https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Whither Haloed Institutions of the Country?

Are people losing faith in some of our hallowed institutions? A survey on Twitter threw up some startling answers! While 65% voted in favor of civil servants, media came last with 5%
Indian Masterminds Stories

Twitter surveys have serious limitations but the results still surprised me. It was a survey by me wherein the following question was asked:

According to you, which of the following institutions is carrying out its responsibilities in the best possible manner?

  1. Civil Servants
  2. Judiciary
  3. Politicians
  4. Media

Of more than 3000 participants, 65% voted in favor of Civil Servants, 22% for Judiciary, Politicians 9% and Media was last with 5%.

In the concluding chapter of my book, Ethical Dilemmas of a Civil Servant, I had quoted Gurcharan Das: “Today, our bureaucracy has become the single biggest obstacle to the country’s development. Indians think of the bureaucrats as self-servers, rent seekers, obstructive and corrupt”. This was a comment made by him in his book, India Unbound that was written more than a decade ago. Has the perception changed? It is a moot point. 

ABOUT CIVIL SERVANTS

Even in the Twitter survey, there were a number of comments against the civil servants. One of the hundreds of the comments was pretty damning: “These saviors of nation have the most abhorrent and corrupt behavior. Civil servants are harassers. They are not facilitators”. Still the civil servants walked away with an overwhelming majority of ‘votes’ that were polled. There were some kind comments as well, “I sometime wonder what keeps them motivated inspite of a very difficult and irrational political class”. 

As mentioned earlier, the survey/poll has serious limitations both in terms of sample size and some inherent bias. Hence, the findings have to be taken with a pinch of salt.  Moreover, this is just a comparison of the four institutions and not an endorsement of any ‘good’ work. There is indeed a general cynicism against all the four institutions, the civil servants can perhaps only claim to be not as bad as the others.

There were a large number comments on incorporating an additional option of NOTA (None of the above) that couldn’t be added on account of the limitation imposed by Twitter on the number of choices that is restricted to four. All the institutions were condemned by a number of participants who couldn’t or didn’t vote as the NOTA option was not available. “All the institutions have declined” as one put it. One even went further, “All these failed us as a country but all have failed themselves as well”. Another one called all these institutions “rotten to the core”. This reflects fairly widespread cynicism regarding the institutions that are tasked with managing the country. Given the general cynicism against all the four institutions, civil servants can perhaps only claim to be not as bad as the others.

ABOUT MEDIA 

One could understand politicians being berated because they are the whipping boys almost always though there were some stray positive comments in their case as well. In one of the comments it was stated that “only politicians are doing their job effectively and efficiently”. What was really surprising was how the media was perceived. It seems to have taken serious beating in the recent past and it gets reflected in this survey. In fact, there were some caustic comments as well, “Really wondering who have voted for media” and another one questioning, “Someone voted for media?”.  

In another survey carried out on Twitter, I had quoted the celebrated journalist, Mark Tully from his book India’s Unending Journey, “The media which takes its cue from the West, seems to think its role is to promote aggression and not discussion, and conflict not conversation” and asked, “Is media adding to the narrative of hatred and playing a divisive role?”. Ninety four percent of the respondents answered in the affirmative. The credibility of media has indeed taken a serious beating and that perhaps is the reason why it lies at the bottom of the shack.

ABOUT JUDICIARY

The biggest surprise was the response in the context of Judiciary, normally considered to be the most revered institution in the country and ultimate savior of democracy. Polling only 22% was least expected. Is there a change in perception about this vaunted institution? The answer perhaps lies in another survey carried out on Twitter a few days before this one. In that survey, I had used a quote of a well-known author, Edward Luce, who in his book, Inspite of Gods had observed, “India’s judicial system is supposedly blind, but it often has eyes for rich and powerful”. In the poll, it was asked whether the respondent agreed or not. It brought forth very startling results. Eighty three percent of the respondents agreed that the judiciary has “eyes for rich and powerful”.

WAKE UP CALL FOR ALL 

There were some other very interesting and probably inexplicable findings in the survey. A number of aspirants for civil service also commented that they would opt for NOTA and also condemned the performance of the civil service. The question still to be answered is why were they joining the civil service if they thought that civil service was making no contribution? Was it on account of their desire to correct it if they managed to become a civil servant or, are they following the dictum, can’t beat them, so join them? Perhaps they would know the answer

Whatever be the case, the message from this survey is loud and clear. One institution may be doing better that the other. One may have undergone a decline, and the other may have apparently improved on account of greater decline of others. It is no cause to celebrate. Each institution needs to deeply introspect as there is enormous cynicism on account of their perceived or real indifference. Whether one agrees with this poll or not, there is scope for huge improvement in the functioning of each of these institutions tasked with serving the country.


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
Civil Services Day 2025 Awards by PM Modi
Civil Services Day 25: 16 IAS Officers Honoured for Excellence in Public Administration - Know More About Them
Civil Services Day 2025 Awards IAS officers
Civil Services Day 25: Inspired by PM’s Vision - Awarded IAS Officers Share Stories of Grassroots Impact
MTNL
MTNL Defaults on Loans Worth Rs. 8,346 Crore; Total Debt Climbs to Rs. 33,568 Crore
Gujarat-government resized
4 IAS Officers Assigned Additional Charges in Gujarat, Ajay Prakash Given Additional Charge As MD, Uttar Gujarat Vij Company Ltd
Punjab_govt_resized
3 IAS & 9 PCS Officers Transferred in Punjab, Sanyam Aggarwal Given Additional Charge As Special Secy, Health and Family Welfare
DGP OM Praksh with his wife1
Retired Karnataka DGP Om Prakash Murdered; Family Dispute or Mental Illness, What Prompted the Homicide?
LIC resized
Pradip Kusum Joseph Dungdung Takes Charge as LIC's Additional Executive Director (Engineering)
IRCTC
Rabindra Nath Mishra to Continue as Director (Finance), IRCTC - Know About Him
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Dr Lokesh M IAS
E-Rickshaw Chaos, Waterlogging, Traffic Mess — Can Noida Fix Its Daily Chaos? | Exclusive with Dr Lokesh M, IAS
IRS Padmapani Bora UPSC
IRS Padmapani Bora’s 16-Year-Long Journey in Governance
WhatsApp Image 2025-04-13 at 1.46
This Collector Finds Happiness In Squeaks Of Children With Hearing Impairment Who Start Hearing After Surgery
UPSC Stories
images (14)
Utsav Anand, the UPSC Topper Who Chose Public Service Over a Plush Career
From IIT Bombay to the 2022 IAS batch (Haryana cadre), Utsav Anand’s journey is proof that sharp minds...
pushplata-yadav-ias
How IAS Pushp Lata’s Strategy and Spirit Took Her to AIR 80
From rural Haryana to IAS, Pushp Lata Yadav’s journey reflects focused planning, adaptation, and the...
IRS Padmapani Bora UPSC
IRS Padmapani Bora’s 16-Year-Long Journey in Governance
IRS officer Padmapani Bora's 16-year career transcends typical bureaucracy. Discover his surprising journey...
Social Media
GozJlgrXYAAHoKv
Murals for Cleanliness: Thoothukudi District Launches Art-Inspired Sanitation Drive in Panchayats
Local artists add colour and messages to village walls, promoting hygiene and community pride
Himanshu Nagpal IAS
Varanasi's Beggar Rehabilitation Initiative Recognised by UIDAI, CDO Himanshu Nagpal Shares the News
Mr. Himanshu Nagpal is a 2019-batch IAS officer
IAS Vaishali Chopra
Young IAS Vaishali Chopra Takes a Stand Against Caste Bias During Field Training in Uttar Pradesh
While the issue itself may seem small, the post is resonating widely online for its honest reflection...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
Civil Services Day 2025 Awards by PM Modi
Civil Services Day 25: 16 IAS Officers Honoured for Excellence in Public Administration - Know More About Them
Civil Services Day 2025 Awards IAS officers
Civil Services Day 25: Inspired by PM’s Vision - Awarded IAS Officers Share Stories of Grassroots Impact
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Dr Lokesh M IAS
IRS Padmapani Bora UPSC
WhatsApp Image 2025-04-13 at 1.46
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT