Indian MasterMinds
  • Switch to Hindi
  • Become a Contributor:  Know how?
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Advertise with us
Switch to Hindi
  • Home
  • Features
  • Videos
  • News
  • Movements
  • Opinion
  • UPSC Aspirants
  • IM Stories
  • Social Media
Indian MasterMinds
Switch to Hindi
  • Home
  • Features
  • Videos
  • News
  • Movements
  • Opinion
  • UPSC Aspirants
  • IM Stories
  • Social Media
HomeNewsUPSCSupreme Court Spikes ‘Rabid’ TV Show portraying ‘Jihad in Bureaucracy’

UPSC

Supreme Court Spikes ‘Rabid’ TV Show portraying ‘Jihad in Bureaucracy’

  • Indian Masterminds Bureau
  • Published on 16 Sep 2020, 5:13 pm IST
  • 5 minutes read

Highlights

The Supreme Court has conveyed to Sudarshan TV in no uncertain terms that it could not allow it to say “Muslims are infiltrating the civil services” and ordered the channel to stop airing its ‘UPSC Jihad’ series on the Bindass Bol show, pending further orders.

  • Share this article
featured banner
  • Supreme Court Of India (Photo Courtesy: Twitter/ Bar and Bench)

Hearing a plea against the series which targeted members of the Muslim community who join India’s civil services, the court said: “At this stage, prima facie, it appears to the court that the object, intent and purpose of the program is to vilify the Muslim community with an insidious attempt to portray them as part of a conspiracy to infiltrate the civil services.”

“We are duty bound to ensure adherence to the program code formed under Cable TV Act edifice of a stable democratic society and observance of constitutional rights and duties is based on coexistence of communities. Any attempt to vilify a community must be viewed with disfavour,” Justice DY Chandrachud said while reading out the order.

The Centre allowed the show to be aired after the Delhi High Court had asked it to decide on the matter. The Supreme Court said that this permission had been given based on a 49-second promo of the show. The channel has aired three episodes of its nine-part series.

Related Stories

The Striking Transformation Of The Pardi Community Of Madhya Pradesh

IAS Officer’s Tips on How to Tackle UPSC CSE

Delhi Police Targets Cyber Criminals, Sets Up Cybercrime Police Stations in 15 Districts

Taking Child-Friendly Policing a Notch Higher

IPS Swagat Das Appointed As Secretary (Security) In Cabinet Secretariat

IPS Maninder Pratap Singh Receives New Posting

Nagaland’s Youngest District and the SP Who Came Here from Haryana

IPS officers Manoj Yadava and U C Sarangi shifted

A bench of Justices DY Chandrachud, Indu Malhotra and KM Joseph asked the channel to defer the airing of the next segment of the show scheduled for Tuesday night. While the channel argued against this in the name of press freedom, Justice Chandrachud said, “This is not a freedom of speech issue. When you say there is a conspiracy by Muslims to flood the civil services,” .

Vlilification Of A Community

Advocate Shadan Farasat, who appeared for the petitioners, said the show had been broadcast thrice. “The content of this broadcast is nothing but the vilification of the Muslim community and that their participation (in UPSC) is wrong,” he said.

“If you read the transcript you will see that they say Muslims are infiltrating the Civil services. They say how Muslim OBCs are eating the share of other OBCs. The show has graphs they have used words like “ha***** gaddar” in the show. Very unfortunate words,”, said senior advocate Anoop Chaudhari, appearing for the petitioners.

Advocate Sharukh Alam, in another intervenor petition filed by a group of Jamia Millia Islamia students, contended hat Sudarshan TV was using hashtags like “USPC Jihad”, “Muslim Infiltration” to promote the show.  Alam argued that the idea against Muslims in civil services was being spread in a very concerted way.

During the hearing, Justice Chandrachud said, “It’s anathema on 19(1)(a) to impose censorship but at the same time human dignity has to be taken into account and some standards have to imposed which in fact, go beyond this program.” He also said that such “insidious charges” also put a question mark on the UPSC exams. “Aspersions have been cast on UPSC. Such allegations without any factual basis, how can this be allowed? Can such programs be allowed in a free society?” he said.

‘Journalistic Freedom Not Absolute’

“Electronic media is as powerful as the print media because the access of electronic media is extraordinarily huge and broad and it can become a focal point for destabilising the nation by targeting particular communities,” he said. Justice Joseph said that “when we talk about journalistic freedom, it is not absolute”. “He shares same freedom as like other citizens. There is no separate freedom for journalists like in the US. We need journalists who are fair in their debates,” he said.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta argued that freedom of a journalist was supreme. “Rabid things being put forth both ways”, not just by the right-wing, but the left-wing as well, he told the court.

“If something nasty written about me, can we really do anything about it? It is press freedom after all,”, he said. Justice Chandrachud said that an “electronic media house which is dedicated to profit-making has to be differentiated from the individual blogs”.

Hindu Terror Analogy

“Your lordships must have seen those programs where “Hindu Terror” was highlighted. The questions is to what extent can courts control the publication of content,” Mehta said. Mehta also argued: “During lockdown there was a web portal which carried a show as to how lockdown will lead to food scarcity and food riot thus leading to migration. I dont consider it less serious than a threat to communal disharmony.”

Justice Chandrachud told Senior Advocate Shyam Divan, who was appearing for Sudarshan TV, that the court expected some restraint from the channel. “Your client is doing a disservice to the nation by doing what it is doing,” he said.

The top court had on August 28 refused to impose a pre-broadcast ban on the show while hearing a plea of lawyer Firoz Iqbal Khan. It issued notices to the Centre, the Press Council of India, the News Broadcasters Association and Sudarshan News. The Ministry of Information and Broadcasting had allowed the programme to be aired, cautioning it to not violate any programme code.

Former Civil Servants Move SC

Meanwhile, seven former civil servants had also moved the Supreme Court to become parties to the pending plea seeking a stay on the show’s telecast. The former civil servants, including Amitabha Pande and Navrekha Sharma, have made an informal collective “Constitutional Conduct Group” and filed the plea seeking to intervene in the pending petition of Khan.

They said that the apex court should lay down an authoritative pronouncement on “hate speech” in view of the fact that it had expressed an intention to consider the balance between free speech and other constitutional values in the instant case.

The scope and meaning of hate speech should be decided so that the citizens, law enforcement authorities, and the courts have clarity on speech which is protected and the speech which falls outside such protection. “There is no bright line between hate speech and offensive speech. Each case requires the application of judicial mind,” it said.

  • Share this article

Tags

  • IPS Association
  • Jihad in Bureaucracy
  • Sudarshan TV
  • UPSC

END OF THE ARTICLE

  • PREVIOUS STORY War of Words Between Top Cops Over Delhi Riots ...
  • NEXT STORY IPS Vs IPS
  • PREVIOUS STORY War of Words Between Top Cops Over Delhi Riots Probe
  • NEXT STORY IPS Vs IPS

NEXT STORIES

featured banner
Tamil Nadu: Financial Assistance to UPSC Aspirants, 1000 Candidates Will Get 7.5K Stipend
  • Ayodhya Prasad Singh
  • Published on 21 Mar 2023, 1:29 pm IST
  • 2 minutes read

Highlights

Among the shortlisted students, those who clear the preliminary exams will be provided with a lump sum amount of Rs 25,000.

featured banner
Registration for UPSC CSE 2023 Exam Ends Today, Apply Now!
  • Indian Masterminds Bureau
  • Published on 21 Feb 2023, 1:11 pm IST
  • 1 minute read

Highlights

Candidates who haven’t registered yet can apply from the official website of the UPSC. The official website is upsc.gov.in

Most Popular

It’s Okay To Be Not Okay, Speak Up and Seek Help for Depression: NITI Aayog Director Shubhrata Prakash

Do You Have ‘Courage to Dream’?

Shubham Kumar Reveals His Preparation Strategy That Got Him AIR 1 in UPSC CSE 2020

How To Increase Farmers’ Income By 40% in Six Months…

Tamil Nadu Police, First in the World, to Adopt Blockchain Technology

featured banner
Registration for UPSC CSE 2023 To End Soon, Apply Now!
  • Indian Masterminds Bureau
  • Published on 18 Feb 2023, 12:06 pm IST
  • 1 minute read

Highlights

Candidates who haven’t registered yet can apply from the official website of the UPSC. The official website is upsc.gov.in

Must read

Inspiring Story of Samyak S Jain: Visually Impaired, Secured AIR-7 in UPSC CSE 2021

Women Rules UPSC CSE-2021 Results, Bag Top 3 Ranks!

100 Candidates Mentored by IPS Officer Mahesh Bhagwat’s Team Get Selected in UPSC CSE 2021

The Top 10 of UPSC CSE 2021: A Cut Above the Rest, Know How They Did It!

Language No Barrier in CSE: Meet Ravi Kumar Sihag, UPSC Topper in Hindi Medium With Air 18

Exclusive Interview With UPSC Topper Shubham Kumar, Shares Valuable Tips On How to Crack Civil Services Exam

‘If I Can Become an IAS Officer, Anybody with Willpower Can’

Taking IAS Officer Father’s Legacy Forward, Shubhankar Pathak Aces UPSC CSE 2021 in Maiden Attempt 

UPSC CSE 2021: Priyamvada Mhaddalkar Tops Maharashtra with AIR-13

UPSC CSE 2021: Ankita Agarwal’s Journey from AIR-239 in 2019 to AIR-2 in 2021

A Daughter Who Fought till Last for Her Father’s Dream, Cracked UPSC CSE 2021 in Sixth Attempt

UP Farmer’s Son On His Way to IAS After Securing AIR 6 in UPSC CSE 2021

“Civil Service is Pro People, That’s Why It Fascinates Me,” Says Yasharth, AIR 12 Rank Holder in CSE 2021

Answer Writing, Self-Notes and Group Sessions are the Keys to UPSC CSE 2021 Topper Shruti Sharma’s Success

Flaws in the System Triggered this Doctor to Get into Civil Services, and She Did It in Style with AIR 19 in UPSC CSE-2021

Ishita Rathi, Daughter of Police Couple, AIR 8 in UPSC CSE-2021 with Economics as Optional

UPSC CSE 2021: Performance of Muslim Candidates Worst in a Decade

featured banner
UPSC CSE 2023 Notification is Out, Check Link Here
  • Indian Masterminds Bureau
  • Published on 1 Feb 2023, 3:16 pm IST
  • 1 minute read

Highlights

Last date to fill out the form is February 21, 2023 till 6:00 PM

Movements

IAS Anurag Agarwal Along With Other IAS Officers Reshuffled In Punjab; Check List

Uttar Pradesh: 08 IPS officer Transferred; IPS Piyush Mordia Posted As ADG, Lucknow Zone

Madhya Pradesh: 12 IPS Officers Transferred; Check List

Gujarat: IAS Vijaykumar Lalubhai Kharadi Appointed As Deputy Director General of SPIPA

Jharkhand Government Issues Transfer and Postings of IAS officers Including Praveen Toppo

Abs Shalini Appointed as Deputy Secretary in Department of Consumer Affairs, Delhi

Four Gujarat Cadre IAS officers Promoted to ACS Grade

Major Reshuffle in MP; Top Cops of Bhopal, Indore Swap Postings

featured banner
UPSC CSE Prelims 2023 Notification; Read Here
  • Indian Masterminds Bureau
  • Published on 21 Jan 2023, 1:40 pm IST
  • 1 minute read

Highlights

As per the official UPSC notification, Civil Services Preliminary Exam 2023 will be conducted on May 28, 2023 (Sunday).

News

Himachal Pradesh Govt. Short Of Senior IAS Officers

Assam: IAS Sewali Devi Sharma Suspended Over Allegation Of Misuse Of Fund In SCERT

Big: Textile Commissioner Office Will Shift From Mumbai to Delhi, Government Released a Letter

Himachal Pradesh: IAS Debasweta Banik Will Go On Central Deputation, Government Will Appoint a DC in Hamirpur Soon

Tamil Nadu: Financial Assistance to UPSC Aspirants, 1000 Candidates Will Get 7.5K Stipend

Esha Sengupta posted as MD, West Bengal Tribal Corp

IPS Vimukt Ranjan to Become DIG of SPG

Sridhar Nadimatla To Be Next CMD of NMDC

featured banner
More Than a Quarter of a Million Posts Are Vacant in The Central Government, IAS-IPS Not on 2300 Posts
  • Indian Masterminds Bureau
  • Published on 24 Dec 2022, 6:31 pm IST
  • 2 minutes read

Highlights

According to sources in the Ministry say that due to the lack of these high officials, there is a problem in the operation of administrative and law and order in various states.

Video Interview

How Are IPS Officers Trained, The Life At SVPNPA…

From Black Robes To Khakee

#InternationalWomensDay2023 Special: One Advice Each From Inspiring Bureaucrats

Vultures Being Cultured

Save The Elephant

A Historic Step In Tiger Conservation

Story Of The Journey From Satara To LBSNAA

IAS Officer Abhilasha Abhinav On How To Crack The Personality Test

LATEST ARTICLES

  • Tamil Nadu: Financial Assistance to UPSC Aspira...
  • Registration for UPSC CSE 2023 Exam Ends Today,...
  • Registration for UPSC CSE 2023 To End Soon, App...
  • UPSC CSE 2023 Notification is Out, Check Link Here
  • UPSC CSE Prelims 2023 Notification; Read Here

Indian Masterminds

Inform, Inspire, Influence

  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • Advertise with us
  • Become a Contributor

@2021 Indian Masterminds. All Right Reserved.