https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Haryana Government Faces Legal Scrutiny Over Appointment of Retired IPS Officer R C Mishra as Police Complaints Authority Chairperson – Know the Matter

Legal experts argue that the appointment contradicts the Supreme Court’s directive, which mandates that the Chairperson of the State Police Complaints Authority must be a retired judge of the High Court or Supreme Court
Indian Masterminds Stories

The recent appointment of a retired IPS officer as Chairperson of the Haryana State Police Complaints Authority has stirred a legal and administrative debate, with concerns raised over the violation of Supreme Court guidelines issued in the landmark Prakash Singh vs. Union of India (2006) judgment on police reforms.

Also Read: MP: Rail Coach Factory in Raisen to Create 5,000+ Jobs, Boost Swadeshi Manufacturing

In an official order issued on Friday, Dr. Sumita Mishra, Home Secretary of Haryana, announced the appointment of Mr. R.C. Mishra, a 1989-batch retired IPS officer, as the Chairperson of the State-Level Police Complaints Authority, and Mr. Lalit Siwach, a 2014-batch retired IAS officer, as a member.

Violation of Supreme Court Directives?

Legal experts argue that the appointment contradicts the Supreme Court’s directive, which mandates that the Chairperson of the State Police Complaints Authority must be a retired judge of the High Court or Supreme Court. The directive, stemming from the Prakash Singh judgment of September 2006, is considered the cornerstone of police reform in India.

“The law is clear. A retired High Court or Supreme Court judge must head the State Police Complaints Authority. Retired IAS and IPS officers can only be appointed as members, not as the chairperson,” said Mr. Hemant Kumar, advocate at the Punjab and Haryana High Court.

Previous Legal Precedents

The issue is not new. In August 2015, the Punjab and Haryana High Court had quashed the appointment of Mr. Pradeep Mehra, a 1975-batch retired IAS officer, as Chairperson of the Chandigarh UT Police Complaints Authority, citing the same Supreme Court guidelines.

Following that, the administration appointed retired High Court Justice Mahavir Singh Chauhan in 2017 and more recently Justice Kuldeep Singh in December 2023 to ensure compliance.

Pattern of Non-Compliance in Haryana

This is not the first instance of Haryana appointing retired civil servants instead of judges to the post of Chairperson:

  • In April 2021, Ms. Navraj Sandhu, a retired IAS officer, was appointed as Chairperson.
  • In February 2019, Mr. Ram Niwas, another retired IAS officer, was appointed to the same post.
  • The 2010 authority also saw Mr. H.S. Rana, retired IAS, appointed as Chairperson.

Legal observers point out that this continued deviation from the Supreme Court’s directions undermines the credibility and independence of the complaint redressal mechanism.

Advocate: Appointment Legally Challengeable

Mr. Hemant Kumar has stated that the latest appointment of Mr. R.C. Mishra could be legally challenged in the High Court, as it clearly violates the framework set by the Supreme Court.

“If the state wishes to follow the law in spirit, a panel of retired judges must be sought from the Chief Justice of the High Court. Only a retired judge can serve as chairperson, while IAS and IPS officers may serve as members,” he added.

What the Law Prescribes

As per the Supreme Court ruling, the structure of the State Police Complaints Authority should include:

  • A retired judge of the High Court or Supreme Court as Chairperson.
  • Up to two other members, one of whom must be a woman.
  • At the district level, the Chairperson must be a retired district judge.

Government Yet to Respond

As of now, the Haryana Government has not issued any clarification on the legal concerns raised. The appointments could potentially face judicial scrutiny if challenged by concerned parties or civil society groups in the High Court.

With growing emphasis on transparency and police accountability, adherence to judicial mandates becomes crucial to ensure public trust in oversight mechanisms. The coming weeks may determine whether Haryana stands by its decision or reconsiders in light of legal and constitutional obligations.

Also Read: Madhya Pradesh to Boost Swadeshi, Industrial Growth, and Public Welfare Initiatives – All Details Inside


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
Two crossed national flags on wooden table
India Doesn’t Owe Trump a 'Thank You': Ex-IAS Sanjay Dixit Rejects Mediation Gratitude
ChhattisgarhGovt_resized
Chhattisgarh to Launch ‘Gaudham Yojana’ for Livestock Protection and Rural Empowerment - Details Inside
Haryana gov resized
Haryana Government Faces Legal Scrutiny Over Appointment of Retired IPS Officer R C Mishra as Police Complaints Authority Chairperson - Know the Matter
BEML Limited
BEML Secures First-Ever International Contract in Rail & Metro Segment - Details Inside
NCL
NCL Honoured with “Coal India Productivity Award” at National Convention - Details Inside
Rakesh Singh IPS News
Retired IPS Officer Rakesh Singh Loses Legal Battle to His Lawyer Daughter in Allahabad High Court – Calls It His “Proudest Moment”
V Vualnam IAS
ICoAS Foundation Day 2025 Celebrated with Focus on ‘SAM@₹TH भारत’ Vision - Details Inside
Rashmi Karandikar Husband
Senior IPS Officer Rashmi Karandikar Under Scrutiny for Undisclosed Rs. 2.64 Crore Transaction - Know More
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
WhatsApp Image 2025-08-08 at 5.25
Dharavi Redevelopment: IAS Minds Turning 100-Year-Old Slum into a Modern City | Video Interview
IAS Aditya Singh
How IAS Officer Aditya Singh is Redefining Governance in Madhya Pradesh | Video Interview 
IAS Karn Satyarthi
How IAS Karn Satyarthi Transformed Gumla Through Empathy and Innovation
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
Manoj Kumar Gupta BPSC
‘I Missed My Kids’ Childhood for This Rank’ - A Father’s Journey to Success in BPSC
Manoj Kumar Gupta, once a poor boy from Buxar, cracked the 64th BPSC exam while raising two kids and...
BPSC Bihar police
From Lantern Light to Police Uniform: How Praveen Kumar from a Small Bihar Village Cracked BPSC to Become SDPO
From a lantern-lit village in Bihar to becoming an SDPO, Praveen Kumar's journey is a testament to resilience,...
IAS Priyansha Garg
Why Mindset Matters: IAS Priyansha Garg’s Mental Health Mantra for UPSC
After two failed prelims, Priyansha Garg cracked UPSC with AIR 31 in her fourth attempt, proving how...
Social Media
FEMINA
Women Warriors on the Cover: Femina India Celebrates Army’s Finest in August 2025 Special - Watch the Cover Shoot Inside
Femina India’s August 2025 cover pays tribute to ten Indian Army women officers, showcasing courage,...
Raksha Bandhan Special
A Promise Never Broken: Sister Ties Rakhi to Martyred Brother’s Statue Each Year | Rakshabandhan Special
In Rajasthan’s Khudiyala village, a sister keeps her martyred brother’s memory alive by tying rakhi to...
Mudumalai Tiger Reserve
Mudumalai Tiger Reserve: From India’s First Sanctuary to a Tiger Conservation Success Story | International Tiger Day Special
IAS Supriya Sahu Hails Mudumalai's Role in Tiger Conservation on Tiger Day. Declared in 1940, Now Among...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
Two crossed national flags on wooden table
India Doesn’t Owe Trump a 'Thank You': Ex-IAS Sanjay Dixit Rejects Mediation Gratitude
ChhattisgarhGovt_resized
Chhattisgarh to Launch ‘Gaudham Yojana’ for Livestock Protection and Rural Empowerment - Details Inside
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
WhatsApp Image 2025-08-08 at 5.25
IAS Aditya Singh
IAS Karn Satyarthi
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT