https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Supreme Court Orders Madhya Pradesh Government Withdraw Controversial APAR Order for IFS Officers

The SC instructed the Senior Advocate for the State of MP to address the issue seriously and warned that if the Order from 29/06/2024 is not withdrawn, contempt proceedings might be initiated against the State.
Indian Masterminds Stories

The Supreme Court of India has delivered a stern warning to the Madhya Pradesh Government, instructing it to withdraw a controversial office order related to the Performance Appraisal Report (APAR) for Indian Forest Service (IFS) officers or face contempt proceedings.

IFS officers have raised concerns about a government order issued by the MP government.

The order in question, dated June 29, 2024, introduced a new evaluation mechanism for IFS officers ranging from Divisional Forest Officers (DFOs) to the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests (PCCF). This mechanism shifts the responsibility of assessing these officers’ performance from their peers within the Forest Department to non-Forest Department officials, including District Collectors and Divisional Commissioners.

The order stipulates that the performance evaluations of divisional forest officers, conservators, and chief conservators—who are stationed at the district level and involved in field activities such as those related to the Forest Rights Act, land acquisition, ecotourism, or mining in forest areas—will be conducted separately by district collectors and divisional commissioners.

Officers argue that this approach violates Supreme Court directives and could lead to situations where senior officers are evaluated by their junior counterparts.

In a hearing led by Justice B.R. Gavai, Advocate Gaurav Kumar Bansal argued that the new order violates previous Supreme Court judgments, including T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India and Santosh Bharti v. State of Madhya Pradesh.

Mr Bansal contended that the involvement of non-Forest officers in evaluating tasks such as Joint Forest Management, Forest Rights Act matters, land acquisition, and other forest-related responsibilities undermines the specialized role of the IFS officers. He emphasized that this move could adversely affect forest conservation and protection efforts.

The Supreme Court expressed serious concerns about the implications of the new APAR format and has given the Madhya Pradesh Government a clear ultimatum: withdraw the order or face contempt proceedings. The Court has instructed the Senior Advocate representing the state to address the issue promptly.

The decision underscores the Court’s commitment to maintaining the integrity of the Indian Forest Services and ensuring that their evaluation process remains within the purview of professionals with expertise in forest management.


Indian Masterminds Stories
Related Stories
NEWS
IAS-Officer-Logo
IAS Siddharth Mahajan’s Tenure as Joint Secretary Extended in Department of Commerce
IRS Officers ndian revenue Services
IRS Vikas Singh Appointed Director in Ministry of Petroleum & Natural Gas
Inter cadre Transfer
Two IPS Officer Given Inter-cadre Transfer on the Grounds of Marriage; Check Names Here
Alka Tiwari IAS
Jharkhand: IAS Alka Tiwari Appointed New Chief Secretary Ahead of Elections
Bibek Debroy
Remembering Bibek Debroy: The Economist Who Bridged Ancient Wisdom and Modern Policy
Ministry_of_CorporateAffairs(Corporate)MCA
IRS Kiran Reddy T Appointed Director, Ministry of Corporate Affairs
bribery
Two IRS & Three CGST SIs Arrested By CBI In "Rs. 50 Lakh" Bribery Case
West bengal Government WB
West Bengal: IAS Ravi Kumar Meena Made SDO, Arambagh-Hooghly
Videos
Prakash Singn IPS
Mulayam Singh Introduced Casteism in Police Force
WhatsApp Image 2024-10-25 at 21.23
Why Only Soldiers? Can’t Politicians or Civilians Sacrifice Too?
IMG-20241022-WA0016
IAS Officer’s Mission to Combat Breast Cancer in Rural India | Video Interview
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
Tejas Krishna Prasad
How COVID-19 Led an Olympic Marksman to Crack UPSC
IAS-Officer-Logo
IAS Siddharth Mahajan’s Tenure as Joint Secretary Extended in Department of Commerce
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Prakash Singn IPS
WhatsApp Image 2024-10-25 at 21.23
IMG-20241022-WA0016
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT