https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

The Real Threat To An Institution Comes Not From External Source, It Comes From Within

Indian Masterminds Stories

As India enters the Amrit Kal of her Independence, it is important to set at rest the recurrent doubts about the ability, competence, and capability of the governance professionals of this country. Research on this subject shows a recurrent pattern – it happens every two decades. A hundred and one years ago, KPS Menon topped the ICS exam. Many in the ICS and the Secretary of State’s office felt that this was the beginning of the end of the ICS! How could an Indian be better than the best of Oxbridge graduates?

SARDAR PATEL STEPPED IN

Two decades later, the civil services exams had to be discontinued because of World War II. Again, the naysayers said that this was the beginning of the end, as there would be no further recruitment. This was not all. After the British decided to leave India, the Secretary of State decided to dismember ICS in August/September of 1946. Sardar Patel stepped in and called for a meeting with the Premiers of the eleven provinces (as the states were then called). Not only were the ICS and IP officers asked to continue, but the Conference of Premiers also decided on the constitution of the IAS and the IPS and the joint recruitment and training of all superior services.

A file photo of Sardar Patel

JUDICIAL & EXECUTIVE FUNCTIONS SEPARATED

By the mid-Sixties, most states had separated the judicial and executive functions of the DMs. It led to a series of articles in newspapers and journals saying that this would affect the prestige and power of the bureaucracy. Well, by this time, the primary focus of the state had shifted to Atma Nirbharta in food. While the agriculture department provided the seeds – the ecosystem of credit, market infrastructure and procurement were done by the civil services.

73rd & 74th AMENDMENTS

In 1984, David Potter wrote the book, India’s Political Administrators, and said that civil services would be challenged by elected Panchayats and municipal corporations. In his concluding remarks, he went ahead and announced (much like Fukuyama’s The End of History) that it would take not more than two decades for the services to be wound up. The 73rd /74th amendment were enacted in 1994, but it was welcomed by members of the civil service. In fact, the LBSNAA and NIRD were closely engaged in the national consultations on this subject.

DOUBTS ABOUT A LITERATE INDIA

In 2000, the late lamented Stephen Cohen, author of several books on India and Pakistan, and my mentor at the Brookings Institution Washington DC asked me if a literate India would be more difficult to administer. I remember telling him very clearly that in the next two decades, India would have shed the developing nation tag, and become one of the fastest-growing economies, even as it will afford social security and protection to her people. And I am so glad to mention that the last few years have been marked, not just by rapid economic growth, but also by strict enforcement of the Right to Food and the Right to Work. In and by themselves, these are the largest public welfare programmes in the world – and who is behind the successful rollout of these programmes.

CONSIDER CENTRAL DEPUTATION A RIGHT

There is of course the fundamental issue of how to balance the tenures for all Indian service officers between the Centre and the state. I should however point out that in a purely technical sense, a central tenure is not a deputation – for working for the central government is not only an imperative but if one may say, a matter of right.

Sanjeev Chopra, former LBSNAA Director (the writer of this article)

UPSC INSPIRES CONFIDENCE

Having established the twenty-year pattern of surge and settlement of criticism, let me say that twenty years from now, a similar commentary would appear on the editorial pages of newspapers. The problem with many critics of the civil services is that they have fewer opportunities to interact with the next generation of officers which is equally good, if not better. However, this columnist keeps getting feedback about all the great work that is being done on the ground. Let me also say, that it is now acknowledged by one and all that the competition to join the civil services is far tougher than ever before, and the positive point is that the UPSC inspires confidence and trust in its transparent recruitment process.

THE THREAT LIES WITHIN

But before I close, let me again reiterate that the real threat to an institution does not come from any external source. It comes from within. You have to realise the infinite power within you – the power of knowledge, the power of networking, the power of field experience, the power of leveraging technology – and last but not the least, the protection which the Bhishma Pitamah of the civil service has given to us – very few civil services have the constitutional protection that we have under article 311. And he gave us this protection that we use our Mantrana Shakti and Utsah Shakti for the best use of the nation for, as he said, “You will not have a united India unless you have not a good All India service, which has the independence to speak out its mind, and has a sense of security…”

(This article has been written by Sanjeev Chopra, retired IAS officer, former Director of Lal Bahadur Shastri National Academy of Administration, Distinguished Fellow, USI Delhi, Historian & Policy Analyst, and Festival Director of Valley of Words www.valleyofwords.org)  


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
RINL
Leadership Update: Rakesh Nandan Sahay Appointed as Director (Personnel) at RINL, Selected by PESB from Among 10 Candidates
coal-India-limited-scaled
Coal India Secures Ontillu-Chandragiri Rare Earth Block in Andhra Pradesh, Strengthens Critical Minerals Portfolio
IAS officer Vinay Kumar Choubey
Khasmahal Land Scam: Senior Jharkhand IAS Officer Remains in Jail as ACB Court Rejects Bail
POWERGRID Dividend to Government 2025
POWERGRID Pays ₹574.35 Crore Final Dividend to Government; Total Payout for FY25 Hits ₹4,297.40 Crore
BEL
BEL Secures ₹712 Crore Worth of New Defence and IT Orders, Expands Presence in Cybersecurity and Blockchain
Parag Madhukar Dhakate
Relentless Rains Wreak Havoc in Dehradun: IFS officer PM Dhakate Warns Citizens Amid Flash Floods
Gujarat tallest Govt tower
Surat to House India’s Tallest Government Administrative Building: Iconic Green Twin Towers to Redefine Urban Governance
NTPC
NTPC Ranked Among TIME’s World’s Best 1000 Companies 2025 for Sustainability, Growth, and Employee Excellence
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Dr. S.K
Technology Meets Ecology: IFS Dr S K Srivastava’s Game-Changing Innovations in Forest Management | Eco Warrior Awards 2025 Interview
IFS Uttam Kumar Sharma Interview
From Extinction to Exhilaration: The Untold Story and Future Vision of Project Cheetah | Led by IFS Uttam Kumar Sharma | Eco Warrior Awards 2025
K M Abharna IFS Eco Warrior Awards 2025
Meet K. M. Abharna, the IFS Officer Behind Avni’s Case and Vidya Balan’s Sherni Role
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
Ishwarlal Gurjar UPSC
10th Grade Failure to Indian Police Service: Ishwarlal Gurjar’s UPSC Success Path
Read the inspiring journey of Ishwarlal Gurjar from a small village in Rajasthan to becoming an IPS officer....
IAS Minnu P M
“Lazy, Sleepy, Yet Determined”: Minnu P M’s Honest Take on Cracking UPSC
Minnu PM, once a clerk in Kerala Police, cleared UPSC with AIR 150 after five years of struggle. Her...
IPS Ashish Tiwari
From IIT and Investment Banking to Public Service, Meet IPS Ashish Tiwari 
Ashish Tiwari, IIT graduate and former investment banker, chose public service over global finance. As...
Social Media
Parag Madhukar Dhakate
Relentless Rains Wreak Havoc in Dehradun: IFS officer PM Dhakate Warns Citizens Amid Flash Floods
Cloudbursts in Dehradun triggered flash floods. IFS officer Dr. PM Dhakate warned citizens to stay indoors...
Forest Guard Tiger Encounter
Tigers Clash in the Wild as Forest Guards Capture Rare Footage , Retired IFS Mohan Pargaien Posts Viral Video
Retired IFS officer Mohan Pargaien shares viral video of three tigers brawling in Ramnagar, as forest...
Tamil Nadu Gaur Rescue
Tiruchirappalli Forest Officials Risk Lives to Rescue Juvenile Gaur; Video Shared by IAS Officer Goes Viral
Trichy forest and fire teams risk lives to rescue a juvenile Indian gaur; IAS officer Supriya Sahu shares...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
RINL
Leadership Update: Rakesh Nandan Sahay Appointed as Director (Personnel) at RINL, Selected by PESB from Among 10 Candidates
coal-India-limited-scaled
Coal India Secures Ontillu-Chandragiri Rare Earth Block in Andhra Pradesh, Strengthens Critical Minerals Portfolio
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
Dr. S.K
IFS Uttam Kumar Sharma Interview
K M Abharna IFS Eco Warrior Awards 2025
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT