https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Half the Population, Barely Any Representation: SC Questions Centre on Women Reservation Bill Delay

The Supreme Court has turned to the Preamble promise of political equality and asked the Centre for a response on the landmark women reservation bill, stirring fresh debate on gender representation in India’s legislatures.
Women Reservation Bill
Indian Masterminds Stories

On 10 November 2025, the Supreme Court of India issued a notice to the Central government responding to a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) that sought immediate implementation of the women’s reservation law which mandates one-third of seats be reserved for women in the Lok Sabha and state legislative assemblies. 

Background of Women reservation bill

The original push began in the 1990s: the 81st Amendment Bill (1996) aimed to reserve one-third of seats for women in Parliament and state assemblies. 

Multiple attempts followed (1998, 1999, 2008) but the Bills lapsed due to dissolution of Houses of Parliament. 

Read Also: Only 9 Women for 441 Posts’ – Supreme Court Hears Plea for One-Third Reservation for Women Lawyers in State Bar Councils

Finally, in 2023, Parliament passed the Bill with overwhelming support: Lok Sabha passed it on 20 Sept 2023, Rajya Sabha on 21 Sept 2023. President Draupadi Murmu gave assent on 28 Sept 2023. 

The Act introduced Article 334A to the Constitution, specifying one-third reservation for women in Lok Sabha and state assemblies, but conditionally “after the exercise of delimitation is undertaken … following census”. 

The petition was filed by Jaya Thakur (General-Secretary, Madhya Pradesh Women’s Wing, Indian National Congress) and is represented by Senior Advocate Shobha Gupta. They argue the law – officially the Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam (Constitution (128th Amendment) Act, 2023) – shouldn’t await a fresh delimitation exercise after the next census for implementation. 

While the Bill was passed by Parliament in September 2023 and received the President’s assent on 28 September 2023, it still remains contingent upon a delimitation exercise based on the next census before becoming effective. 

What Did the Supreme Court Say?

During the hearing, the bench – comprising B. V. Nagarathna and R. Mahadevan – emphasized that the Constitution’s Preamble guarantees political and social equality, and pointed out that women, constituting nearly 48 % of the country’s population, are effectively the “largest minority”. 

The bench asked the Centre: “When is the delimitation exercise going to happen?” and noted that implementation of the law is an executive responsibility. It pointed out the Court cannot issue a mandamus (order) for the matter. 

It underscored that the Preamble’s phrase “political and social equality” has direct bearing on this case. 

Importantly, the Court issued notice to the respondents (i.e., the Centre) in the case. 

Importance of Women Reservation Bill

  • Women presently occupy only about 15% of Lok Sabha seats, far below the global average. 
  • By raising the matter of the Preamble and political equality, the Court is signalling that gender representation isn’t just a policy choice but a constitutional promise.
  • If implemented, the reservation could reshape political power dynamics, opening up a larger pathway for women in decision-making.
  • The question of delimitation, timing and implementation remains contentious: waiting for a new census could delay actual representation further, undermining the spirit of the law.

Way Forward 

  • The Centre must submit a response to the Court’s notice. The timeline is yet unknown, but public interest and legal urgency may speed matters.
  • Implementation hinges on delimitation – redrawing of constituencies after the next census – a process that can take years.
  • Opposition and advocacy groups will continue to monitor whether waiting for delimitation undermines the law’s aim of timely gender‐balanced representation.
  • Further legal proceedings could clarify whether the “after delimitation” clause can be interpreted more flexibly or even struck down.

Read Also: No More Land Scams: Supreme Court Backs Blockchain in Land Registration to Curb Corruption


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
Defence PSU Bhavan
Rajnath Singh Inaugurates Defence PSU Bhavan in Delhi to Boost R&D, Innovation, and Atmanirbharta
state bar council elections supervision
Bar Polls Under Judicial Watch: SC Empowers Retired Judges for State Bar Council Elections Supervision After Mounting Complaints
SJVN
SJVN Q2 Net Profit Drops to ₹307.8 Crore, Approves ₹1,000 Crore Fundraising for Growth Projects
vishnu-deo-
Chhattisgarh CM Vishnu Deo Sai Announces ₹200 Crore Development Plan and 100-Bed Hospital for Ratanpur
IAS Rajesh Patil
Who Is IAS Rajesh Patil? The Odisha Cadre Officer Completes IRONMAN 70.3 Goa, Balances Bureaucracy, Books, and Endurance
IPS
Mumbai Confidential: IPS Power Tussle Turns Bureau Headache as Senior Officers Lock Horns
SP Vaid
‘Feels Like Inhaling 1,000 Cigarettes’: Ex-J&K DGP Shesh Paul Vaid Slams Delhi’s Toxic Air, Calls It a ‘Humanitarian Crisis’
Uttarakhand Foundation Day 2025
Himalayan Hopes Soar: PM Modi Inaugurates ₹8,260 Crore Development Projects on Uttarakhand Foundation Day 2025
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Anil Swarup
Conquering The Emperor of Maladies With Aplomb
CS Rao, IFS Officer
How IFS Officer C.S. Rao Is Transforming Sikkim Into a Model of Green and Sustainable Tourism
WhatsApp Image 2025-10-31 at 13.49
Walking with the Wild: How Dr. Sonali Ghosh is Protecting Assam’s Forests
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
IFS Kenneth Chakma UPSC
This IFS Officer Wants to Turn the Northeast into a Global Model of Green Prosperity
UPSC achiever and IFS officer Kenneth Chakma shares his path from GSI to the Forest Service and his mission...
Moin Ahamd Mansoori IAS UPSC Success Story
How IAS Moin Ahamd Mansoori’s Selection Brought Respect, Dignity, and a New Life to His Family
From running a cyber café to becoming an IAS officer, Moin Ahamd Mansoori’s story of struggle, UPSC journey,...
asjhajshaj
The Soil That Raised Him Now Celebrates Him: How Farmer’s Son & Teacher Kamal Khadav Became SDM - After Mishearing a Question in His Interview
Farmer’s son Kamal Khadav from Bedawadi, Nagaur, secured 9th rank in RAS 2023 through self-study while...
Social Media
IAS L.V
Clean Skies vs Choking Smog: Ex-IAS L V Nilesh's Critiquing Post Comparing Delhi’s Smog to U.S. Skies Sparks National Outrage
Ex-IAS officer Mr. L.V. Nilesh’s viral post comparing Delhi’s polluted air to the U.S. has reignited...
IAS Pari Bishnoi
“Don’t Quit”: IAS Pari Bishnoi’s Inspiring Journey From Weight Gain to UPSC Glory is Inspiring Millions Across India
IAS officer Ms. Pari Bishnoi’s journey from failure to achieving All India Rank 30 in the UPSC exam showcases...
Tenzin Yangki IPS Arunachal
Historic First: Who Is Tenzin Yangki, Arunachal Pradesh’s First Woman to Join IPS? Anand Mahindra Hails Her
She secured an impressive 545th rank in the prestigious UPSC Civil Services Examination - 2022.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
Defence PSU Bhavan
Rajnath Singh Inaugurates Defence PSU Bhavan in Delhi to Boost R&D, Innovation, and Atmanirbharta
state bar council elections supervision
Bar Polls Under Judicial Watch: SC Empowers Retired Judges for State Bar Council Elections Supervision After Mounting Complaints
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Anil Swarup
CS Rao, IFS Officer
WhatsApp Image 2025-10-31 at 13.49
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT