https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Former Police Chiefs Divided: Applause and Concerns Over New Indian Criminal Laws

India implements new criminal laws - Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), and Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA), Critics argue that despite changes, the legal system retains much of its colonial legacy, advocating for broader reforms.
Indian Masterminds Stories

Since India’s independence from colonial rule, its criminal laws have undergone numerous revisions. However, a significant overhaul was long overdue. July 1, 2024, marked a pivotal moment for the Indian justice system with the implementation of three new criminal laws: the Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), the Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), and the Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA). These laws are set to replace the existing Indian Penal Code (IPC), the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC), and the Indian Evidence Act, respectively, following their passage in Parliament last December.

The introduction of these new laws has sparked both acclaim and criticism. Proponents argue that the reforms will enhance police power and transparency, while critics warn that certain changes could lead to increased potential for misuse by law enforcement. To gain a deeper understanding of these new laws, Indian Masterminds spoke with former IPS officers Anil Raturi, Prakash Singh, and Amod K. Kanth, gathering their insights and perspectives on the implications of these significant legal reforms.

THE POSITIVES 

Welcoming the new names of the laws, former DGP of Uttarakhand Mr. Anil Raturi said that many of the old laws were from British times and, although they had been updated, their names had never changed. He believes that since India is a free country, it should have its own names for everything.

In the Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), there are many positive changes, such as recognizing mob lynching, organized crimes, chain snatching, and separately penalizing sexual intercourse done through “deceitful means.” These changes aim to give more protection to children and women.

The Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) replaces the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) of 1973. The CrPC provided procedures for prosecution, arrest, bail, and more. Under the new BNSS, zero FIRs are now mandatory, meaning that victims can file an FIR at any police station, which will then be transferred to the appropriate jurisdiction.

Anil Raturi
Anil Raturi

Forensic investigation has become mandatory for offenses punishable with imprisonment of seven years or more. All inquiries, proceedings, and trials will be conducted electronically. Additionally, electronic communication devices can now be used for investigations, trials, or inquiries. Community service has also been introduced as a punishment for various crimes.

Former DGP of BSF, Assam, and UP, Mr. Prakash Singh, a pioneer in police reforms, believes these changes will empower both the police and the public.

CONCERNS OVER HASTY LEGISLATION

However, Mr. Singh also emphasizes that the biggest problem with the bill is that it was rushed through Parliament. It was passed when half of the opposition was suspended, leaving insufficient time for thorough debate or discussion on these new laws. “These laws will affect the entire nation, but representatives were not given the opportunity to present their suggestions. Our Indian Police Foundation also sought time to discuss the changes, but we were denied that opportunity,” he said.

Prakash Singh

Mr. Singh believes that the lack of comprehensive debate could lead to potential oversights and unintended consequences. He stresses the importance of a more inclusive legislative process, where diverse perspectives and expert opinions are considered. “For such significant reforms, it is crucial that we take the time to ensure they are well thought out and serve the best interests of all citizens,” he added.

POTENTIAL  MISUSE

The BNSS extends police custody of an accused from 14 days to 60 days, and for cases with less than 7 years of punishment, the police now have two weeks to investigate before registering an FIR. While this measure aims to reduce the number of fake cases, it also has the potential for misuse by officials. Both Mr. Singh and Mr. Raturi share the same concern. They believe that although the DSP has been given supervisory authority, victims might still be denied an FIR under these provisions, potentially leading to corruption.

Another provision attracting criticism is Clause 69, which penalizes sexual intercourse conducted through “deceitful means” with imprisonment for up to 10 years and a fine. While this law can protect women, it also raises concerns about the possibility of false accusations, similar to the misuse seen in dowry cases. Mr. Singh describes it as a double-edged sword. In contrast, Mr. Raturi welcomes the law and believes there is always room for amendments if practical problems arise.

PARTIAL REFORMS AND PRACTICAL CONCERNS

Mr. Singh, who has long advocated for police reforms in India, criticizes the new laws for only partially addressing the colonial legacy of the legal system. He points out that despite the government’s claims of decolonizing the system, 75% of the laws remain unchanged. The renumbering of sections, such as changing the section for murder from 302 to 103, will create practical problems not only for police and lawyers but also for the victims. He argues that this change will cause confusion in the long run. Instead of a complete overhaul, Mr. Singh suggests that the government should have added new sections to the existing laws and introduced separate chapters for the new changes.

He also emphasizes that despite claims of empowering the police, real change will not occur until the Police Act of 1861 is completely revised and the police are given functional autonomy. Mr. Amod K. Kanth supports this view, stating that the new laws only result in cosmetic changes. According to him, India needs to fundamentally change the architecture of its police and criminal justice system if it truly wants to decolonize.


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
SJVN
Leadership Continuity: Rajendra Prasad Goyal Given Additional Charge as Director (Finance) of SJVN Ltd- Know more about Him
government-of-haryana
Haryana Government Transfers 2 IPS, 13 HPS Officers in Major Police Reshuffle- Check Details
scam
‘Hello, This is IPS Officer Speaking…’: 9th-Pass Youth Tricks Cops in Three States with Fake Voice Scam
Screenshot 2025-07-18 214334
L&T Chairman Mr. S.N. Subrahmanyan’s FY25 Remuneration Jumps Nearly 50% to Rs. 76.25 Crore!
bureaucracy news
Appointments Update: IRS Kommisetty Murlidhar to Join Andhra Govt; Jay Nath Yadav Inducted into IAS
Indian Overseas Bank (IOB)
Indian Overseas Bank Plans Rs. 4,000 Crore Fundraising via QIP; Net Profit Soars 76% in Q1 FY26
Paresh Saxena IPS
IPS Officer Dr Paresh Saxena Protests Empanelment Denial, Returns President’s Distinguished Service Medal
Screenshot 2025-07-18 212145
Chhattisgarh: CM Vishnu Deo Sai Unveils ‘Anjor Vision @ 2047’ - A Bold Roadmap for a Developed Future!
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
promila gupta
The Secret of The Secret – How To Make The Universe Conspire For You
AI 171 CRASH
AAIB Initial Probe In AI-171 Crash Questioned By Aviation Experts
Ravi Kapoor
Why Ex-IRS Officer Ravi Kapoor Walked Away from Power
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
Bhavesh Royada
“People often don’t put in the effort required for exams of this level,” Bhavesh Royada
Bhavesh Royada left a stable engineering job to follow his passion for nature. Overcoming failures and...
WhatsApp Image 2025-07-14 at 15.58
The Economist Who Became an IFS Officer
How Abhimanyu Gahlaut balanced global economics and civil services dreams to crack UPSC with AIR 38
Disha Dwivedi UPSC
How Disha Dwivedi Cracked UPSC in Her Sixth Attempt with Unshakable Determination
Disha Dwivedi’s UPSC journey from five prelims failures to securing AIR 672 in 2024 showcases strategic...
Social Media
Screenshot 2025-07-18 203508
Majestic Tiger Rescue and Release in Sundarbans Captivates the Internet: IFS Susanta Nanda Shares Video On X
The video captures the tiger’s strength, agility, and instinct—a breathtaking sight as the big cat slices...
Standing Leopard
Leopard Stuns Internet by Standing on Two Legs Like a Meerkat
A rare video of a leopard standing on two legs in Kruger Park stuns viewers and goes viral across social...
G S Roshni
Kerala’s Fearless Forest Officer G.S. Roshni Rescues 16-Foot King Cobra with Bare Hands, Garners Praise & Critique
Beat Forest Officer G.S. Roshni’s first-ever king cobra rescue goes viral, earning her the title of ‘Green...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
SJVN
Leadership Continuity: Rajendra Prasad Goyal Given Additional Charge as Director (Finance) of SJVN Ltd- Know more about Him
government-of-haryana
Haryana Government Transfers 2 IPS, 13 HPS Officers in Major Police Reshuffle- Check Details
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
promila gupta
AI 171 CRASH
Ravi Kapoor
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT