https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

“Too Much of Democracy”, And The Storm It Created

Statements by civil servants have the potential to bring a tsunami of reactions Hence, they need to be cautious while giving public statements Even a statement made in private can get leaked and create a furore
Indian Masterminds Stories

A couple of years ago, a “Too much of Democracy” statement by Amitabh Kant took the media by storm. I also couldn’t believe it and my first reaction was that it was a misquote. However, soon the video wherein he had made that statement came to light. What also came to light was the context in which such a statement was made. He himself went on to clarify his statement. I cannot recall any instance in my entire career when a statement by a serving civil servant led to so much reaction in the media and the public. Perhaps it was on account of the visibility that Amitabh Kant enjoyed in his capacity as Chief Executive Officer, NITI Ayog, a pretty high-profile organization itself. I have known Amitabh Kant in my professional capacity and I have absolutely no doubt that he is truly wedded to democratic norms. However, public statements by all civil servants (perhaps every high-profile individual) stand the risk of being misconstrued. Hence, it is always better to be cautious about what gets stated in the public domain, especially in the super-charged environment wherein anything can be interpreted to suit one’s convenience.

FACED SIMILAR SITUATION

I recall having gone through a similar situation when occupying the hot seat of Coal Secretary, Government of India, in 2015, though the environment then was not as charged.

‘Why to blame only netas, 5Cs also hinder decision making: Coal Secretary’. This was the headline of a leading daily that generated a tsunami of reactions. Perhaps almost everyone felt it, but no one had the courage to state it. It all began with small comments that I made on Facebook and Twitter:

“Pace of development is not so much impacted by the dishonest as by inhibiting factors that prevent the honest from taking decisions.”

This is what I truly believed, and it went viral on the net though it was still a storm in the teacup. However, the subsequent explanation in a closed personal group on Facebook created a tsunami as it impacted the holy cows of governance in the country:

“We very conveniently blame politicians for all the ills. However, isn’t it true that 5 Cs (namely CBI, CVC, CAG, CIC and Courts) contribute substantially in creating an inhibiting environment for quick and effective decision making that impact development? Ironically all these institutions are not occupied by politicians but by civil servants.”

DELUGE OF REACTIONS

There was a deluge of reactions, almost all of it in support of the aforementioned statement. An ex-Cabinet Secretary remarked, “Anil Swarup is spot on. To make matters worse, the C’s have begun playing more and more to the gallery in the last few years.”  A Secretary, known to be close to the powers, commented, “You have made very bold statement on FB.Kudos!” Another Secretary was equally forthright, “A truly bold statement, Anil. Cheers! You are changing the images of ‘bureaucrat’.” An ex-ambassador to the World Trade Organisation (WTO) quipped, “Well done, Anil. You have hit the nail squarely on the head.” A retired IPS officer, who had worked with the CBI agreed with the statement, “With my fairly long experience of CBI, I fully endorse the view of Anil.” Another IPS officer, heading a central paramilitary force, also commented, “He’s correct… We have often discussed this point. Ours is the only country where the aforesaid entities, rightly called commentators, are considered more important than players! Or, put differently, conductors of post-mortem more important than the doctor carrying out the diagnosis.”

Interestingly, one of the Cs mentioned was the CAG. An ex-DG of CAG went on to congratulate me for raising the issue, “Congratulations… for raising pertinent issues hindering good and fast decisions in Government.”

Some Cabinet ministers rang me up to congratulate me for raising the issue.

LESSON LEARNED

I had flagged an issue appropriately while I was still in service. Some of the persons manning these institutions had gone overboard to ‘play to the gallery’, killing initiative amongst those they left behind in the civil service and rendering decision making increasingly more difficult. No wonder governance has suffered and continues to suffer from the devastation caused by a CAG in the not-so-distant past and the likes of him. This was palpable in the Ministry of Coal where I sought to construct something after the massive destruction caused by the demolishing squad.

I had absolutely no qualms about the initial statement I made with regard to the factors inhibiting pace of development. I have always believed that without recognizing the inhibiting factors, correctives steps cannot be taken effectively.  Hence, there was no question of retracting or modifying what I said because I truly believed in what I said. There could, however, be a legitimate question about my making subsequent statement/clarification wherein I identified the agencies that were indeed inhibiting decision making. There could be a point of view that the subsequent statement/explanation could have been avoided as it embarrassed some of those occupying these ‘haloed’ institutions.

However, the statement that created a ‘tsunami’ was not made in public domain but in private one. It somehow got leaked. But there was a lesson for me. For a civil servant, nothing is private. Hence, I chose to be careful subsequently even in my private communications. However, it didn’t deter me from expressing my point of view in every file that came to me. All this was purely ‘official’, nothing private or public.


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike
Karnataka Govt Restructures Bengaluru Civic Setup; IAS, KAS Officers Assigned to GBA & 5 New Corporations
MP CM Mohan Yadav Morena Industry
Chambal Ravines to Renewable Revolution: CM Yadav Lays Foundation for ₹12,500 Cr Industrial Boost in Morena
shahdol-village Footballers MP
Shahdol Footballers to Train in Germany; PM Modi Highlights Madhya Pradesh’s Sporting Revolution
NeGD
Digital India Milestone: NeGD Enables Nationwide Integration of 1,938 e-Services via DigiLocker & e-District Platforms
Tamil Nadu Police: Senior IPS Officer G Venkatraman
IPS G. Venkataraman Appointed Acting DGP of Tamil Nadu Amid Deviation from SC Guidelines, Following Shankar Jiwal’s Retirement
MP News
MP: CM Yadav Unveils Rs. 10 Crore Development Blueprint for Chhatarpur; Stadiums, Medical College Boost, and Major Infra Push Announced
Yogi Government
UP to Introduce India’s First 'Ease of Doing Business Bill 2025', Yogi Government To Decriminalize 99% Industrial Laws
Madhya-Pradesh-State-IAS
Major IAS Transfers Expected in Madhya Pradesh After Chief Secy Anurag Jain's Extension, Ujjain & Indore Expecting Bureaucratic Overhaul
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IPS Mukesh Kumar Bhamoo
Managing Elections, Communal Tensions, and Public Safety – Meet IPS Mukesh Kumar Bhamoo | Video Interview
WhatsApp Image 2025-08-25 at 13.56
Operation Hunt: IPS Dr. Karanraj Vaghela’s Mission to Nab Valsad’s Most Wanted
Dr
Resisted Flawed Schemes, Transferred Thrice In Three Months, Found Solace In Writing
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
IAS Minnu P M
“Lazy, Sleepy, Yet Determined”: Minnu P M’s Honest Take on Cracking UPSC
Minnu PM, once a clerk in Kerala Police, cleared UPSC with AIR 150 after five years of struggle. Her...
IPS Ashish Tiwari
From IIT and Investment Banking to Public Service, Meet IPS Ashish Tiwari 
Ashish Tiwari, IIT graduate and former investment banker, chose public service over global finance. As...
WhatsApp Image 2025-08-12 at 7.27
First Attempt IRS, Fourth Attempt IPS: The Relentless Pursuit of Jitendra Kumar Yadav Who Cracked UPSC 3 Times
IPS Yadav is originally from Chhattisgarh. He was first selected for the IRS through UPSC and later for...
Social Media
Masahiro Hara
From Go Board to Global Use, How QR Codes Changed the World: IRAS Officer Ananth Rupanagudi Spotlights Masahiro Hara’s Vision
IRAS officer Ananth Rupanagudi shared a video on Masahiro Hara, the inventor of QR codes, highlighting...
IFS Susanta Nanda Video
A Mother’s Duty: Tigress Watches Over Cubs Splashing in Waterhole — Heartwarming Video Shared By Retd. IFS Officer Susanta Nanda
A tender wildlife video shared by Retd. IFS officer Susanta Nanda shows a tigress keeping watch over...
Mohanmala
Kaziranga Mourns: Beloved Elephant Mohanmala Passes Away After Five Decades of Service
Kaziranga National Park mourns the loss of Mohanmala, a beloved elephant who served over 50 years as...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike
Karnataka Govt Restructures Bengaluru Civic Setup; IAS, KAS Officers Assigned to GBA & 5 New Corporations
MP CM Mohan Yadav Morena Industry
Chambal Ravines to Renewable Revolution: CM Yadav Lays Foundation for ₹12,500 Cr Industrial Boost in Morena
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IPS Mukesh Kumar Bhamoo
WhatsApp Image 2025-08-25 at 13.56
Dr
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT