https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

How Justified is Lateral Entry, Veterans Comment

Indian Masterminds Stories

Recently, Mr. Jitendra Singh, the Minister of State for Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT), raised the issue of streamlining IAS appointments in Parliament. According to an order of the DoPT, only 33 of the 73 appointments made by the Union government in the past four weeks were of IAS officers. This means that majority of appointments were of non-IAS officers.  

Although the central government has brought a training program to promote non-IAS officers to the ranks of joint secretaries, directors and deputy directors, this has created a debate as to whether it is right to appoint non-IAS in such high positions, especially to the rank of a Joint Secretary. 

Indian Masterminds spoke to few retired civil servants who had held very senior positions during their time, to know about their opinions on this matter, and this is what they had to say. 

PREVIOUS GOVTS ARE TO BE BLAMED 

Retired IAS officer of UP cadre, Mr. Vijay Shankar Pandey, said that posts are vacant and there are no officers available to be appointed. He attributed this situation to the previous governments. 

“All this has happened because of the mistakes that previous governments committed. During 1900s, the government cut down the number of IAS and it continued. They were lacking in vision for the future and that is why this situation has arisen,” he said.

He further said that previously also, people from other central services were given these posts, and there is nothing wrong in it. “Hiring must be done based on the capabilities, merits and talents. Ultimately the country should be in a better position. Nothing else matters.” 

Alok Ranjan, Ex-IAS

Former Chief Secretary of UP, Mr. Alok Ranjan, also holds a somewhat similar opinion. However, he adds a word of caution: “It is okay till the officers are taken from the centralised forces. The government should not take people from outside. If they need to, they should hire for specific task only, and aim for people with special skill and expertise in that area. However, it should be a general practise only, not for a high position like a Joint Secretary, as it is an important position for IAS cadre.”

He also said that if the government is facing lack of officers for suitable positions, then they should increase the intake of the IAS officers. 

LATERAL ENTRY IS NOT WRONG

Retired IPS officer and Former DGP of Uttarakhand, Mr. Anil Raturi, doesn’t find any problem in lateral entry. He said, “It is completely fine. If people are talented, then they could be assigned tasks. Cadre or services should not act as a barrier. Besides, the government has a full-fledged procedure to hire anybody.”

MID-TERM EVALUATION IS REQUIRED 

Retired IAS officer Rohit Nandan

However, retired IAS officer and former CMD of Air-India, Mr. Rohit Nandan opposes this type of entry and wants the focus to be on evaluation, instead. He said, “I think it is a foolish concept. The services of experts have always been available to the government through consultants and advisors. The only change is that, in this new dispensation, the experts have to record their advice on files and take responsibility for it. It’s worth examination what has actually happened on the files dealt with by these Joint Secretaries, and whether they initiated any proposal at their level for decision making. I am personally of the opinion that a mid-term evaluation of the success of this experiment should be carried out by a genuine external agency to arrive at any conclusion about the performance of the scheme.”

As far as the impact on the IAS cadre is concerned, he feels that it has had a minimal effect and the dominance of the regular bureaucracy has not changed. “You might be aware that some lateral appointees have quit because they felt that the system refused to accept them,” he said in conclusion.


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
SJVN
Leadership Continuity: Rajendra Prasad Goyal Given Additional Charge as Director (Finance) of SJVN Ltd- Know more about Him
government-of-haryana
Haryana Government Transfers 2 IPS, 13 HPS Officers in Major Police Reshuffle- Check Details
scam
‘Hello, This is IPS Officer Speaking…’: 9th-Pass Youth Tricks Cops in Three States with Fake Voice Scam
Screenshot 2025-07-18 214334
L&T Chairman Mr. S.N. Subrahmanyan’s FY25 Remuneration Jumps Nearly 50% to Rs. 76.25 Crore!
bureaucracy news
Appointments Update: IRS Kommisetty Murlidhar to Join Andhra Govt; Jay Nath Yadav Inducted into IAS
Indian Overseas Bank (IOB)
Indian Overseas Bank Plans Rs. 4,000 Crore Fundraising via QIP; Net Profit Soars 76% in Q1 FY26
Paresh Saxena IPS
IPS Officer Dr Paresh Saxena Protests Empanelment Denial, Returns President’s Distinguished Service Medal
Screenshot 2025-07-18 212145
Chhattisgarh: CM Vishnu Deo Sai Unveils ‘Anjor Vision @ 2047’ - A Bold Roadmap for a Developed Future!
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
promila gupta
The Secret of The Secret – How To Make The Universe Conspire For You
AI 171 CRASH
AAIB Initial Probe In AI-171 Crash Questioned By Aviation Experts
Ravi Kapoor
Why Ex-IRS Officer Ravi Kapoor Walked Away from Power
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
Bhavesh Royada
“People often don’t put in the effort required for exams of this level,” Bhavesh Royada
Bhavesh Royada left a stable engineering job to follow his passion for nature. Overcoming failures and...
WhatsApp Image 2025-07-14 at 15.58
The Economist Who Became an IFS Officer
How Abhimanyu Gahlaut balanced global economics and civil services dreams to crack UPSC with AIR 38
Disha Dwivedi UPSC
How Disha Dwivedi Cracked UPSC in Her Sixth Attempt with Unshakable Determination
Disha Dwivedi’s UPSC journey from five prelims failures to securing AIR 672 in 2024 showcases strategic...
Social Media
Screenshot 2025-07-18 203508
Majestic Tiger Rescue and Release in Sundarbans Captivates the Internet: IFS Susanta Nanda Shares Video On X
The video captures the tiger’s strength, agility, and instinct—a breathtaking sight as the big cat slices...
Standing Leopard
Leopard Stuns Internet by Standing on Two Legs Like a Meerkat
A rare video of a leopard standing on two legs in Kruger Park stuns viewers and goes viral across social...
G S Roshni
Kerala’s Fearless Forest Officer G.S. Roshni Rescues 16-Foot King Cobra with Bare Hands, Garners Praise & Critique
Beat Forest Officer G.S. Roshni’s first-ever king cobra rescue goes viral, earning her the title of ‘Green...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
SJVN
Leadership Continuity: Rajendra Prasad Goyal Given Additional Charge as Director (Finance) of SJVN Ltd- Know more about Him
government-of-haryana
Haryana Government Transfers 2 IPS, 13 HPS Officers in Major Police Reshuffle- Check Details
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
promila gupta
AI 171 CRASH
Ravi Kapoor
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT