20 November 2026
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Supreme Court Strikes Down APTEL Review Order For Violating Article 141

The Supreme Court has strongly reprimanded APTEL for overturning an issue already settled by its earlier judgment. Calling the Tribunal's action a breach of judicial discipline, the Court restored its 2019 order and imposed ₹3.5 lakh in costs on Maithan Alloys and SAIL.
Supreme Court Collegium RTI
Indian Masterminds Stories

New Delhi: The Supreme Court of India has strongly criticised the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (APTEL) for reviewing an earlier order that was already upheld by the Supreme Court. The Court said the Tribunal had crossed its legal limits and violated judicial discipline. It also imposed a total cost of ₹3.5 lakh on the parties who supported the review order.

Supreme Court Criticises APTEL For Ignoring Its Earlier Judgment

The Supreme Court strongly criticised APTEL on October 30, 2026, for reviewing its earlier decision in a dispute involving Damodar Valley Corporation (DVC) and Maithan Alloys Limited.

Read also: This Supreme Court Observation Could Redefine How Public Office Is Viewed In India

A Bench of Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran observed that the Tribunal had acted against a binding judgment of the Supreme Court.

The Bench expressed serious concern over the Tribunal’s actions and remarked that APTEL had “gone haywire“. The Court also described the Tribunal’s action as a blatant breach of judicial discipline.

APTEL Review Order: What Was The Dispute Between DVC And Maithan Alloys

The case relates to the electricity tariff determination of Damodar Valley Corporation for the period between 2009 and 2014.

The Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC) had allowed DVC to treat contributions made to its Sinking Fund as recoverable expenditure through electricity tariffs. The Sinking Fund was maintained by DVC to repay or redeem its bonds.

Maithan Alloys Limited challenged this decision, leading to a dispute over whether DVC could recover these contributions through electricity tariffs.

APTEL’s 2019 Decision And The Supreme Court’s Earlier Judgment

In 2019, APTEL upheld the decision that allowed DVC to recover its Sinking Fund contributions through electricity tariffs.

While reaching its decision, the Tribunal relied on the Supreme Court’s judgment in Bhaskar Shrachi Alloys Limited v. Damodar Valley Corporation (2018).

However, the matter returned to APTEL in 2024 after Maithan Alloys filed a review petition more than five years after the earlier decision.

The Tribunal allowed the review and held that permitting both depreciation on assets created using bond proceeds and Sinking Fund contributions would result in double benefit. This decision prompted DVC to approach the Supreme Court.

Supreme Court Says APTEL Review Order Violated Judicial Discipline

The Supreme Court found that APTEL had acted beyond the limits of its review jurisdiction.

The Bench observed that the Tribunal had ignored a binding precedent of the Supreme Court while reviewing its earlier decision. The Court explained that a review can only be allowed on limited legal grounds.

An error must be clearly visible in the record. It should not require lengthy arguments or a detailed examination to identify it. The Supreme Court held that APTEL’s review exercise did not meet these legal requirements.

Supreme Court Sets Aside APTEL’s Review Order

Allowing DVC’s appeal, the Supreme Court set aside the Tribunal’s review order. The Bench held that APTEL had wrongly reopened an issue that had already been settled by its earlier decision, which was upheld in 2019. 

The Court strongly objected to the Tribunal’s decision to revisit the matter despite the binding legal position. It emphasised that judicial discipline requires tribunals to follow the decisions of higher courts.

Supreme Court Imposes ₹3.5 Lakh Cost

The Supreme Court also imposed costs on the parties who supported the review order. The Court directed:

  • Maithan Alloys Limited: To pay ₹2 lakh.
  • Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL): To pay ₹1.5 lakh.

The total cost imposed by the Supreme Court was ₹3.5 lakh. The decision sends a strong message that tribunals must follow binding judgments and cannot reopen settled issues without valid legal grounds.

Read also: No Service, No Payment: Supreme Court Strengthens Consumer Rights in India With Verdict on Unused Service Charges

FAQs

What Was The Dispute Between DVC And Maithan Alloys?

The dispute concerned DVC’s electricity tariff determination for 2009–2014. The main issue was whether DVC could recover contributions made to its Sinking Fund through electricity tariffs.

Why Did The Supreme Court Criticise APTEL In 2026?

The Supreme Court criticised APTEL for reviewing its earlier decision despite a binding Supreme Court judgment. It held that the Tribunal had violated judicial discipline and exceeded the limits of its review jurisdiction.

How Much Cost Did The Supreme Court Impose On Maithan Alloys And SAIL?

The Supreme Court imposed ₹2 lakh in costs on Maithan Alloys Limited and ₹1.5 lakh on Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL). The total amount was ₹3.5 lakh.


Indian Masterminds Stories
Join our WhatsApp Channel
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
BHASHINI NIELIT MoU
BHASHINI, NIELIT Join Hands to Bring Multilingual AI to Technical Education; Students to Access Learning in Indian Languages
HARIMAU SHAKTI 2026
India-Malaysia Military Exercise HARIMAU SHAKTI–VI Begins in Malaysia; 240 Personnel to Train in Counter-Terror Operations
government-of-haryana
Haryana Reshuffles 32 IFS Officers; Shiva Kumar Gets Gurugram Charge, Jitender Ahlawat to Head South Circle
Aero India
Aero India 2027 Media Registration Opens; Journalists Must Apply by January 4
IAS Archana Singh
Rajasthan Sampark 181: IAS Archana Singh Calls for Separate Classification of Grievances, Stresses Timely IPR Filing
ChhattisgarhGovt_resized
Chhattisgarh Promotes Four IAS Officers; Subodh Singh and Niharika Barik Elevated to ACS Rank
Madhya Pradesh Sports Development
MP Sports Development: 11 Academies, 201 International Medals and World-Class Facilities Under CM Mohan Yadav
MoHUA Resized
PM SVANidhi Samman Awards 2026: 52 Awards to Honour Contributions to Street Vendors’ Empowerment
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Five years after Kargil, India sent its cricketing heroes to Pakistan where terrorism posed a deadly threat. The man guarding them, former Special Director of Intelligence Bureau, Mr. Yashovardhan Azad, reveals what all went behind the scenes during that crucial tour. 
Trust No One, Said His Instinct in Pakistan
Gajendra Singh Shekhawat
How India Plans to Boost Tourism, Create Jobs and Ease Overcrowding : Gajendra Singh Shekhawat on the Road to 2047
Dr Saket Badola IFS
Beyond Tigers and Safaris: How Corbett Literature Festival Wants to Change the Conservation Conversation
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
Mayank Gurjar
He Lost His Father in Class 12, Then Cleared UPSC in One Attempt to Become an IPS Officer
After losing his father in Class 12, Mayank Gurjar held on to his dream of public service, graduated...
Gautam UPSC
He Studied at 4 AM in a 10×10 Mumbai Slum Room; Today, Gautam Padibhar is an Indian Forest Service Officer
Meet IFS officer Gautam Padhibhar, a 2023-batch Chhattisgarh cadre officer who rose from financial hardship...
Aniket Sagar ICoAS
No Coaching, Full-Time Job and Two Attempts: How Aniket Sagar Cleared ICoAS
Aniket Sagar, a chartered accountant from Bundelkhand, cleared UPSC ICoAS 2025 after working at PwC,...
CSR NEWS
Coal India CSR Programme
Coal India Organises CSR Programme to Align Mining Operations with Community Development 
Initiative Aims to Strengthen CSR Implementation in Coal-Bearing Regions and Improve Community Well-Being...
hurl
HURL Signs MoU with Injot Trust to Launch Project ANGOR for Children's Education in Assam
The three-year CSR initiative will cover five locations in Assam, focusing on holistic education, digital...
cmpdil
CMPDIL Partners with Tata Steel Foundation to Upgrade Technical Education at ITI Tamar 
The project will modernise training infrastructure with robotic welding technology, digital learning...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
BHASHINI NIELIT MoU
BHASHINI, NIELIT Join Hands to Bring Multilingual AI to Technical Education; Students to Access Learning in Indian Languages
HARIMAU SHAKTI 2026
India-Malaysia Military Exercise HARIMAU SHAKTI–VI Begins in Malaysia; 240 Personnel to Train in Counter-Terror Operations
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Five years after Kargil, India sent its cricketing heroes to Pakistan where terrorism posed a deadly threat. The man guarding them, former Special Director of Intelligence Bureau, Mr. Yashovardhan Azad, reveals what all went behind the scenes during that crucial tour. 
Gajendra Singh Shekhawat
Dr Saket Badola IFS
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT