https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Consumers,Not World Bank, Should Rate Ease Of Doing Business

Indian Masterminds Stories

“World Bank Scraps Doing Business Survey”: The Telegraph

“World Bank Discontinues Ease of Doing Business Reports”: Live Mint

Why was World Bank doing this in the first place? Who should determine whether business has actually become easy or not?

I had raised these and some other questions when the NITI Aayog/Department of Industrial Policy (DIPP) and Promotion were going head over heels to “satisfy” the World Bank officials about the improving business environment in the country. Consequent to the efforts, India climbed up the “ease-of-doing-business” ladder. Whether business actually became easy or not was a totally different matter. If private sector investment is the criteria to go by, business had actually not eased. Yet again, “road-showing” model of NITI/DIPP became an important component of “ease-of-doing-business”.

Very interestingly, during the initial years, World Bank looked at only Delhi and Mumbai for determining whether business had become easy (cities that were already saturated for investment) but we lapped it up so long as it suited us.

FICCI’S LETTER TO PM

In a letter to the Prime Minister, FICCI had written that “the model being followed by PMG (could be) replicated across the processes where approvals and clearances are granted under various departments”. No, this was not when the country was apparently climbing the ease of doing business ladder. This was in 2013 when everything that could go wrong was going wrong but the businesses were perceiving that the approach adopted by the Project Monitoring Group (PMG) to fast-track projects that had investment above Rs. 1000 crore could be adopted by all.

In fact, CII too wrote to the Prime Minister about their “appreciation for the good work being done by the PMG”. Why did they say that?  They were under no pressure to say that because they and everyone else were aware that the government was crumbling. They said it because they perceived it as an evolving ease-of-doing business model. The results were here for everyone to see. In just 15 months, projects worth more than Rs. 5 lakh crores were cleared in a transparent manner. Ironically, Prime Minister Modi in one of his Independence Day speeches “claimed” that PMG was his government’s creation.

WEB BASED PLATFORM CREATED

What was PMG doing? Can it become the model for ushering in true ease-of-doing-business?

A web-based platform was created wherein any industry (public or private) proponent could create his own login and password and upload their cases pertaining to a specific ministry and/or state. Simultaneously, each ministry was asked to designate a Joint-Secretary level officer as the nodal officer. Once the project was accepted for consideration by the PMG, the project details and the issues relating to that ministry/department went automatically to the concerned nodal officers along with an automatic mailer. The nodal officer then had to provide comments on the portal itself. These comments were accessible to the concerned project proponent.

SUB GROUPS SET UP

Sub-groups were set up for each ‘recipient’ ministry (there were 12 of them till February 2014), and these sub-groups met periodically on fixed days and time (three of them met every week). The project proponents made brief presentations on the issues that were discussed in the presence of representatives of the ‘sponsoring’ ministry and the ‘recipient’ ministry. The primary objective was to obtain a timeline for a decision to be taken by the recipient ministry. The minutes of the meeting were recorded on the portal at the time of the meeting itself. The discussions were focussed, and the meetings were short as quality groundwork was done by the respective ministries in advance.

Learning from the experience in the implementation of Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY), the discussions were also held at the state headquarters and not merely in Delhi. This facilitated larger participation of the state bureaucracy, including the district collectors, and more in-depth and detailed deliberation on issues. This approach entailed a lot of travelling but it was well worth the effort as it facilitated marketing the concept behind the resolution of issues.

Industry associations like the Confederation of Indian Industries (CII) and the FICCI were leveraged to disseminate the message behind the setting up of PMG and the progress thereunder. Soon, the PMG had started showing results.

SYSTEMIC BOTTLENECKS

Analyses of the problems revealed systemic bottlenecks. These were then taken up with the concerned Ministries/Departments for resolution. Ministry of Environment and Forest was persuaded to digitize the entire process of clearances. Digital tracking enabled transparency and pinpointing of the place of delays. One Cabinet Minister lost her job because she was sitting on files worth Rs. 54,000 crore.

Many States replicated the model for projects that were below Rs. 1000 crore. The PMG was now helping them get their clearances from the Central Ministries. PMG emerged truly as a facilitating organization.

PMG WILL FAST TRACK PROJECTS

Is there a rationale for reviving the PMG in letter and spirit? Yes, not merely at the Centre but also at the state level. It will not only fast-track projects as it had done in the past, but it will provide a platform to the industry to resolve not only their individual problems but also point out towards systemic issues. The PMG will provide evidence relating to procedural complications and the impact they are having on clearances. They can then be corrected. This would be true ease-of-doing-business.

HAS BUSINESS ACTUALLY BECOME EASY?

Whether business has become easy or not cannot and should not be determined by agencies like the World Bank. The ‘consumer’ or ‘recipient’ of the services from the Government should determine whether business has become easy. Don’t ask them in a conference. No one will dare to speak the truth. However, if we continue to be pre-occupied with road-shows, we will have only anecdotal evidence of “Make-in-India” happening. It will never actually happen.

Until and unless we dare to face the truth, business will never become easy. However, to do that, there has to be acceptance of the fact that it is still not very easy to do business in India and then work at a strategy that is designed not to please a few but to please the investor. The “Make-in-India” lion will not need to roar. It will need to walk the rough terrain of Indian business.


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
PM Gatishakti
Govt Opens PM Gati Shakti Portal to Private Sector for Infrastructure Planning and Logistics Optimization
international monetary fund (IMF)
RBI Officers Appointed to IMF Advisory Roles — Meet Dr. Pankaj Kumar and Dr. Dirghau Raut
Backdoor Privatisation
SBI Launches Gender Diversity Initiative to Raise Women Workforce to 30% by 2030 Across All Roles
IPS Puran Kumar suicide Haryana
Haryana IPS Puran Kumar Suicide: Today’s Update - Postmortem Delayed 7 Days Amid Wife’s Arrest Demand; Political Storm Intensifies
Ministry of Defence
Ministry of Defence Utilises Over 50% of FY 2025-26 Capital Budget by September, Boosts Indigenous Defence Procurement
Chennai Petroleum Corporation Limited (CPCL)
PESB Selects S G Venkatesh as Director (Technical) of Chennai Petroleum Corporation Limited
ongc cost-cutting strategy
ONGC Charts ₹9,300 Crore Cost-Cutting Strategy Amid Global Volatility; Expects Oil Prices to Stabilize at $60–$65 per Barrel
IAS-G
Who Is IAS G Surya Sai Praveenchand? 2019-Batch Officer Takes Charge as JMD of AP Transco
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IDES Saquib Alam
Beyond IAS and IPS: The Inspiring Work of an IDES officer | Video Interview 
IDES Saquib Alam
UPSC Strategy & Mindset Tips from IDES Officer Saquib Alam | Video Interview 
Dr G K Goswami IPS
Everything you ever wanted to know about e-murder, e-dacoity and data safety
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
VikramDeo Saryam MPPSC
He Couldn't Pay Engineering Fees, Now He’s a Deputy Collector: Meet Vikram Deo, Farmer’s Son Who Cracked MPPSC with Sheer Willpower
Vikram, a farmer’s son from Ramgovindpur, overcame financial hardships and years of setbacks to secure...
Shivani Sirmache MPPSC
Do It From Home If You Can,’ Said Her Family - She Did It with Self-Study and Sheer Will: Meet Shivani Sirmache, MPPSC 2024 Topper
Shivani Sirmache, a village girl from Sirali, cracked MPPSC 2024 with Rank 11 through complete self-study,...
IAS Officer C
"She Believed She Could, So She Did" - The Inspiring Journey of IAS Officer C. Vanmathi
From herding buffaloes and facing early marriage pressure to becoming an IAS officer, C. Vanmathi’s journey...
Social Media
IFS Parveen Kaswan
Heartbreak by the River: 15-Day-Old Elephant Calf Rejected by Mother, Rescued by IFS Parveen Kaswan and His Team
Jaldapra, West Bengal: In a moving incident that tugs at the heart, a 15-day-old elephant calf was rescued...
Ashwini Bhide IAS and Anand Mahindra
Who Is IAS Ashwini Bhide, Hailed as a Role Model for Mumbai Metro Transformation by Anand Mahindra?
From heritage to high-tech: Bhide’s leadership in Metro Line 3 earns public praise and admiration
World Rhino Day India
On World Rhino Day, IFS Officer Parveen Kaswan Shares Rare Insights - India Now Hosts 80% of the World’s One-Horned Rhinos
September 22 Marks Global Call for Rhino Conservation; India Holds 80% of World’s Greater One-Horned...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
PM Gatishakti
Govt Opens PM Gati Shakti Portal to Private Sector for Infrastructure Planning and Logistics Optimization
international monetary fund (IMF)
RBI Officers Appointed to IMF Advisory Roles — Meet Dr. Pankaj Kumar and Dr. Dirghau Raut
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IDES Saquib Alam
IDES Saquib Alam
Dr G K Goswami IPS
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT