoming an SDPO, Praveen Kumar's journey is a testament to resilience,...
IAS Priyansha Garg
Why Mindset Matters: IAS Priyansha Garg’s Mental Health Mantra for UPSC
After two failed prelims, Priyansha Garg cracked UPSC with AIR 31 in her fourth attempt, proving how...
Ashish Akshat
From Setback to State Topper: How Ashish Akshat Topped JPSC While Working Full-Time
Ashish Akshat from Dhanbad topped JPSC 2023, proving that resilience, discipline, and family support...
Social Media
Mudumalai Tiger Reserve
Mudumalai Tiger Reserve: From India’s First Sanctuary to a Tiger Conservation Success Story | International Tiger Day Special
IAS Supriya Sahu Hails Mudumalai's Role in Tiger Conservation on Tiger Day. Declared in 1940, Now Among...
Mangroves
Mangroves: Nature’s Shield Against Disasters, Says Officer Parveen Kaswan on Mangroves Day - Watch His Post Here
Mangroves, with their dense, interlaced root systems, form a mesh-like structure that serves as a buffer...
Retired IPS Inderjit Singh Sidhu
Purpose Doesn’t Retire: How 88-Year-Old Retired DIG Becomes Chandigarh’s ‘Quiet Warrior’ of Cleanliness
Inderjit Singh Sidhu’s Dawn Patrol Earns Applause, Mahindra’s Praise for a Man Who Chose Action Over...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
Delhi Metro Rail
DMRC Advances Phase 4 Expansion: Achieves Key Tunnel Breakthrough on Golden Line at Tughlakabad
RLDA
PAC Flags RLDA Over Delayed Land Development: Just 3 of 17 Sites See Progress Despite Decade-Old Handover
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Ananth Rupanagudi IRAS
WhatsApp Image 2025-07-26 at 13.16
WhatsApp Image 2025-07-24 at 18.24
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT