https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Supreme Court Closes Contempt Plea in DGP Row, Says Political Scores Can’t Be Settled via Courts – Know More Details

Bench Directs Parties to Proper Legal Forums, Says PIL Jurisdiction Reserved for Disadvantaged Groups
Indian Masterminds Stories

New Delhi: On August 18, the Supreme Court underscored that contempt proceedings cannot be invoked to settle political disputes, stressing that the proper forum for service-related grievances lies with the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT). The Court emphasized that Public Interest Litigation (PIL) jurisdiction was designed exclusively to safeguard the rights of those from socio-economically disadvantaged backgrounds.

The remarks came during the hearing of petitions challenging the process of ad-hoc appointments of Directors General of Police (DGPs) across states. The matter was heard by a Bench comprising Justice B.R. Gavai, Justice K. Vinod Chandran, and Justice N.V. Anjaria.

Senior Counsels Present Proposals on Appointment Process

Senior Advocate Ramachandran informed the Bench that a Tamil Nadu officer, who had previously been exonerated, had applied for the post of DGP. He also referred to a plea filed by former police officer Prakash Singh, which suggested that instead of the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC), the selection process should involve the Chief Minister, the Leader of the Opposition, and the Chief Justice of the High Court.

Supporting this framework, Ramachandran said, “I agree with the proposal, and this would ensure greater transparency.”

Advocate Prashant Bhushan, appearing for Prakash Singh, added, “The process should follow the model used for appointing the CBI Director.”

Senior Advocate Gopal Sankarnarayanan emphasized that insulating the police from executive interference was essential. He submitted, “Even in the Anoop Baranwal case, the principle was to ensure that the police remain free from executive control. We have the list where appointment was against the order of this Court.”

Also Read: ‘Not the Way to Function’: Says CJI Gavai Halts Further Hearings in Paramedical Case As MP High Court Ignored SC Stay

Court Questions Role of Judicial Monitoring

Senior Advocate Anjana Prakash, representing the Jharkhand DGP contempt case, told the Court, “An Acting DGP has been appointed just like Uttar Pradesh did. States are repeatedly trying to bypass the process.”

At this stage, the Chief Justice raised a larger question, remarking, “Our extraordinary powers operate only until a law is enacted. Once the legislature makes a law, what should prevail—our directions or the statute?”

Responding to this, Prakash Singh observed, “The main PIL has gone cold without monitoring, which is why such cases keep arising.”

The Chief Justice countered, “Do we even have the expertise to monitor this?”

In response, Ramachandran suggested, “The suggestion is for High Court special benches to meet every three months to ensure the judgment is implemented.”

The Bench, however, concluded the discussion by stating, “We’ll take it up after the Constitution Bench matter.”

SC Declines to Proceed with Contempt Plea

Delivering its order, the Court made it clear that it was not inclined to pursue the contempt petition. The amicus suggested that the pending writ petition before the Jharkhand High Court could be withdrawn and re-filed in the Supreme Court.

The Chief Justice firmly observed, “In the Jharkhand matter, contempt cannot be used to settle political disputes. If there’s an issue with a specific appointment, the proper forum is CAT. Political scores should be settled before the electorate. PIL jurisdiction is meant to protect those from socio-economically disadvantaged backgrounds.”

He further clarified, “This contempt plea is essentially aimed at defying this Court’s orders against the State Chief Secretary. The State rules appear to protect Mr. Anurag Gupta, and the grievance also involves the removal of Mr. Ajaykumar Shri as police chief. What emerges is a dispute between two officers being projected as contempt.”

Concluding, the Bench reiterated that remedies exist in law for aggrieved officers. “If any officer feels wronged by removal or denial of service benefits, the remedy lies in law. PIL was started by this Court to allow a public spirited person to relax locus for genuine public interest, not to settle personal or institutional rivalries. Hence, we decline to entertain the plea,” the Chief Justice said.

The contempt plea now stands closed, with the broader issue of DGP appointments set to be considered at a later stage, once the Constitution Bench concludes its hearings.

Also Read: SC Intervenes on Struggles of Disabled Cadets, Questions Denial of Medical and ESM Benefits


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
PFC logo resized Power Finance Corporation Ltd
KHPL Signs Rs 4,829 Crore Loan Agreement with Power Finance Corporation (PFC) for Khorlochhu Hydropower Project in Bhutan
Maharashtra govt-logo
Meet IPS Officer G Vijay Krishna Yadav, Reinstated by Maharashtra Government After 7 Years Despite Bribery Allegations
ntpc_barh_wins_two_awards (1)
NTPC Barh Wins 2 Prestigious Awards at 15th PRCI Excellence Awards 2025 for Excellence in Communication
NBCC
NBCC Signs Agreement with Goa Government for ₹1,700 Crore Redevelopment Projects
Sanjeev Chaturvedi
Who’s Afraid of Sanjiv Chaturvedi? 15 Judges Step Aside from His Cases
BEML Limited
BEML Shines at 19th Global Communication Conclave 2025, Wins Five Prestigious PRCI Awards
ECI Sadan_ Election
Election Commission of India (ECI) Names 470 IAS, IPS, IRS Officers as Central Observers for Bihar and Other State By-Elections
IAS Rajeev Verma Delhi
Who Is IAS Rajeev Verma? The Officer Appointed as Delhi’s New Chief Secretary, to Take Charge on October 1
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Siddhartha Saxena UPSC CAPF
How Siddhartha Saxena Cracked UPSC CAPF AIR 326 Against All Odds
Dr. S.K
Technology Meets Ecology: IFS Dr S K Srivastava’s Game-Changing Innovations in Forest Management | Eco Warrior Awards 2025 Interview
IFS Uttam Kumar Sharma Interview
From Extinction to Exhilaration: The Untold Story and Future Vision of Project Cheetah | Led by IFS Uttam Kumar Sharma | Eco Warrior Awards 2025
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
Ankit MPPSC 2024 Rank 3
From Village Dreams to Deputy Collector’s Chair: Meet Ankit, MPPSC Rank 3 Hindi Medium Topper
Ankit, a Hindi-medium aspirant from Balaghat, secured Rank 3 in MPPSC 2024 and became Deputy Collector...
Shubham Muchhala MPPSC 2024
9 Years, 6 Interviews, Now Deputy Collector: Meet MPPSC 2024 Hindi Medium Topper Shubham, the Face of Relentless Struggle
After nine years, seven prelims, six mains, and five interview failures, Shubham Muchhala secured MPPSC...
Abhay Daga IPS UPSC Success Story
IIT Graduate, Microsoft Alum, Actor, to Cracking UPSC CSE: The Story of Abhay Daga
Read the inspiring journey of Abhay Daga, an IIT graduate, Microsoft alum, and actor, who cleared UPSC...
Social Media
World Rhino Day India
On World Rhino Day, IFS Officer Parveen Kaswan Shares Rare Insights - India Now Hosts 80% of the World’s One-Horned Rhinos
September 22 Marks Global Call for Rhino Conservation; India Holds 80% of World’s Greater One-Horned...
Parag Madhukar Dhakate
Relentless Rains Wreak Havoc in Dehradun: IFS officer PM Dhakate Warns Citizens Amid Flash Floods
Cloudbursts in Dehradun triggered flash floods. IFS officer Dr. PM Dhakate warned citizens to stay indoors...
Forest Guard Tiger Encounter
Tigers Clash in the Wild as Forest Guards Capture Rare Footage , Retired IFS Mohan Pargaien Posts Viral Video
Retired IFS officer Mohan Pargaien shares viral video of three tigers brawling in Ramnagar, as forest...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
PFC logo resized Power Finance Corporation Ltd
KHPL Signs Rs 4,829 Crore Loan Agreement with Power Finance Corporation (PFC) for Khorlochhu Hydropower Project in Bhutan
Maharashtra govt-logo
Meet IPS Officer G Vijay Krishna Yadav, Reinstated by Maharashtra Government After 7 Years Despite Bribery Allegations
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Siddhartha Saxena UPSC CAPF
Dr. S.K
IFS Uttam Kumar Sharma Interview
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT