https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Collegium Split Surfaces: Centre Moves Ahead with Justice Pancholi’s Appointment Despite Nagarathna Opposition

Centre advances Justice Vipul Pancholi’s elevation despite Justice BV Nagarathna’s dissent, raising Collegium transparency concerns.
student mental health guidelines
Indian Masterminds Stories

New Delhi: The Central government has decided to move ahead with the elevation of Justice Vipul Pancholi to the Supreme Court, despite strong opposition from Collegium member Justice BV Nagarathna.

Collegium Divide on Elevation

Justice Nagarathna, who is in line to become the Chief Justice of India in 2027, expressed sharp dissent against Justice Pancholi’s appointment. She warned that his elevation could be “counter-productive” to the administration of justice and might undermine the credibility of the Collegium system.

Her note pointed out that Justice Pancholi ranks 57th among High Court judges. She stressed that several more senior judges from different High Courts should be considered before him.

However, the other four Collegium members, Chief Justice of India BR Gavai, Justices Surya Kant, Vikram Nath, and JK Maheshwari supported his elevation, effectively overruling the dissent.

Government Clears Appointment

According to sources, the Centre has already advanced the appointment file for Justices Alok Aradhe and Vipul Pancholi. The file, sent to the Prime Minister’s Office, is now expected to reach Rashtrapati Bhawan for presidential approval.

Officials indicated that the warrants of appointment may be issued before the end of the week.

If confirmed, Justice Pancholi will serve nearly eight years in the Supreme Court, making him one of the longest-serving judges in recent years.

Also Read: Supreme Court Collegium Recommends Elevation of Bombay & Patna Chief Justices to Apex Court

Career Background

Born on May 28, 1968, Justice Vipul Pancholi enrolled as an advocate in September 1991 and practiced at the Gujarat High Court.

He was elevated as an additional judge on October 1, 2014, and confirmed as a permanent judge on June 10, 2016. In July 2023, he was transferred to the Patna High Court, where he currently serves as Chief Justice.

Projected CJI Tenure

Justice Pancholi is expected to become the Chief Justice of India in October 2031 after Justice Joymalya Bagchi’s retirement. He will be the third sitting Supreme Court judge from the Gujarat High Court and is projected to serve as CJI for more than one and a half years.

Transparency Concerns Raised

The resolution dated August 25, recommending Justices Pancholi and Alok Aradhe, did not include Justice Nagarathna’s dissent note. This omission has drawn criticism from the Campaign for Judicial Accountability and Reforms (CJAR).

CJAR flagged three concerns in the resolution: lack of details about the appointees’ backgrounds, absence of the Collegium coram, and no explanation for prioritizing junior judges over seniors.

Justice Nagarathna also referred to the circumstances of Justice Pancholi’s 2023 transfer from the Gujarat High Court to the Patna High Court. She reportedly urged the Collegium to review the confidential minutes of that transfer and requested that her dissent be made public on the Supreme Court’s website.

Also Read: SC Collegium Recommends Elevation of Bombay HC CJ Alok Aradhe and Patna HC CJ Vipul Pancholi to Apex Court


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
Delhi Metro DMRC
DMRC Wins ICI Award 2025 for Outstanding Prestressed Concrete Structure on Maujpur–Majlis Park Corridor
Ayodhya Uttar Pradesh Diwali
Kashi to Reverberate with Music and Dance Ahead of Dev Deepawali: Ganga Mahotsav from November 1–4
Govt
Uttarakhand Govt Transfers 16 IPS and 8 PPS Officers; Major District Chiefs Reassigned - Full List Here
HAL_and_UAC_Sign_MoU_
HAL and Russia’s UAC Join Hands to Manufacture SJ-100 Passenger Aircraft in India under ‘Aatmanirbhar Bharat’
KAATIL
India Takes a Giant Leap with ‘KAATIL’ — A Jet-Powered Loitering Munition Built for Future Wars
8th pay commission
Cabinet Approves ToR for 8th Central Pay Commission; Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai Appointed Chairperson, Recommendations Due in 18 Months
Zero Ka Dum
BPCL Signs Strategic MoUs with OIL, NRL and FACT to Drive Refining, Petrochemicals and Green Energy Growth
IAS Manoj Kumar Das
Who Is IAS Manoj Kumar Das, the New Chief Secretary of Gujarat? – A Technocrat Leader with 30 Years of Service
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IAS Gokul S
Meet IAS Gokul S — The Officer Who Turned Disability into Determination | Video Interview 
WhatsApp Image 2025-10-23 at 10.40
Everybody Needs To Know What Is Transpiring Behind Closed Doors Of Courts
WhatsApp Image 2025-10-19 at 12.23
UPSC Journey Should Be Enjoyable, Not Cumbersome
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
IAS Gokul S
Meet IAS Gokul S — The Officer Who Turned Disability into Determination | Video Interview 
Visually impaired IAS officer Gokul S turned his challenges into change, empowering hundreds through...
Parmeshwar Chaudhary RAS
From Taunts to Triumph: How Farmer’s Son Parmeshwar Chaudhary Rose from Lab Assistant to SDM, Securing Rank 3 in RAS 2023
Parmeshwar, once taunted over his SI selection, has scripted a stunning success—securing Rank 3 in RAS...
IAS Rupal Rana UPSC
How Rupal Rana Cracked UPSC CSE 2023 with AIR 26 After Four Attempts
UPSC Topper Rupal Rana secured AIR 26 in 2023 after four attempts. Learn her preparation strategy, booklist,...
Social Media
Tenzin Yangki IPS Arunachal
Historic First: Who Is Tenzin Yangki, Arunachal Pradesh’s First Woman to Join IPS? Anand Mahindra Hails Her
She secured an impressive 545th rank in the prestigious UPSC Civil Services Examination - 2022.
IFS Parveen Kaswan
Heartbreak by the River: 15-Day-Old Elephant Calf Rejected by Mother, Rescued by IFS Parveen Kaswan and His Team
Jaldapra, West Bengal: In a moving incident that tugs at the heart, a 15-day-old elephant calf was rescued...
Ashwini Bhide IAS and Anand Mahindra
Who Is IAS Ashwini Bhide, Hailed as a Role Model for Mumbai Metro Transformation by Anand Mahindra?
From heritage to high-tech: Bhide’s leadership in Metro Line 3 earns public praise and admiration
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
Delhi Metro DMRC
DMRC Wins ICI Award 2025 for Outstanding Prestressed Concrete Structure on Maujpur–Majlis Park Corridor
Ayodhya Uttar Pradesh Diwali
Kashi to Reverberate with Music and Dance Ahead of Dev Deepawali: Ganga Mahotsav from November 1–4
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IAS Gokul S
WhatsApp Image 2025-10-23 at 10.40
WhatsApp Image 2025-10-19 at 12.23
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT