https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

The Lurking Fear All Around

The western world has questioned democracy in the largest democracy of the world The Opposition is now taking the moral high ground on the basis of these reports Let us examine dispassionately where does the country stand in the context of democracy
Indian Masterminds Stories

“When Yog becomes Yoga, it gets to be recognized in the country of origin.” I had tweeted this some time ago to highlight the fact that we are so obsessed with western endorsements that we look for such certificates to validate our point of view or practice. This is true even now. We went hammer and tongs to get a certificate from the World Bank about ease-of-doing-business and spruced up the processes in Delhi and Mumbai (at least in the beginning) to climb up the ladder. We did climb but the ground reality didn’t change despite our roadshows in Davos and other parts of the world.

Now the same western world has questioned democracy in the largest democracy of the world. There have been reactions. The Opposition that was at some time responsible for erosion of democratic norms is now taking the moral high ground on the basis of these reports.

Let us take a look at what exactly was said and then examine dispassionately where does the country stand in the context of democracy.

FAR-FETCHED COMPARISON

The V-Dem Institute of Sweden says in its report that India’s autocratization process has largely followed the typical pattern for countries in the ‘Third Wave’ over the past ten years: a gradual deterioration where freedom of media, academia, and civil society were curtailed first and to the greatest extent…and most of the decline occurred following BJP’s victory and their promotion of Hindu-nationalist agenda”.

The US-based non-profit Freedom House downgraded India from free democracy to a “partially free democracy”.

Using these two reports, some have even gone on to compare the present regime with that of Col. Gaddafi and Saddam Hussain. There is a comparison with Pakistan as well. This is indeed quite far-fetched as I wonder whether those that are ‘flaunting’ these comparisons would have been able to make such statements if India were as dictatorial as the two deposed autocrats.

AT NASCENT STAGE

Indian democracy is still nascent. It is evolving. There are bound to be problems. And, in any case, there is no perfect model of democracy anywhere in the world. Each democracy, including those in the US and England, has evolved over centuries. It took the US a Civil War and almost 100 years to abolish slavery after its independence but the ‘slavish’ mentality continued much longer. Britain faces an unprecedented crisis on account of allegation of racism against the Royal family. This is after centuries of maturity.

Democracy doesn’t get manifested in India only through the electoral process. Yes, the citizens get to vote to elect a government, both at the state and federal levels periodically, but democracy is much beyond that. It has its legal roots in the Indian Constitution that provides for certain inalienable rights like the freedom of expression and movement. These are ensured by an independent and impartial judiciary and a free press. The Parliament and the State Assemblies are forums where issues of importance are discussed. India is indeed a functional democracy that we are proud of. Then, is something not all well now?

A look at the events during the past few years and the response/conduct of institutions that are sentinels of democracy will help us understand what is going right or wrong with Indian democracy.

ON PARLIAMENT

“The intellectual level of the debate was quite low. Sometimes the debaters did not make themselves intelligible… A turbulent mass of people, all gesticulating and bawling, with pathetic old man shaking his bell and making frantic efforts to call the house to a sense of indignity by friendly appeals, exhortations and grave warnings?”

No, it is not a description of Indian Parliament. It is an extract from Mein Kampf on what Hitler could make out of the proceedings of Austrian Parliament, but is indeed reminiscent of how sometimes our own Parliament functions. This institution has virtually ceased to be a sentinel of our democracy and this happened long ago, not in the recent past. Brute majority of the ruling party has only made its irrelevance even more profound.

ON JUDICIARY

The Judiciary has seen its ups and downs during the past few decades. Judges have been given post-retirement assignments in the past as well. Some of these assignments have been frowned upon. However, if there is a perception of a quid-pro-quo when such assignments are handed over, it erodes the institution.

When a Supreme Court Judge, who holds a press conference against the sitting Chief Justice of India, is not only not taken to task for blatant contempt but is appointed as Chief Justice, eyebrows are raised. And, when the same judge against whom sexual harassment charges are levelled is ‘rewarded’ with a nomination to Rajya Sabha after he presides over some ‘favorable’ judgements for the government, it lends credence to the doubts about the independence of the Judiciary.

ON ELECTION COMMISSION

Election Commission is an institution that we have been all proud of. Credibility of the institution went many notches up when the likes of T N Seshan were at the helm. However, when an Election Commissioner, who is apparently “inconvenient” in line to become the Chief Election Commissioner, is “allowed” to join the Asian Development Bank, tongues start wagging.

ON INSECURITY AMONGST MINORITIES

Whether we accept it or not, there is a sense of insecurity amongst some minorities in the country. However, it is not for the first time that minorities have felt insecure in the country. Perhaps that is how democracies evolve. How can we forget what happened in 1984? The worrisome feature now is the flaunting of necessity to promote such animosity by some sections of the society for political gains. This is dangerous and will need to be tackled pro-actively. Indifference to “goli maaro saalo ko” (shoot the brothers-in-law) will be counterproductive and can cause irreparable damage in the long run.

ON MEDIA

There have been occasions in the past when newspapers in India had published a blank cover page to protest against press censorship. And, the country came out of it. The media today is unfortunately deeply divided. Objectivity is sorely missing and this does not augur well for the democracy. The alleged “harassment” of journalists and media houses critical of the government is also not a good sign. Similar apprehensions have been expressed in the academia.

STILL A FUNCTIONAL DEMOCRACY

However, despite all this, we still have farmers agitating freely for months just on the outskirts of the national capital, Delhi. We still have different political parties ruling in a number of states. We still have articles critical of the government published in the media. We still have a Prime Minister duly elected by the people and periodically endorsed by the majority at the hustings. We also have a leader whose initial claim to leadership was perhaps his lineage but now is able to challenge another democratically elected leader in his own right.

All this would not have been possible in Saddam’s or Gaddafi’s world, even in Pakistan. Yes, we are still a functional democracy. Yet, we have to be on the guard. There is a lurking fear around.


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
Punjab-Police-Logo
Punjab Govt Reshuffles IPS Officers: New Postings in Counter Intelligence, SSOC, and Tarn Taran SSP
Ladli Behna Yojana in Petlawad
Madhya Pradesh CM Mohan Yadav Transfers ₹1,541 Crore to 1.26 Crore Women Under Ladli Behna Yojana in Petlawad
Nalco
NALCO Foundation Partners with SDI Bhubaneswar to Launch Skill Training Program for Rural Youths in Odisha
Maharashtra govt-logo
Maharashtra Govt Signs Investment MoUs Worth ₹1.08 Lakh Crore for 47,000 Jobs - Learn Details Inside
Engineering-Projects-India-Ltd EPIL
Engineering Projects India (EPI) to Manage ₹800 Crore Maternal & Child Care Centre at Safdarjung Hospital, Delhi
Delhi Metro DMRC
Smooth Commute Ahead: Delhi Metro QR Tickets Now Accessible on ixigo App via ONDC Integration
Rashtriya Chemicals and Fertilizers, RCF
Leadership updates: Sipra Bajpai Appointed Independent Director at Rashtriya Chemicals and Fertilizers Ltd to Boost Governance
HAL award
Hindustan Shipyard (HSL) Wins 'Shipbuilding Company of the Year' at Maritime Excellence Awards 2025
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IPS Shikha Goel
How Modern Forensics Helps Police Solve Crimes – IPS Officer Shikha Goel Explains | Video Interview
IPS Shikha Goel
Decoding Digital Dangers: Insights from IPS Shikha Goel on Cyber Crimes
IPS Mukesh Kumar Bhamoo
Managing Elections, Communal Tensions, and Public Safety – Meet IPS Mukesh Kumar Bhamoo | Video Interview
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
Ishwarlal Gurjar UPSC
10th Grade Failure to Indian Police Service: Ishwarlal Gurjar’s UPSC Success Path
Read the inspiring journey of Ishwarlal Gurjar from a small village in Rajasthan to becoming an IPS officer....
IAS Minnu P M
“Lazy, Sleepy, Yet Determined”: Minnu P M’s Honest Take on Cracking UPSC
Minnu PM, once a clerk in Kerala Police, cleared UPSC with AIR 150 after five years of struggle. Her...
IPS Ashish Tiwari
From IIT and Investment Banking to Public Service, Meet IPS Ashish Tiwari 
Ashish Tiwari, IIT graduate and former investment banker, chose public service over global finance. As...
Social Media
IAS Medha Roopam
IAS Medha Roopam’s Inspiring Dedication in Flood-Hit Noida Goes Viral: Focuses on Relief, Education Amid Heavy Rains
Books in One Hand, Umbrella in Other: Noida DM Medha Roopam Leads Flood Relief from the Front
IAS Sakshi Sawhney Amritsar DC
Punjab Floods: IAS Sakshi Sawhney’s Emotional Appeal to Elderly Man Wins Hearts, Video of Humanity Goes Viral
Viral Video Captures Emotional Moment as Amritsar DC Shows Sensitivity and Courage Amid Relief Effor...
Masahiro Hara
From Go Board to Global Use, How QR Codes Changed the World: IRAS Officer Ananth Rupanagudi Spotlights Masahiro Hara’s Vision
IRAS officer Ananth Rupanagudi shared a video on Masahiro Hara, the inventor of QR codes, highlighting...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
Punjab-Police-Logo
Punjab Govt Reshuffles IPS Officers: New Postings in Counter Intelligence, SSOC, and Tarn Taran SSP
Ladli Behna Yojana in Petlawad
Madhya Pradesh CM Mohan Yadav Transfers ₹1,541 Crore to 1.26 Crore Women Under Ladli Behna Yojana in Petlawad
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IPS Shikha Goel
IPS Shikha Goel
IPS Mukesh Kumar Bhamoo
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT