New Delhi: The Supreme Court of India has upheld the decision to introduce a written examination midway through the recruitment process for 46 Excise Constable posts in Nagaland. The Court said that a written test provides a common and objective way to assess candidates and reduces excessive dependence on interviews.
The ruling came in a case challenging the decision of the Nagaland government to add a written examination after issuing the original recruitment advertisement.
Details of Nagaland Excise Constable Recruitment
The case is titled T. Akon Phom And Others vs State Of Nagaland And Others. The recruitment process started in April 2025. The Nagaland Department of Excise and Prohibition initially announced 40 Excise Constable posts.
Read also: Can NRIs Remarry After Foreign Divorce? Supreme Court Clarifies Indian Law
Later, the number of vacancies increased to 46. The original recruitment advertisement provided for two stages of selection:
- Physical Test
- Suitability Test or Viva-Voce (Interview)
However, on June 4, 2025, the Departmental Recruitment Board issued a corrigendum and added a written examination to the selection process. The written examination was based on the Class 8 syllabus and carried 100 marks.
Why Did the Nagaland Government Introduce A Written Examination
The government said that a very large number of candidates had applied for a limited number of vacancies. According to the State, a total of 11,521 applications were received for 46 posts.
Out of these, 5,985 candidates appeared for the physical test, while 2,297 candidates qualified for the next stage.
The government argued that a written examination was necessary to assess candidates fairly and manage the large number of applicants. It also said that the test would provide an objective method of shortlisting candidates.
Why Did Nagaland Excise Constable Recruitment Candidates Challenge The Decision
Some candidates challenged the introduction of the written examination before the courts. They argued that the recruitment process should follow the conditions mentioned in the original advertisement.
According to them, the selection criteria could not be changed after the recruitment process had already started. They also argued that adding a written examination was against the applicable recruitment rules.
The matter reached the Supreme Court after the Gauhati High Court’s Division Bench upheld the decision of the Nagaland government.
What Did The Supreme Court Say
A Bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar examined the matter.
The Court observed that the Nagaland Excise Service (Revised) Rules, 1999, allowed direct recruitment through a competitive examination or selection.
The rules did not prescribe a detailed method for conducting the selection process. Therefore, the recruitment authority had the power to introduce a suitable selection or shortlisting method, provided it followed the applicable rules.
The Court also noted that the written examination was based on the already-prescribed Class 8 educational standard.
Written Examination Provides Fair Assessment, Says Supreme Court
The Supreme Court rejected the argument that adding a written examination automatically made the recruitment process arbitrary. It explained that a written test provides a common basis for assessing all candidates.
The Court also observed that interviews can involve a greater degree of subjective assessment. Therefore, an objective written examination can help reduce excessive dependence on interview-based evaluation.
The Court further noted that the revised examination requirement was widely publicised through local newspapers. All candidates who qualified in the physical test had to follow the same revised selection procedure.
Candidates Failed To Prove Discrimination Or Prejudice
Another important point considered by the Supreme Court was whether the revised selection process had treated candidates unfairly. The Court noted that the appellants had participated in the recruitment process despite knowing about the revised procedure.
They also failed to demonstrate how the introduction of the written examination had caused discrimination or actual prejudice to them. The Court therefore found no sufficient reason to interfere with the Gauhati High Court’s decision.
Nagaland Excise Constable Recruitment: Supreme Court Dismisses The Appeal
After examining the arguments and applicable recruitment rules, the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal.
The decision allows the Nagaland government to continue with the revised recruitment procedure for the 46 Excise Constable posts. The judgment highlights that recruitment authorities may introduce suitable selection procedures during an ongoing recruitment process when the existing rules permit such action. However, any such change must remain consistent with the applicable rules and principles of fairness and equality.
Read also: Supreme Court Questions Two-Child Election Rule As India’s Fertility Rate Falls
FAQs
The Supreme Court decided T. Akon Phom And Others vs State Of Nagaland And Others concerning the introduction of a written examination during the recruitment process for Excise Constable posts.
Yes. The Supreme Court held that a recruiting authority can introduce a written examination midway if the applicable recruitment rules permit it and the revised procedure is fair and non-discriminatory.
The recruitment initially advertised 40 Excise Constable posts. The number was later increased to 46 posts.














