https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

SC Raps Allahabad High Court Over Witness Protection Misuse, Says Bail Cancellation Principles Cannot Be Ignored

Supreme Court criticises Allahabad HC for copy-paste orders treating witness protection as bail substitute, orders corrective steps.
Indian Masterminds Stories

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has strongly criticised the Allahabad High Court for routinely passing template orders that treat the Witness Protection Scheme, 2018 as a substitute for bail cancellation. The apex court warned that such practices undermine established legal principles and dilute judicial authority.

A bench of Justices J B Pardiwala and Sandeep Mehta expressed concern over the repetitive nature of orders issued by the High Court. It noted that at least 40 such orders were passed in the past year alone, many of them verbatim copies, continuing a trend observed for more than two years.

Bench Rejects ‘Template’ Approach

According to the Supreme Court, the High Court wrongly viewed the scheme as an alternative remedy. “We are at pains to note that we came across at least 40 recent orders … as per the records available from the official website of the Allahabad High Court,” the bench remarked.

The judges said public prosecutors also failed in their duty by advising complainants to seek protection under the 2018 scheme, rather than pressing for cancellation of bail, even in cases where accused persons allegedly threatened or intimidated witnesses.

Case That Triggered SC’s Intervention

The case before the Court was filed by Phireram, who had sought cancellation of bail for accused persons in a murder case, alleging threats to his life. The Allahabad High Court dismissed his plea and instead directed him to seek protection under the Witness Protection Scheme.

The Supreme Court set aside that order, terming it “very curious,” and sent the matter back to the High Court for hearing on its merits. It held that bail cancellation must be decided by applying settled principles, not by diverting complainants to the protection scheme.

Also Read: Supreme Court Rebukes Allahabad HC Over 43 Bail Adjournments, Emphasises Urgency in Liberty Case

Witness Protection vs Bail Cancellation

The bench clarified that the Witness Protection Scheme was never intended to replace provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure or the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 in bail matters. While the scheme ensures security for threatened witnesses, bail cancellation is preventive, ensuring that accused persons do not misuse liberty to obstruct justice.

The judges explained that bail comes with serious obligations under Sections 437(3) and 439(2) CrPC. Substituting these with a protective mechanism, they said, makes bail conditions meaningless. The scheme, they added, applies to grave offences like those punishable with death, life imprisonment, or imprisonment of seven years or more, but cannot be used as a universal solution in all cases.

SC Orders Corrective Steps

The Court stressed that both bail cancellation and witness protection serve distinct but complementary purposes to ensure fair trials. The bench directed circulation of its ruling to all High Courts, and specifically to the Chief Justice of the Allahabad High Court, to ensure corrective measures.

Also Read: Supreme Court Urges Fast-Track NIA Courts to Prevent Criminals Exploiting Trial Delays to Secure a Bail


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
Union Minister Hardeep Singh Puri
Govt Slams Undervaluation of Oil PSUs Despite ₹2.5 Lakh Cr Profit, Rules Out BPCL Sale: Hardeep Singh Puri
BEML Limited
BEML Strengthens Defence Portfolio with Tripartite Pact for AMCA Program Amid Stock Market Dip
RITES ..
RITES Secures $18 Million Locomotives Order from Talis Logistics, South Africa
Bank_of_Baroda_signs_MoU_
Bank of Baroda Partners with Tata Power Renewable Energy to Finance Solar Projects for MSMEs and C&I Customers
IAF
MoU Signed Between IAF and IIT Ropar for Development of Indigenous Weapon System Solutions
REC Corporate Communicator
REC’s Irfan Rashid Wins Chanakya Jury Special Award for Promising Corporate Communicator of the Year
Central_Coalfield_Limited_logo
Western Coalfields’ Anup Hanjura Recommended as Next Director (Technical) of Central Coalfields Limited
BSNL
BSNL to Activate 4G Network at 6,659 Sites Across Uttar Pradesh; PM Modi to Unveil ‘Swadeshi’ 4G Stack
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Siddhartha Saxena UPSC CAPF
How Siddhartha Saxena Cracked UPSC CAPF AIR 326 Against All Odds
Dr. S.K
Technology Meets Ecology: IFS Dr S K Srivastava’s Game-Changing Innovations in Forest Management | Eco Warrior Awards 2025 Interview
IFS Uttam Kumar Sharma Interview
From Extinction to Exhilaration: The Untold Story and Future Vision of Project Cheetah | Led by IFS Uttam Kumar Sharma | Eco Warrior Awards 2025
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
Abhay Daga IPS UPSC Success Story
IIT Graduate, Microsoft Alum, Actor, to Cracking UPSC CSE: The Story of Abhay Daga
Read the inspiring journey of Abhay Daga, an IIT graduate, Microsoft alum, and actor, who cleared UPSC...
Rishav Awasthi MPPSC Risabh Awasthi MPPCS
Family’s Dream, His Determination: How Small-Town Dreamer Rishav Awasthi Conquered MPPSC 2024 with Rank 2 | Exclusive
After two failed attempts, Rishav Awasthi secured Rank 2 in MPPSC 2024, driven by family support, self-study,...
Harshita Dave MPPSC 2024
The Girl Who Turned Dreams Into a Deputy Collector Post at 22: Meet MPPSC 2024 Women Topper Harshita Dave
At just 22, Harshita Dave topped MPPSC 2024, becoming the women topper and securing Rank 5. Her journey...
Social Media
World Rhino Day India
On World Rhino Day, IFS Officer Parveen Kaswan Shares Rare Insights - India Now Hosts 80% of the World’s One-Horned Rhinos
September 22 Marks Global Call for Rhino Conservation; India Holds 80% of World’s Greater One-Horned...
Parag Madhukar Dhakate
Relentless Rains Wreak Havoc in Dehradun: IFS officer PM Dhakate Warns Citizens Amid Flash Floods
Cloudbursts in Dehradun triggered flash floods. IFS officer Dr. PM Dhakate warned citizens to stay indoors...
Forest Guard Tiger Encounter
Tigers Clash in the Wild as Forest Guards Capture Rare Footage , Retired IFS Mohan Pargaien Posts Viral Video
Retired IFS officer Mohan Pargaien shares viral video of three tigers brawling in Ramnagar, as forest...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
Union Minister Hardeep Singh Puri
Govt Slams Undervaluation of Oil PSUs Despite ₹2.5 Lakh Cr Profit, Rules Out BPCL Sale: Hardeep Singh Puri
BEML Limited
BEML Strengthens Defence Portfolio with Tripartite Pact for AMCA Program Amid Stock Market Dip
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Siddhartha Saxena UPSC CAPF
Dr. S.K
IFS Uttam Kumar Sharma Interview
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT