https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Tougher Scrutiny: Supreme Court Interviews Push Success Rate for HC Judges Below 50%

From 90% to Below 50%: How New Interviews Are Changing HC Judge Appointments.
Indian Masterminds Stories

New Delhi: The path to becoming a constitutional court judge has become significantly more challenging for lawyers, a stark contrast to the relative ease of just a few decades ago. Previously, a recommendation from a High Court collegium to the three-member Supreme Court collegium, headed by the Chief Justice of India (CJI), almost guaranteed an appointment. However, recent changes in the selection process have drastically reduced the success rate of recommended candidates.

The main shift in the process came with the introduction of personal interviews for candidates recommended by High Court collegia. This new system was implemented by CJI Justice Sanjiv Khanna, in consultation with Justices B R Gavai and Surya Kant. The idea behind this change was to better assess the suitability of candidates for judgeship in a constitutional court. This shift has led to a sharp decline in the success rate, from around 90 percent to less than 50 percent in recent months.

The introduction of interviews comes in response to increasing concerns over the quality of judgments delivered by some High Court judges and allegations of corruption. The move aims to ensure that only those most suitable are appointed to high judicial office.

The new system’s impact is clear, as evidenced by the latest round of interviews. A total of 101 candidates were recommended by the collegia of 12 High Courts, including Andhra Pradesh, Allahabad, Bombay, Calcutta, Delhi, Gujarat, Manipur, Orissa, Patna, Rajasthan, Telangana, and Uttarakhand. However, after rigorous interviews by the Supreme Court collegium, only 49 were deemed suitable for appointment as High Court judges.

This development marks a significant change in the judicial appointment process, emphasizing merit and suitability over recommendations alone. The impact of this new procedure is expected to be far-reaching in shaping the future of India’s judiciary.


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
sagayam-ias
Retired IAS Officer U Sagayam Cites Security Threat, Skips Court Appearance in Granite Scam Case - Know About Him
Surendra-Singh-Yadav IPS
Former Chandigarh DGP Surendra Singh Yadav Faces Setback as Court Rejects Challenge to Transfer Orders to BSF
Nikunja Bihari Dhal IAS
Odisha: Senior IAS Nikunja Bihari Dhal Reflects on Work-Life Balance After Relieved from Post as Addl Chief Secy
IAS Officers Indian Administrative Services
IAS Shashank Mani Tripathi Lateral Shifted to Ministry of Home Affairs
UP Government Uttar Pradesh Yogi
6 IAS Officers Transferred in Uttar Pradesh, Dinesh Kumar Appointed as Special Secy, Home Dept
Calcutta HC
Calcutta High Court Issues Contempt Notice Against IPS Officer Vishal Garg and 6 Others
SBI_resized
SBI Declares Rs. 15.90 Dividend Per Share for FY 2024-25
IAS-Vikas-Anand-resized
IAS Officer Vikas Anand Repatriated to Join Delhi CM’s Office, Know More About Him
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IMG-20250429-WA0019
How Mission IAS is Transforming Dreams of Underprivileged UPSC Aspirants
Aakash Garg
Computer Engineer Aakash Garg Takes AIR-5 in UPSC CSE 2024 Through Sheer Discipline And Hard Work | Exclusive
Sandeep M Tamgadge
How IPS Sandeep M Tamgadge’s Journey Can Guide Your UPSC Preparation
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
Shubham Kaurav UPSC
Four Attempts, One Dream: How Shubham Kaurav Cracked UPSC CSE with AIR 291
With determination, self-study, and a strategic mindset, Gwalior’s Shubham Kaurav turned years of hard...
Shruti Maloo UPSC
From Reserve List to AIR 534: How Maharashtra's Shruti Maloo Reached the Interview Stage in All Her UPSC Attempts
Shruti Maloo’s UPSC journey is a story of perseverance, strategy, and resilience. After three attempts,...
Abhi-jain-IAS-story-2025-04-7912a774cc9e0c21ed0d6dfdc092c74d
A Farmer's Son, A Nation's Servant: Abhi Jain, AIR 34 in UPSC CSE 2024
Farmer’s son Abhi Jain cracked UPSC in his fifth attempt, securing AIR 34 without coaching—balancing...
Social Media
Shakti Dubey AIR 1
UPSC Rank 1 Shakti Dubey's Success Sparks Debate on Civil Services Examination System, Ex-IPS Officer Raises Questions
Shakti Dubey’s UPSC Rank 1 success has sparked debate after ex-IPS officer Yashovardhan Azad questioned...
IAS Pulkit Garg
Central Jail Road Transforms into a Vibrant People-Centric Street in Varanasi
This road has been given a soul, the soul of a musical path, adorned with pink enamel folk art and every...
Rajan Singh Ex-IPS
Ex-IPS Officer Rajan Singh Shares Powerful Insight on Influence through Action
Mr. Rajan Singh is an ex-IPS officer of the 1997-batch (Kerala cadre) and founder of HabitStrong Org...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
sagayam-ias
Retired IAS Officer U Sagayam Cites Security Threat, Skips Court Appearance in Granite Scam Case - Know About Him
Surendra-Singh-Yadav IPS
Former Chandigarh DGP Surendra Singh Yadav Faces Setback as Court Rejects Challenge to Transfer Orders to BSF
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IMG-20250429-WA0019
Aakash Garg
Sandeep M Tamgadge
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT