https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Is Reservation to Blame for Train Accidents in India?

Is reservation to blame for train accidents in India? IRS Officer Nethrapal reveals the surprising truth behind the narratives and the real culprits.
Indian Masterminds Stories

The discourse surrounding reservation policies in India often ignites heated debates, especially when linked to societal issues such as railway accidents. Recently, social media has seen a surge in narratives blaming reservation policies for train mishaps, attributing these incidents to allegedly less skilled technicians from SC/ST/OBC backgrounds. However, a closer examination of these claims reveals a different story.

IRS Nethrapal has a few things to say about this. Let’s learn more-

THE CONTROVERSIAL CIRCULAR: “BEST AMONG FAILED”

At the heart of the controversy is a circular that allowed two Scheduled Tribe (ST) candidates who secured 20% marks to be considered under the “Best Among Failed” scheme. This policy, implemented due to the unavailability of sufficient reserved candidates, has been criticized for allegedly compromising the quality of railway staff.

Social media influencers often cite this circular as evidence of reservations leading to train accidents. However, it’s crucial to understand the full context and the policy’s current status.

POLICY STATUS: WITHDRAWN AND MISUNDERSTOOD

“Firstly, it’s important to note that the “Best Among Failed” policy was withdrawn in 2020. Thus, the viral claims suggesting that many reserved candidates are securing positions without meeting the required marks are outdated and misleading,” Mr. Nethrapal shared with Indian Masterminds.

Furthermore, even when this policy was in place, it was limited to a small number of non-sensitive posts, primarily in administration and finance, and involved initial appointments on an ad hoc basis. Candidates were required to undergo further training and testing within six months before being regularized.

MISCONCEPTIONS AND REALITY

The persistent narrative that the “Best Among Failed” policy placed underqualified individuals in sensitive positions, such as those involving train operations and safety, is unfounded.

“These positions have always been filled based on merit and stringent qualification criteria, ensuring that train safety is not compromise,” he stated.

BROADER ACCOUNTABILITY

Blaming reservations exclusively for train accidents overlooks several critical factors. The actual causes of railway derailments and accidents are multifaceted, involving numerous technical, operational, and human errors.

A study by Ashwini Deshpande and Thomas Weisskopf (2010) provides empirical evidence that reservations do not impede efficiency or productivity in Indian Railways. On the contrary, their analysis suggests that SC/ST employees in high-level positions are positively associated with productivity growth. This indicates that individuals from marginalized groups often perform exceptionally well when given the opportunity, motivated by the desire to prove their detractors wrong.

THE REAL CULPRITS: A MULTIFACETED PROBLEM

Train accidents in India stem from a complex interplay of factors, as revealed by a Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) report:

Engineering Lapses: Poor track maintenance, including improper gauge, inadequate ballast, and faulty welds, is a major cause.

Mechanical Issues: Rolling stock defects like uneven wheel diameters and inadequate coach maintenance contribute significantly.

Human Error: Mistakes by staff, including signal mismanagement, carelessness, and alcohol abuse, play a role.

Training and Supervision Deficiencies: Lack of proper training for new technologies and lax supervision exacerbate the problem.

Communication Failures: Ineffective communication during operations and maintenance activities creates safety hazards.

The CAG report highlights the need for:

Enhanced Mechanization: Utilizing machinery for track maintenance to minimize human error.

Improved Training: Regular training programs for staff to ensure proficiency in modern techniques.

Stricter Supervision: Ensuring adherence to safety protocols and maintenance schedules.

Enhanced Coordination: Establishing robust communication channels across departments for seamless operations.

These measures, rather than scapegoating reservation policies, hold the key to improving railway safety in India.

REPRESENTATION MATTERS: A STATISTICAL LOOK

An analysis of railway derailments from 2017-2021 shows that the engineering department is responsible for approximately 39% of derailments, followed by the operating department at 17%. These statistics underscore the complex interplay of factors behind train accidents, none of which are directly related to reservation policies.

Despite the controversy, it is noteworthy that a significant majority of Group A and B officers in Indian Railways are from upper castes, with a mere 8.05% representation from OBCs, against the mandated 27%.

“This statistic challenges the narrative that reservations are to blame for inefficiencies in railway operations.”

The narrative that reservations are responsible for train accidents is unfounded and misleading. The real causes of train accidents are technical, operational, and managerial issues within the railway departments. By addressing these core issues through enhanced training, strict supervision, better coordination, and adherence to maintenance protocols, Indian Railways can significantly reduce the occurrence of derailments and improve overall safety. The vilification of reservation policies only serves to distract from these critical areas and perpetuates unjust biases against marginalized communities.

Check out the book by clicking on the link given below-

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1JUsN71-Uzf4MEKkZMzz31ZkvW7qlqKzT


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
NTPC Green
NTPC Green Energy Upgraded to Schedule ‘A’ CPSE, Strengthening India’s Renewable Energy Drive
IAS Amandeep Duli
Who is IAS Amandeep Duli? Lalitpur DM Goes Viral for Diwali Wishes and Looks, Transferred in UP Administrative Reshuffle
Reimagining Manufacturing Roadmap
India Eyes Top 3 Global Spot with NITI Aayog’s Reimagining Manufacturing Roadmap 2035
bureaucracy news
IRS Himanshu Roy’s Tenure Extended Till Jan 2026, IRSEE Officer Smita Srivastava to Continue in Education Ministry
Indian Bureaucracy News Latest
Centre Approves Major Bureaucratic Changes: Rajesh Aggarwal Repatriated, Rajesh Lakhani Gets Additional Charge, Tripathi Appointed OSD to Amit Shah
UPSC Answer Keys Transparency
UPSC Releases CSE 2024 Reserve List; 114 Additional Candidates Recommended for IAS, IPS, and IFS - Check List Here
M2M SIM ownership transfer
DoT Approves New Framework for M2M SIM Ownership Transfer — A Game-Changer for India’s IoT Revolution
Prime Toolings dual boosters
India’s New Missile Muscle: Prime Toolings Unveils Dual-Booster Engine to Power Atmanirbhar Defence Drive — Know More Here
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IAS Gokul S
Meet IAS Gokul S — The Officer Who Turned Disability into Determination | Video Interview 
WhatsApp Image 2025-10-23 at 10.40
Everybody Needs To Know What Is Transpiring Behind Closed Doors Of Courts
WhatsApp Image 2025-10-19 at 12.23
UPSC Journey Should Be Enjoyable, Not Cumbersome
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
IAS Gokul S
Meet IAS Gokul S — The Officer Who Turned Disability into Determination | Video Interview 
Visually impaired IAS officer Gokul S turned his challenges into change, empowering hundreds through...
Parmeshwar Chaudhary RAS
From Taunts to Triumph: How Farmer’s Son Parmeshwar Chaudhary Rose from Lab Assistant to SDM, Securing Rank 3 in RAS 2023
Parmeshwar, once taunted over his SI selection, has scripted a stunning success—securing Rank 3 in RAS...
IAS Rupal Rana UPSC
How Rupal Rana Cracked UPSC CSE 2023 with AIR 26 After Four Attempts
UPSC Topper Rupal Rana secured AIR 26 in 2023 after four attempts. Learn her preparation strategy, booklist,...
Social Media
Tenzin Yangki IPS Arunachal
Historic First: Who Is Tenzin Yangki, Arunachal Pradesh’s First Woman to Join IPS? Anand Mahindra Hails Her
She secured an impressive 545th rank in the prestigious UPSC Civil Services Examination - 2022.
IFS Parveen Kaswan
Heartbreak by the River: 15-Day-Old Elephant Calf Rejected by Mother, Rescued by IFS Parveen Kaswan and His Team
Jaldapra, West Bengal: In a moving incident that tugs at the heart, a 15-day-old elephant calf was rescued...
Ashwini Bhide IAS and Anand Mahindra
Who Is IAS Ashwini Bhide, Hailed as a Role Model for Mumbai Metro Transformation by Anand Mahindra?
From heritage to high-tech: Bhide’s leadership in Metro Line 3 earns public praise and admiration
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
NTPC Green
NTPC Green Energy Upgraded to Schedule ‘A’ CPSE, Strengthening India’s Renewable Energy Drive
IAS Amandeep Duli
Who is IAS Amandeep Duli? Lalitpur DM Goes Viral for Diwali Wishes and Looks, Transferred in UP Administrative Reshuffle
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IAS Gokul S
WhatsApp Image 2025-10-23 at 10.40
WhatsApp Image 2025-10-19 at 12.23
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT