https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Centre’s 360° appraisal system to assess IAS officers is valid: Madras HC

Declaring Mr. Kataria's plea as illegal, Justices V.M. Velumani and V. Lakshminarayanan dismissed his writ petition. The judges though did not impose costs on the petitioner “since an interesting question of law had been framed and argued.
Indian Masterminds Stories

The Madras High Court has dismissed a writ petition filed by IAS officer Dayanand Kataria and upheld the validity of the Centre’s 360-degree appraisal/multi-source feedback system for appraising the performance of all Indian Administrative Service officers, in State government service, for empanelment so that they could apply for vacancies that arise under the Government of India (GoI).

Declaring Mr. Kataria’s plea as illegal, Justices V.M. Velumani and V. Lakshminarayanan dismissed his writ petition.

The judges though did not impose costs on the petitioner “since an interesting question of law had been framed and argued”.

Mr. Kataria of the 1989 batch of Tamil Nadu cadre was empaneled to serve at the Joint Secretary level under the GoI in 2012. Such empanelment then took place by assessing performance in terms of the 1996 office memorandum issued by the Union Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions.

He was due for empanelment as an Additional Secretary and then Secretary in the subsequent years. 

However, after the Centre made changes in assessment rules in 2016, Mr. Kataria lost his chances.

With the introduction of the multi-source feedback system, the government elicited opinions about individual officers from seniors, peers, juniors, external stakeholders, and serving secretaries.

Mr. Kataria then approached the court to declare the 360-degree appraisal system as “illegal, void and to be in violation of the principles of natural justice. 

The Division Bench said it did not find any illegality in the Centre’s deciding to assess an officer’s performance by looking beyond his/her Annual Confidential Report (ACR).

“If an employer wants certain qualities in its employees, especially at the senior level, it cannot be said to be arbitrary,” the bench said. 

Under the 360-degree rule, an expert committee is constituted to receive inputs about an officer from his seniors, peers and juniors on well-defined attributes such as decisiveness and quality of work; willingness to take responsibility and moral courage; innovativeness, initiation, and risk-taking abilities; patience and problem-solving skills; being a team player and so on. 

By no stretch of imagination can it be said that these are vague, the said. “Furthermore, as submitted by the learned Additional Solicitor General AR.L. Sundaresan, the report of the expert committee is not final,” the bench added.

Announcing the verdict, Justice Lakshminarayanan pointed out that the expert committee’s report was only an additional input and not the be-all and end-all with respect to empanelment. 

There was also a separate review panel for independent assessment. This Special Committee of Secretaries (SCOS) assists the Cabinet Secretary in reviewing the matter and placing it before the Cabinet Committee on Appointments, which has the final authority on empanelment. 

“Therefore, the fear of the writ petitioner that the expert panel could act in an arbitrary manner has also been resolved,” the bench said.

The judges concluded by saying: “While eligibility may be matter of judicial review, suitability certainly is not. In which manner and how the government identifies those suitable for its needs is not judicially reviewable unless it is arbitrary and violative of the Constitution or the statutory rules.”


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
NTPC_Barauni_signed_agreement_
NTPC Barauni to Install 89 High-Mast Lights Across Begusarai to Boost Safety and Community Development
BPCL_bags_Excellence_Awards_
BPCL Wins Top Honours for City Gas Distribution and Customer Service at 19th PNGRB Foundation Day
Allahabad high court
SC Collegium Approves Appointment of Vinai Kumar Dwivedi as Judge of Allahabad High Court
JK Cement Health Camp Panna
Free Health Camp Organised for Forest Personnel During Wildlife Week 2025 by South Panna Forest Division
REC Mobile Medical Units
Union Minister Bhupender Yadav Flags Off REC’s ₹5.71 Cr Mobile Medical Units to Boost Rural Healthcare in Rajasthan
BSNL
Indigenous 5G Coming Soon: BSNL’s 4G Network to Be Upgraded to 5G Within 6–8 Months
Punjab and Sind Bank
Result: Punjab & Sind Bank Reports 16% Loan Growth in Q2 FY26, Business Crosses ₹2.4 Lakh Crore
Namchik Namphuk coal mine
Arunachal Pradesh’s First Commercial Coal Mine Inaugurated at Namchik Namphuk by Union Minister G. Kishan Reddy
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IDES Saquib Alam
UPSC Strategy & Mindset Tips from IDES Officer Saquib Alam | Video Interview 
Dr G K Goswami IPS
Everything you ever wanted to know about e-murder, e-dacoity and data safety
IFS Ravikant Meena UPSC IFS
Ravikant Meena on IFS Preparation, Optionals, and Life in Forest Service
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
IDES Saquib Alam
UPSC Strategy & Mindset Tips from IDES Officer Saquib Alam | Video Interview 
Discover how IDES officer Saquib Alam left his corporate job at Mahindra, overcame six UPSC attempts,...
Utkarsh Ujjwal IAS
IAS Utkarsh Ujjwal Shares Key Advice for UPSC Aspirants: Work Ethic, Failure, and Focus
Read the inspiring journey of IAS Utkarsh Ujjwal, 2023 batch, Gujarat cadre. From IIT Guwahati to clearing...
Sagar Datta Majumdar UPSC CSE 2024 AIR 317
“Don’t get trapped in the vicious cycle of self-doubt,” says UPSC Achiever Sagar Datta Majumdar
Discover how Sagar Datta Majumdar from Agartala, Tripura, cracked UPSC CSE 2024 with All India Rank 317....
Social Media
World Rhino Day India
On World Rhino Day, IFS Officer Parveen Kaswan Shares Rare Insights - India Now Hosts 80% of the World’s One-Horned Rhinos
September 22 Marks Global Call for Rhino Conservation; India Holds 80% of World’s Greater One-Horned...
Parag Madhukar Dhakate
Relentless Rains Wreak Havoc in Dehradun: IFS officer PM Dhakate Warns Citizens Amid Flash Floods
Cloudbursts in Dehradun triggered flash floods. IFS officer Dr. PM Dhakate warned citizens to stay indoors...
Forest Guard Tiger Encounter
Tigers Clash in the Wild as Forest Guards Capture Rare Footage , Retired IFS Mohan Pargaien Posts Viral Video
Retired IFS officer Mohan Pargaien shares viral video of three tigers brawling in Ramnagar, as forest...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
NTPC_Barauni_signed_agreement_
NTPC Barauni to Install 89 High-Mast Lights Across Begusarai to Boost Safety and Community Development
BPCL_bags_Excellence_Awards_
BPCL Wins Top Honours for City Gas Distribution and Customer Service at 19th PNGRB Foundation Day
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IDES Saquib Alam
Dr G K Goswami IPS
IFS Ravikant Meena UPSC IFS
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT