New Delhi: In a significant setback for the Telangana government, the Supreme Court on Thursday quashed the appointments of Prof. M. Kodandaram and Amir Ali Khan as Members of the Legislative Council (MLCs) under the Governor’s quota. The Court held that the selection process was invalid and contrary to constitutional provisions.
The decision, which effectively removes both individuals from their positions, follows a prolonged legal battle stemming from a petition filed by Dasoju Sravan and Satyanarayana.
Petition Challenged Qualifications of Nominees
The petitioners argued that the appointments violated established norms for nominations under the Governor’s quota. As per constitutional guidelines, these seats are reserved for persons with exceptional achievements in literature, science, art, and social service.
Prof. Kodandaram, a noted political analyst and founder of the Telangana Jana Samithi (TJS), and Amir Ali Khan, editor of the Urdu daily The Siasat Daily, were nominated by the state government. The Telangana High Court had earlier quashed their appointments, but the Supreme Court stayed that order, allowing them to continue in office until Thursday’s final verdict.
Also Read: ‘People Need Judgments’: SC Orders Jharkhand HC Judges to Take Leave and Deliver Verdicts
Court Reaffirms Adherence to Constitutional Standards
In its ruling, the apex court stressed the importance of maintaining the integrity of the Governor’s quota. The Bench underscored that such nominations must strictly follow the constitutional mandate and cannot be used for political accommodation.
The verdict has reignited debate over the selection process for Legislative Council members under this special category, with legal observers noting that it reinforces merit-based criteria over political considerations.
Further Proceedings Scheduled
The case will return to the Supreme Court on September 17, when further directions on the matter are expected. Until then, the two vacated seats will remain unfilled.
The ruling stands as a reminder that even gubernatorial appointments are subject to judicial scrutiny, ensuring that constitutional provisions are upheld in both letter and spirit.
