https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

SC Raps Allahabad High Court Over Witness Protection Misuse, Says Bail Cancellation Principles Cannot Be Ignored

Supreme Court criticises Allahabad HC for copy-paste orders treating witness protection as bail substitute, orders corrective steps.
Indian Masterminds Stories

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has strongly criticised the Allahabad High Court for routinely passing template orders that treat the Witness Protection Scheme, 2018 as a substitute for bail cancellation. The apex court warned that such practices undermine established legal principles and dilute judicial authority.

A bench of Justices J B Pardiwala and Sandeep Mehta expressed concern over the repetitive nature of orders issued by the High Court. It noted that at least 40 such orders were passed in the past year alone, many of them verbatim copies, continuing a trend observed for more than two years.

Bench Rejects ‘Template’ Approach

According to the Supreme Court, the High Court wrongly viewed the scheme as an alternative remedy. “We are at pains to note that we came across at least 40 recent orders … as per the records available from the official website of the Allahabad High Court,” the bench remarked.

The judges said public prosecutors also failed in their duty by advising complainants to seek protection under the 2018 scheme, rather than pressing for cancellation of bail, even in cases where accused persons allegedly threatened or intimidated witnesses.

Case That Triggered SC’s Intervention

The case before the Court was filed by Phireram, who had sought cancellation of bail for accused persons in a murder case, alleging threats to his life. The Allahabad High Court dismissed his plea and instead directed him to seek protection under the Witness Protection Scheme.

The Supreme Court set aside that order, terming it “very curious,” and sent the matter back to the High Court for hearing on its merits. It held that bail cancellation must be decided by applying settled principles, not by diverting complainants to the protection scheme.

Also Read: Supreme Court Rebukes Allahabad HC Over 43 Bail Adjournments, Emphasises Urgency in Liberty Case

Witness Protection vs Bail Cancellation

The bench clarified that the Witness Protection Scheme was never intended to replace provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure or the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 in bail matters. While the scheme ensures security for threatened witnesses, bail cancellation is preventive, ensuring that accused persons do not misuse liberty to obstruct justice.

The judges explained that bail comes with serious obligations under Sections 437(3) and 439(2) CrPC. Substituting these with a protective mechanism, they said, makes bail conditions meaningless. The scheme, they added, applies to grave offences like those punishable with death, life imprisonment, or imprisonment of seven years or more, but cannot be used as a universal solution in all cases.

SC Orders Corrective Steps

The Court stressed that both bail cancellation and witness protection serve distinct but complementary purposes to ensure fair trials. The bench directed circulation of its ruling to all High Courts, and specifically to the Chief Justice of the Allahabad High Court, to ensure corrective measures.

Also Read: Supreme Court Urges Fast-Track NIA Courts to Prevent Criminals Exploiting Trial Delays to Secure a Bail


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
MRPL
MRPL Honoured for Outstanding WASH Initiatives at FKCCI CSR & Sustainability Awards 2025
Pushkar Singh Dhami
CM Dhami Hands Over Appointment Letters to 15 Teachers, Launches ₹15 Crore Tribal Welfare Projects in Uttarakhand
Punjab Forest Dept
Ludhiana Forest Dept Probes Illegal Felling of Fully Grown Trees Near Ghuman Chowk, DFO Rajesh Gulati Orders Inquiry
Fake IAS Saurabh Tripathi
Lucknow Fake IAS Scandal: Saurabh Tripathi Took 'Contracts' for Transfers; Secretary Arrested, Probe Widens to Real Officers
Madhya Pradesh farmer relief
MP: CM Mohan Yadav Transfers ₹20.6 Crore Relief to 17,500 Farmers Across 11 Districts- Know More
V.O
VOC Port Launches India’s First Port-Based Green Hydrogen Project, Signs MoUs with NTPC Green Energy & IPRCL
Karnataka Forest Department
Shivamogga Forest Raid: Three Suspected Poachers Arrested, Firearm and Vehicle Seized in Malnad Reserve
UP transport projects
UP: CM Yogi Adityanath Launches 400 New Buses and 25 Transport Projects to Boost Road Safety & Green Mobility
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IPS Shikha Goel
Decoding Digital Dangers: Insights from IPS Shikha Goel on Cyber Crimes
IPS Mukesh Kumar Bhamoo
Managing Elections, Communal Tensions, and Public Safety – Meet IPS Mukesh Kumar Bhamoo | Video Interview
WhatsApp Image 2025-08-25 at 13.56
Operation Hunt: IPS Dr. Karanraj Vaghela’s Mission to Nab Valsad’s Most Wanted
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
Ishwarlal Gurjar UPSC
10th Grade Failure to Indian Police Service: Ishwarlal Gurjar’s UPSC Success Path
Read the inspiring journey of Ishwarlal Gurjar from a small village in Rajasthan to becoming an IPS officer....
IAS Minnu P M
“Lazy, Sleepy, Yet Determined”: Minnu P M’s Honest Take on Cracking UPSC
Minnu PM, once a clerk in Kerala Police, cleared UPSC with AIR 150 after five years of struggle. Her...
IPS Ashish Tiwari
From IIT and Investment Banking to Public Service, Meet IPS Ashish Tiwari 
Ashish Tiwari, IIT graduate and former investment banker, chose public service over global finance. As...
Social Media
IAS Sakshi Sawhney Amritsar DC
Punjab Floods: IAS Sakshi Sawhney’s Emotional Appeal to Elderly Man Wins Hearts, Video of Humanity Goes Viral
Viral Video Captures Emotional Moment as Amritsar DC Shows Sensitivity and Courage Amid Relief Effor...
Masahiro Hara
From Go Board to Global Use, How QR Codes Changed the World: IRAS Officer Ananth Rupanagudi Spotlights Masahiro Hara’s Vision
IRAS officer Ananth Rupanagudi shared a video on Masahiro Hara, the inventor of QR codes, highlighting...
IFS Susanta Nanda Video
A Mother’s Duty: Tigress Watches Over Cubs Splashing in Waterhole — Heartwarming Video Shared By Retd. IFS Officer Susanta Nanda
A tender wildlife video shared by Retd. IFS officer Susanta Nanda shows a tigress keeping watch over...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
MRPL
MRPL Honoured for Outstanding WASH Initiatives at FKCCI CSR & Sustainability Awards 2025
Pushkar Singh Dhami
CM Dhami Hands Over Appointment Letters to 15 Teachers, Launches ₹15 Crore Tribal Welfare Projects in Uttarakhand
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IPS Shikha Goel
IPS Mukesh Kumar Bhamoo
WhatsApp Image 2025-08-25 at 13.56
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT