New Delhi: The Supreme Court has expunged adverse observations made by the Madras High Court against senior Indian Police Service (IPS) officer A. Arun, in a case involving a preventive detention order issued during his tenure as Greater Chennai Police Commissioner.
In its November 2 judgment, a bench comprising Justices Vikram Nath, R. Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh accepted Arun’s unconditional apology and his assurance that he would exercise greater care while discharging his official responsibilities.
However, the court also cautioned that an apology cannot replace the due care required when exercising statutory powers that affect an individual’s personal liberty.
The Supreme Court clarified that its order was limited to removing the adverse remarks against the officer. The Madras High Court’s decision to quash the preventive detention order remains unaffected.
Why Did the Supreme Court Expunge Remarks Against A. Arun?
The matter originated from a preventive detention order issued by A. Arun (IPS: 1998: TN) on September 22, 2025, when he was serving as Commissioner of Police, Greater Chennai.
The order was passed under Section 3(1) of the Tamil Nadu Prevention of Dangerous Activities Act, 1982, commonly referred to as the Goondas Act.
The detention concerned a man who was subsequently identified in the Supreme Court proceedings as the father of Varsha Sharma, the petitioner before the Madras High Court.
According to the Supreme Court judgment, the underlying criminal case arose from a complaint by a person named Ravi, who had entered into a sale and construction agreement with Lokaa Developers Private Limited for the purchase of an apartment.
The complainant had allegedly paid ₹1.38 crore towards the property. However, the apartment was not handed over despite the agreements and payment. It was further alleged that the property was dealt with in favour of third parties and mortgaged using documents alleged to be forged.
A criminal case was registered on August 29, 2025, under various provisions of the Indian Penal Code. The man and his wife, who were directors of the company, were arrested on September 1, 2025.
Subsequently, a proposal for preventive detention was forwarded to Arun by the Inspector of Police, Central Crime Branch-II. After considering the material placed before him, he issued the detention order on September 22, 2025.
Madras High Court Quashed the Detention Order
Varsha Sharma challenged the detention of her father before the Madras High Court through a habeas corpus petition.
On May 29, 2026, the High Court set aside the detention order and made adverse observations against Arun in its judgment.
The High Court criticised the manner in which the preventive detention order had been issued and questioned the officer’s approach to exercising such powers.
Arun subsequently approached the Supreme Court, seeking the removal of the adverse remarks.
A. Arun Tendered an Unconditional Apology
During the Supreme Court proceedings, Arun appeared before the bench. His senior counsel, Sidharth Luthra, submitted that the officer had realised his mistake and was willing to tender an unconditional apology.
An affidavit was subsequently filed in which Arun expressed regret for failing to acknowledge his error and apologise when he was summoned by the Madras High Court.
He also apologised to both the Supreme Court and the Madras High Court and assured the bench that he would exercise greater care while performing his official duties in the future.
Taking note of the apology and assurance, the Supreme Court ordered that the adverse remarks against him in paragraphs 6, 8, 10 and 19 to 23 of the Madras High Court judgment be expunged.
Supreme Court’s Caution on Preventive Detention Powers
While granting relief to Arun, the Supreme Court emphasised that public authorities must carefully examine the facts and applicable law before exercising statutory powers.
The bench observed that preventive detention requires particular caution because it directly affects an individual’s liberty.
The court also underlined the responsibilities attached to senior positions in police administration, stating that officers must appreciate the significance of their duties and the consequences of exercising statutory authority.
Supreme Court Judgment: A. Arun vs Varsha Sharma and Others
The Supreme Court delivered its judgment on November 2, 2026, in A. Arun vs Varsha Sharma and Others.
The case was registered as a criminal appeal arising out of Special Leave Petition (Criminal) No. 16725 of 2026. The judgment is reported as 2026 INSC 1186.
The ruling removes the adverse observations made against Arun but does not restore the preventive detention order. The Madras High Court’s decision setting aside the detention remains intact.
Read Also: SC Expunges Madras HC Strictures Against Tamil Nadu IPS Officer A. Arun After Unconditional Apology














