New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has ruled that an Aadhaar card alone cannot be treated as conclusive proof of date of birth when deciding an employee’s retirement age. The court also upheld a decision against an employer that terminated a woman employee one year before her actual retirement date by relying on her Aadhaar details.
The judgment highlights the importance of checking reliable employment records before making retirement decisions.
Details of Aadhaar Card Date Of Birth Proof Ruling
The case involved a woman named Rosamma Joy, who worked at J.J. Electronics in Delhi.
Read also: Is Aadhaar Card Not Proof Of Age? MP High Court Explains Its Legal Position
She claimed that she had been working at the company as a finishing worker since December 1, 1981. Her last drawn monthly salary was ₹10,500.
The dispute started when the company ended her employment on May 20, 2017, claiming that she had reached the retirement age of 58 years.
The company relied on her Aadhaar card, which showed her date of birth as May 20, 1959. However, the woman challenged this decision before the Labour Court, arguing that her employment had been terminated illegally.
Why Did The Date Of Birth Become A Major Issue
The main issue was the difference between the date of birth recorded in her Aadhaar card and the company’s earlier employment-related records.
Her Aadhaar card showed May 20, 1959, as her date of birth. However, the company had already provided a different date of birth, May 20, 1960, to the Employees’ State Insurance Corporation (ESIC) in June 2010.
This record was created several years before the employment dispute started. The Labour Court considered the earlier ESIC record more reliable and rejected the company’s argument that the woman had reached retirement age in May 2017.
What Did The Delhi High Court Say About Aadhaar Card Date Of Birth Proof
Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri observed that an Aadhaar card, by itself, is not proof of date of birth.
The court explained that Aadhaar is mainly used to establish a person’s identity. The date of birth recorded in Aadhaar may be based on documents or information provided by the cardholder.
The court also referred to the UIDAI clarification dated December 20, 2018, which explains that Aadhaar is not, by itself, proof of date of birth.
The judgment also referred to the Supreme Court’s decision in Saroj v. IFFCO-Tokio General Insurance Co., 2024, which recognised that Aadhaar can establish identity but is not automatically proof of date of birth.
The High Court further explained that when different documents show different dates of birth, their evidentiary value must be examined before reaching a conclusion.
Why Did The Court Support The Woman Employee
The High Court found that the company had itself provided May 20, 1960, as the woman’s date of birth to ESIC in 2010. However, it later relied on her Aadhaar card to claim that she had reached retirement age in May 2017.
The court also noted that the company failed to produce the original documents supporting the date of birth it had provided to ESIC.
It did not even cross-examine the ESIC official who appeared before the Labour Court to prove the employment-related record.
The High Court observed that the company could not record one date of birth with ESIC and later rely on a different date in Aadhaar to end her employment one year earlier.
What Compensation Did The Woman Receive
The Labour Court had already found that the woman’s termination was illegal and unjustified.
It directed the company to pay her full back wages at the rate of ₹14,698 per month from May 20, 2017, to May 20, 2018.
This was the period during which she would have continued working until reaching the retirement age of 58 years.
The Labour Court also awarded consequential benefits and interest at 6% per annum from the date of publication of its award until payment.
The Delhi High Court upheld these findings and dismissed the company’s petition.
It also directed the release of the amount deposited with the court, along with any interest earned, and payment of the remaining amount, if any, within four weeks.
Read also: Adopted Children To Be Recorded As Sons And Daughters: Kerala High Court
FAQs
An employer cannot automatically establish an employee’s retirement age using Aadhaar alone when other records show a different date of birth. The evidentiary value of the available documents must be examined.
An Aadhaar card is primarily proof of identity and is not, by itself, conclusive proof of date of birth. UIDAI has clarified that its acceptance for date-of-birth purposes depends on the applicable rules and circumstances.
On November 13, 2026, the Delhi High Court dismissed J.J. Electronics’ petition and upheld the Labour Court’s decision awarding full back wages to Rosamma Joy for her illegal termination.














