Jaipur: An examination of the Immovable Property Returns (IPRs) filed by 283 IAS officers of Rajasthan has revealed significant gaps in the disclosure of their property details, including purchase prices, current market values, dimensions and locations.
According to an analysis of the declarations, these officers have reported owning a total of 623 immovable properties, comprising 240 houses and flats and 383 plots and land parcels. However, a substantial number of officers have either failed to disclose the purchase cost of their properties or have not provided their current market valuation.
According to Dainik Bhaskar report, of the 283 officers examined, 128 have not provided adequate information about the purchase price or current market value of their properties. As many as 71 officers did not disclose purchase prices, while 50 failed to provide current market valuations. Incomplete information about property dimensions and locations has further complicated the assessment of their declared assets.
The disclosures also show that 82 officers have declared zero immovable assets, while senior officers at the Additional Chief Secretary (ACS) and Principal Secretary levels collectively hold a considerably larger share of the declared properties.
The issue has attracted attention following a Dainik Bhaskar investigation into the property declarations of IAS officer Shikhar Agrawal. The IPR portal was taken offline following the report and subsequently restored on Sunday. After its restoration, the newspaper examined the property disclosures of Rajasthan IAS officers.
283 IAS Officers Declare 623 Properties in IPR
The analysis of the IPR filings reveals that 283 IAS officers have declared a combined 623 immovable properties across different categories of seniority.
The properties include residential houses, flats, plots and agricultural or other land holdings. Of the total 623 properties, 240 are houses or flats, while 383 are plots or land parcels.
The distribution across different administrative levels is as follows:
- Additional Chief Secretary (ACS): 22 officers declared 102 properties, including 47 houses/flats and 55 plots/land parcels.
- Principal Secretary: 13 officers declared 45 properties, comprising 17 houses/flats and 28 plots/land parcels.
- Secretary and Other Ranks: 248 officers declared 476 properties, including 176 houses/flats and 300 plots/land parcels.
- Total: 283 IAS officers declared 623 properties, comprising 240 houses/flats and 383 plots/land parcels.
The figures indicate that the 22 ACS-rank officers have declared 102 properties, while 13 Principal Secretaries have reported 45 properties. The remaining 248 officers, including Secretaries and other ranks, account for 476 properties.
The disclosures also reveal that senior officers at the ACS and Principal Secretary levels hold a substantially higher concentration of properties compared with officers at the Secretary level and below. According to the report, their combined property holdings are around eight times higher.
Some officers have declared ownership of seven to eight flats, while others have reported extensive land holdings.
Read also: IAS Shikhar Agrawal Returns to Jaipur After US Visit; ACB May Question Him in 40-Villa Case
82 IAS Officers Declare Zero Immovable Assets
One of the notable findings of the analysis is that 82 IAS officers have declared zero immovable assets in their returns.
This means these officers have reported no immovable property in their declarations, including ancestral property.
The finding has attracted attention because the number includes officers across different levels of seniority, from senior administrative positions to comparatively junior ranks.
At the same time, the disclosures of several other officers contain incomplete information, making it difficult to establish the actual value and extent of their property holdings.
128 Officers Fail to Disclose Purchase Price or Market Value
A major concern emerging from the IPR analysis is the absence of reliable valuation details.
Of the 283 IAS officers examined, 128 have either not disclosed the purchase price of their properties or have failed to provide their current market valuation.
The breakdown reveals that 71 officers did not mention the purchase price of their properties, while 50 did not provide their current market value.
Some officers have reportedly relied on the District Level Committee (DLC) rates to declare property values. However, DLC rates are often considerably different from prevailing market prices.
As a result, the declared figures may not accurately represent the actual market worth of the properties.
The analysis also found that 15 per cent of officers had provided incomplete information about property dimensions. In one instance, an officer declared ownership of six properties but provided measurements for only two.
Without information about the size of a house, flat or land parcel, it becomes difficult to independently assess whether the declared valuation reflects its actual worth.
ACS Officers: 102 Properties, But Several Details Missing
The 22 officers at the Additional Chief Secretary level have declared a total of 102 properties, including 47 houses and flats and 55 plots or land parcels.
However, the disclosures of several senior officers contain gaps in purchase prices, market valuations, dimensions and locations.
Purchase cost missing: Two ACS-rank officers have not disclosed the purchase cost of six properties acquired over the previous six years.
Market valuation not provided: Eight officers have not disclosed the current market value of their properties and have reportedly relied on DLC rates instead.
Property dimensions missing: Among nine ACS officers whose property details were examined in this context, only four provided the area or dimensions of their 26 properties. This has made it difficult to establish the actual value of several assets.
One officer reportedly declared a house worth only ₹6 lakh without providing its size, making it difficult to assess the accuracy of the valuation.
Jewels of India flats: Three ACS-rank officers have declared ownership of flats in the residential project Jewels of India. While one officer valued the flat at ₹2.07 crore, two other IAS officers declared their respective flats at ₹6 crore each.
According to property-market experts quoted in the report, the prevailing price of a 3BHK unit in the project ranges between ₹6 crore and ₹8 crore.
Property locations not disclosed: One ACS officer did not disclose the location of four out of six declared properties.
The analysis also found that nine ACS-rank officers had acquired 18 properties outside Rajasthan.
Principal Secretaries: 45 Properties, Several Valuation Gaps
The 13 Principal Secretaries in Rajasthan have collectively declared 45 immovable properties, comprising 17 houses and flats and 28 plots or land parcels.
Of these properties, nine are located outside Rajasthan.
However, the returns filed by officers at this level also contain gaps in valuation and property-related information.
Six Principal Secretaries did not disclose the current market value of their properties, while five failed to mention the purchase price of the assets declared in their IPRs.
Three officers also did not provide the dimensions or area of their land and houses, making it difficult to assess their actual market worth.
The disclosures indicate that even among officers holding senior administrative positions, important details necessary for evaluating property declarations are missing.
Secretaries and Other Officers: 71 Don’t Disclose Purchase Cost
The largest group in the analysis comprises 248 IAS officers at the Secretary level and below, who have declared a combined 476 properties.
These include 176 houses and flats and 300 plots or land parcels.
However, their disclosures also reveal substantial gaps in property valuation.
Among Secretaries and Joint Secretaries, 71 officers have not disclosed the purchase price of their properties, while 36 have not provided their current market value.
Another 40 officers have reportedly declared property values based on DLC rates, which may differ significantly from prevailing market prices.
The analysis also found that 60 officers have not provided the dimensions or area of their land and residential properties.
Consequently, determining the actual value of these assets becomes difficult.
51 Land Purchases Made Outside Rajasthan
Of the 300 land acquisitions declared by Secretaries and other IAS officers, 51 were made outside Rajasthan.
In many cases, officers have purchased land or houses in their home states or in locations where they have ancestral property.
The disclosure of property locations is also incomplete in several cases.
Out of 243 Secretaries and other IAS officers whose location details were examined, 218 disclosed the locations of their properties, while 25 failed to specify where the properties had been purchased.
This lack of location information, along with missing measurements and valuations, makes independent assessment of the declarations more difficult.
60 Officers Purchase Properties Outside Rajasthan
Across the different seniority levels, 60 IAS officers have reportedly purchased properties outside Rajasthan.
The purchases include residential properties and land parcels in different states.
In several instances, officers have acquired properties in their native states or places associated with their ancestral holdings.
The disclosures underline the geographical spread of the assets owned by Rajasthan-cadre IAS officers. However, incomplete information in several returns has made it difficult to determine the precise value and dimensions of all these properties.
Former Chief Secretary DB Gupta Calls for Dedicated IPR Scrutiny Cell
The gaps identified in the property declarations have raised questions about the effectiveness of the existing verification mechanism.
Former Rajasthan Chief Secretary DB Gupta has called for the establishment of a dedicated scrutiny cell within the Department of Personnel (DoP) to examine the information submitted by officers in their Immovable Property Returns.
According to him, the existing IPR proforma is clear, but the information provided by officers needs to be properly scrutinised before the returns are accepted.
He has suggested that if an officer or government employee submits incorrect, incomplete or ambiguous information, the return should be sent back for clarification.
A declaration should be treated as complete only after the concerned authorities are satisfied with the details furnished.
Gupta said: “The proforma for filing the Immovable Property Return (IPR) is clear; however, the Department of Personnel (DoP) should establish a dedicated cell to review the information provided. This cell should scrutinize the details submitted in the IPRs. If an officer or employee provides incorrect or ambiguous information, the filing should be returned to them for clarification. A submission should be considered complete only after the authorities are satisfied with the information provided.”
His suggestion places the responsibility on the administrative department to ensure that property declarations are not merely submitted but also contain sufficient and verifiable information.
Transparency in Property Disclosures Under Question
The findings have brought renewed attention to the quality of property disclosures made by senior bureaucrats in Rajasthan.
While the 283 officers have collectively declared 623 properties, missing purchase prices, market valuations, dimensions and locations have created significant gaps in the available information.
The declaration of zero assets by 82 officers has also become a point of discussion, although the figures alone do not establish any wrongdoing.
The central issue emerging from the analysis is whether the existing IPR verification system is sufficiently equipped to identify incomplete or ambiguous disclosures.
With former Chief Secretary DB Gupta advocating a dedicated scrutiny mechanism, the focus has now shifted towards strengthening the verification of property returns and ensuring that the information submitted by public servants is complete, transparent and assessable.














