https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

The Art Of Saying No To The Chief Minister And Still Surviving

This extract from former Civil Servant Mr Anil Swarup's much acclaimed book - Ethical Dilemmas Of A Civil Servant - shows how a Civil Servant can refuse to acquiesce before political masters if he is working as per the rule book. What can happen to him - at the most a transfer. But, that is part of the job. One always has a choice to make his own reputation - that of a no nonsense officer or the one without a spine.
Indian Masterminds Stories

It was 1991. I had been District Magistrate (DM) of Lakhimpur Kheri for about a year. Since 1990 the country was facing an unprecedented crisis on account of the ‘Rath Yatra’ (Chariot Tour) being taken out by Lal Krishna Advani, a leader of the Bhartiya Janata Party, to advocate the construction of the Ram Temple at Ayodhya. As Ayodhya was in Uttar Pradesh, the state had become the epicentre of all allied agitations.

Ruling Party Leader Arrested

Against this backdrop a murder took place. It was purely a criminal act. But the District President of the ruling party (Janata Dal, predecessor of Samajwadi Party) wanted to make political capital out of it by taking out a funeral procession. If allowed, this could have been a recipe for disaster and would have led to communal riots as was the case in neighbouring districts. Permission to take out the procession was denied.

However, as the District President insisted on taking out the procession, he was arrested and put behind bars under the provisions relating to preventive detention.

The CM Called

Though this arrest took care of the law and order issues, it didn’t go down well with the ruling party. It was late that night when I received a call from the Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh. He sounded quite agitated. He got down to business immediately without bothering to exchange the usual pleasantries. “DM sahib, why have you arrested and imprisoned my District President?” he asked straight away.

My response was equally forthright, “Sir, a murder had taken place and he insisted on taking out a funeral procession that would have destroyed the peace in the city. Given the charged atmosphere, it would have led to communal riots. I tried to persuade him not to take out the procession but he was not relenting. Hence, we had no option but to arrest him in the interest of sustaining peace.”

CM Capitulates

There was a brief pause at the other end but he came up with another question “Isn’t there some other way?” I was firm but polite in responding, “Sir, had there been some other way, we would not have arrested him. The only possible way now is for someone from Lucknow to speak to him so that he doesn’t insist on taking out a procession. We can then release him.” I carried on, “Sir, you are aware that Lakhimpur Kheri is the only district where we haven’t had to impose curfew as everyone believes that we will take action without any favour”. There was yet another pause before he responded, “Theek Hai (okay)” and disconnected the call.

MS Swarup with his first book, Mot Just A Civil Servant

Party Chief Released

Later on I learnt that he apparently spoke to the District President himself. Consequently, the local chief agreed not to take out the funeral procession. The burial of the dead took place in the dead of the night. The chief was released promptly the next day.

Lakhimpur remained peaceful during the trying period of the Babri Masjid agitation. I was pleasantly surprised when I was awarded for handling the law and order in the district adroitly by the CM himself. Peace in the district could be maintained on account of an absolutely amazing team of officers comprising the likes of Harish Chandra Singh, Superintendent of Police; Rudra Pratap Singh, Sub-Divisional Magistrate; R K Chaturvedi, Circle Officer and many others. The team also ensured that we lived up to the expectations of the residents of the district.

The Book Release Function

(Anil Swarup retired from the Civil Services (U.P. Cadre) in 2019. His last stint was Secretary (School Education), Government of India. Prior to that as Coal Secretary, he ensured first-ever online auction of coal mines in India. He is also the architect of Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY), a precursor of present Ayushman Bharat Scheme, providing free health insurance to the poor. He has written two books Not Just A Civil Servant and Ethical Dilemmas of A Civil Servant. He is also taken up a great initiative bringing all philanthropists, especially bureaucrats, together at nexusofgood.org.in.)


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
SunilGupta
Sunil Gupta Appointed as Director (Operation & Commercial) of Konkan Railway Corporation Limited
Mishra Dhatu Nigam Limited (MIDHANI)
HAL Gains Amid Defence Stock Surge Following Operation Sindoor; Mishra Dhatu Nigam Leads with 15% Jump
UnmeshSharadWagh
Additional Charge of JNPA Chairperson Extended for Unmesh Sharad Wagh- know more about him
Bird Flu in UP
Zoos Across Uttar Pradesh Shut for a Week After Bird Flu Found in Tigress
NLC-INDIA-resized-neyvili
NLC India Ltd & IIT Madras Sign MoU to Advance Carbon Capture Technology for Cleaner Thermal Power
IREDA logo 1
IREDA Initiates Insolvency Proceedings Against Gensol Engineering Over ₹510 Crore Loan Default
accounting-fraud_505_022612034947
Senior IAS Navin Mittal Falls Victim to Facebook Impersonation Scam, ₹99,000 Duped from Acquaintance
IAS Officers Indian Administrative Services (IAS)
SIT Questions Ex-IAS Officer, Former OSD to Jagan Mohan Reddy in Liquor Scam, Bharati Cements Director Sent to Judicial Custody
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Uday Krishna Reddy
Uday Krishna Reddy’s Rise from Constable to IPS Hopeful | Video Interview 
IPS Sandeep Tamgadge
IPS Sandeep Tamgadge’s Two Decades of Service in Nagaland
IMG-20250429-WA0019
How Mission IAS is Transforming Dreams of Underprivileged UPSC Aspirants
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
WhatsApp Image 2025-05-13 at 17.10
Simran of Jind: From a Quiet Haryana Village to AIR 66 in UPSC
Jind’s Simran Kharb secured AIR 66 in UPSC on her third attempt, fulfilling her father’s dream and inspiring...
Uday Krishna Reddy
Uday Krishna Reddy’s Rise from Constable to IPS Hopeful | Video Interview 
Uday Krishna Reddy, a name now synonymous with dedication in the challenging world of the UPSC Civil...
WhatsApp Image 2025-05-08 at 15.21
From Courtrooms to the Corridors of Power, The Inspiring Journey of Kshitij Aditya Sharma, AIR-58, CSE’24
From corporate suits to Constitution roots, Kshitij Sharma ditched a plush lawyer’s life, cracked UPSC...
Social Media
Anupam Sharma IFS
#BoycottTurkey: IFS Officer Anupam Sharma Sparks Nationalist Call to Action
IFS Sharma urged citizens to avoid Turkish agricultural imports
Vikram Misri IFS
United Front Against "Nameless" Trolls! After IAS, IPS, & IFoS Officers, Nation's Top Diplomats Rally in Support of Foreign Secy Vikram Misri
The trolling, coming from “nameless, faceless” sources, has sparked widespread condemnation, especially...
IPS Arun Bothra
“Bangalore Has Only USB Ports”: IPS Arun Bothra Mocks Viral Claim of Pakistan Navy Attack
A viral claim about Pakistan Navy destroying “Bangalore Port” drew ridicule, with officers mocking it...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
SunilGupta
Sunil Gupta Appointed as Director (Operation & Commercial) of Konkan Railway Corporation Limited
Mishra Dhatu Nigam Limited (MIDHANI)
HAL Gains Amid Defence Stock Surge Following Operation Sindoor; Mishra Dhatu Nigam Leads with 15% Jump
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Uday Krishna Reddy
IPS Sandeep Tamgadge
IMG-20250429-WA0019
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT