https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

UPSC Rank 1 Shakti Dubey’s Success Sparks Debate on Civil Services Examination System, Ex-IPS Officer Raises Questions

Shakti Dubey’s UPSC Rank 1 success has sparked debate after ex-IPS officer Yashovardhan Azad questioned the exam’s long preparation period, prompting mixed reactions about youth employment and the UPSC system's relevance.
Indian Masterminds Stories

New Delhi: On April 22, when the UPSC results were announced, Shakti Dubey, a resident of Prayagraj, Uttar Pradesh, has emerged as the topper of the UPSC Civil Services Examination 2025, securing the All India Rank 1. Shakti’s success is particularly remarkable, as she surpassed over 9 lakh candidates to achieve this prestigious rank.

However, her success has ignited a debate on the UPSC examination system. Yashovardhan Jha Azad, a former IPS officer, took to social media to raise questions about the length of time it takes to prepare for the UPSC, with some critics questioning whether the years spent preparing are worth the results.

Mr Azad congratulated Shakti for her securing top rank but mistakenly referred to her as “Shikha Dubey.” Despite this error, it was evident that Azad was referring to Shakti, given the context of his post.

In a post shared on X (formerly Twitter), Azad expressed concern about the toll the process takes on aspirants. He pointed out that Shakti’s success came after five attempts, which means she spent six years preparing, a period he believes could be better spent gaining skills or contributing to society in other ways. Azad emphasized that the UPSC process often leads youth to waste their best years in coaching institutes.

He wrote, “5 attempts means 6 years of toil – the best years of youth gone in coaching? There were 5 lakhs who tried and keep trying. Should we subject our precious youth to waste years & years on an exam?”

Azad went further to suggest that the UPSC system needs reform, advocating for a reduction in the number of attempts and an age limit of 25 for applicants. He also voiced concerns over the growing influence of coaching institutes, claiming they profit heavily from the current system.

However, not everyone agrees with Azad’s criticism. Many netizens, including users like UPSC mentor Vironika, have respectfully disagreed with his perspective.

Ms Vironika argued that the issue lies not with UPSC but with the lack of opportunities in the job market, which forces many to turn to the UPSC exam as a viable career path. She pointed out that UPSC is one of the few transparent, merit-based systems left, providing a structured path for aspirants who have limited options elsewhere.

Ms Vironika wrote, “The problem is not UPSC. The problem is everything else. UPSC is the only national-level exam still conducted on time with transparency. It provides hope, direction, and dignity to lakhs who find no support from a broken job market.”

She further highlighted that many aspirants, including this year’s top scorer Shakti Dubey, are balancing jobs while preparing for UPSC, showing that it’s possible to contribute professionally while aiming for civil services. Vironika emphasized that the lack of viable alternatives and functional job recruitment systems is a bigger issue.

“The lack of alternatives is the real problem,” she concluded, urging for improvements in state exams, Group A/B recruitments, and the creation of lateral entry paths for candidates who seek other career options.

The debate underscores the larger conversation around the UPSC system, youth employment, and the challenges faced by millions of job seekers in India.


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
IPS-logo-resized_new
3 Senior IPS Officers Reassigned in Odisha After Central Deputation, Susanta Kumar Nath Made DG, Prisons and Correctional Services
IAS Sanjeev Hans
Suspended IAS Officer Sanjeev Hans Booked in New Vigilance Case Alongside Rishu Ranjan Sinha
NBCC-CIIMoU
NBCC and CII Join Hands to Establish Multi-Skill Training Institute and Model Career Centre in Delhi
Bank of India_BOI-resized
Bank of India and Sa-Dhan Sign MoU to Boost Financing for Small and Women-Led Enterprises
ITI Limited
ITI Limited Receives ₹50 Crore Tranche from C-DOT Following Revised AMRCD Order for Land Transfer Deal 
ONGC_resized
PESB Initiates Process to Appoint New CMD at ONGC Ahead of Arun Kumar Singh's Retirement
Indian Overseas Bank (IOB)
Indian Overseas Bank Posts 30% Jump in Q4FY25 Net Profit, Reports Strong Asset Quality
C Suvarna IFS
Who is IFS Dr. C. Suvarna, Took Additional Charge as Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Telangana?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IMG-20250429-WA0019
How Mission IAS is Transforming Dreams of Underprivileged UPSC Aspirants
Aakash Garg
Computer Engineer Aakash Garg Takes AIR-5 in UPSC CSE 2024 Through Sheer Discipline And Hard Work | Exclusive
Sandeep M Tamgadge
How IPS Sandeep M Tamgadge’s Journey Can Guide Your UPSC Preparation
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
Anju Singh UPSC
From COVID Dream to AIR 60: The Unlikely Journey of Anju Singh, Who Cracked UPSC in Her 4th Attempt | Exclusive
Anju Singh, an IIT Kharagpur Economics graduate, pursued UPSC with unwavering dedication. After four...
WhatsApp Image 2025-04-30 at 14.21
At 40, with Two Kids, Hearing Impairment, and a Dream, Nisa Unnirajan Made It: AIR-1000, CSE 2024
At 40, juggling motherhood, a full-time job, and a hearing disability, Nisa Unnirajan cleared UPSC in...
Ashi Sharma
How an Architect Ashi Sharma Redesigned Her Future
After shifting from architecture to civil services, Ashi Sharma cracked the UPSC with AIR 12 in her third...
Social Media
Shakti Dubey AIR 1
UPSC Rank 1 Shakti Dubey's Success Sparks Debate on Civil Services Examination System, Ex-IPS Officer Raises Questions
Shakti Dubey’s UPSC Rank 1 success has sparked debate after ex-IPS officer Yashovardhan Azad questioned...
IAS Pulkit Garg
Central Jail Road Transforms into a Vibrant People-Centric Street in Varanasi
This road has been given a soul, the soul of a musical path, adorned with pink enamel folk art and every...
Rajan Singh Ex-IPS
Ex-IPS Officer Rajan Singh Shares Powerful Insight on Influence through Action
Mr. Rajan Singh is an ex-IPS officer of the 1997-batch (Kerala cadre) and founder of HabitStrong Org...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
IPS-logo-resized_new
3 Senior IPS Officers Reassigned in Odisha After Central Deputation, Susanta Kumar Nath Made DG, Prisons and Correctional Services
IAS Sanjeev Hans
Suspended IAS Officer Sanjeev Hans Booked in New Vigilance Case Alongside Rishu Ranjan Sinha
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IMG-20250429-WA0019
Aakash Garg
Sandeep M Tamgadge
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT