New Delhi: The Supreme Court scrutiny of High Court judgments has gained attention after the top court proposed a nationwide exercise to identify objectionable remarks about women in judicial decisions. Chief Justice of India Surya Kant suggested that State Judicial Academies examine High Court judgments and identify gender-insensitive observations. The proposal could allow respective High Courts to take suo motu action and remove inappropriate remarks from their judgments.
Details of SC High Court Women Objectionable Remarks Review Ruling
A three-judge Bench of the Supreme Court, headed by CJI Surya Kant and comprising Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana, discussed the need to examine judicial decisions containing objectionable observations about women.
The Bench suggested that State Judicial Academies could review judgments delivered by their respective High Courts.
The purpose would be to identify inappropriate remarks and bring them to the attention of the concerned High Courts.
The Supreme Court also indicated that the respective High Courts could initiate suo motu proceedings to expunge such remarks from their judgments. However, this was a proposal discussed during the hearing. The Court had not yet issued a final nationwide direction for the exercise.
Why Did The Supreme Court Raise This Issue
The discussion took place during the hearing of a suo motu case related to a July 9, 2026, judgment of the Patna High Court.
The Patna High Court had set aside the conviction of Himanshu Pathak in a 2008 case involving allegations of sexual assault.
According to the prosecution, the accused had allegedly locked a woman inside his photography studio, attempted to remove her salwar and pressed her chest.
The trial court had convicted him of attempt to rape and wrongful confinement. However, the Patna High Court held that the alleged acts did not establish the offence of attempt to rape under the relevant legal provisions. It considered that the allegations could attract Section 354 of the Indian Penal Code, which deals with assault or criminal force against a woman with the intention of outraging her modesty.
The High Court consequently set aside the conviction under the charges for which the accused had been tried.
The Supreme Court later took suo motu cognisance of the judgment and expressed concern over certain observations made in it.
High Court Women Objectionable Remarks Review: Supreme Court Had Earlier Taken Suo Motu Action
This is not the first time the Supreme Court has raised concerns about inappropriate remarks made during judicial proceedings.
In September 2024, the Supreme Court took suo motu action over certain remarks made by a Karnataka High Court judge during court proceedings.
In its September 25, 2024, judgment in In Re: Remarks By High Court Judge During Court Proceedings, the Supreme Court expressed serious concern over comments relating to gender and a particular community.
The Court stressed that judges must remain impartial and avoid observations that could be seen as misogynistic or prejudicial.
It also highlighted that judicial remarks can have a wider impact because court proceedings are increasingly accessible through live streaming and social media.
This earlier judgment highlights the importance of responsible language in the Indian judicial system.
High Court Women Objectionable Remarks Review: Details of November 16 Hearing
During the latest hearing, Senior Advocate Shobha Gupta, who is assisting the Supreme Court Bench, raised concerns about other judgments containing objectionable observations about women.
She argued that the issue was not limited to the Patna High Court judgment and highlighted the need to examine similar judicial decisions. The counsel appearing for Himanshu Pathak requested additional time to submit a response.
The Supreme Court granted one week’s time and deferred the hearing. The Bench also asked the lawyers to remind it at the next hearing about issuing directions to State Judicial Academies to examine High Court judgments. Bihar Advocate General SD Sanjay appeared in the matter.
Read also: India’s Bold Renewable Energy Vision With Transformative Policies
FAQs
State Judicial Academies may be asked to examine judgments delivered by their respective High Courts and identify objectionable observations about women.
The Supreme Court proposed the review to identify objectionable and gender-insensitive remarks about women in High Court judgments and explore ways to remove such observations.
Yes. High Courts can consider initiating suo motu proceedings to expunge inappropriate observations from their judgments, subject to the applicable legal process and judicial directions.














