https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Singapore Court Voids Arbitral Award Led by Ex-CJI Dipak Misra Over Breach of Natural Justice

The award was part of a dispute linked to India’s Dedicated Freight Corridor project, where the tribunal’s judgment was found to contain extensive portions copied from unrelated arbitration cases.
Indian Masterminds Stories

In a landmark ruling, the Court of Appeal of Singapore has set aside an arbitral award chaired by former Chief Justice of India, Dipak Misra, due to a breach of natural justice. The award was part of a dispute linked to India’s Dedicated Freight Corridor project, where the tribunal’s judgment was found to contain extensive portions copied from unrelated arbitration cases.

The arbitration, involving a special purpose vehicle managing India’s freight corridors and a consortium of infrastructure companies, centered on a dispute over additional payments linked to increased minimum wages for workers in India, stemming from a 2017 government notification. The contract, which designated Singapore as the seat of arbitration, led the consortium to initiate proceedings in December 2021 under the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) rules.

However, what stood out in the judgment was the significant amount of copied content. The Court of Appeal observed that nearly 47 percent of the 451 paragraphs in the arbitral award were verbatim excerpts from two earlier arbitration proceedings that were also chaired by Justice Misra. The two other co-arbitrators in the current case had no knowledge of the content or context of the earlier cases, which created an imbalance in the decision-making process.

The court ruled that this extensive reproduction of previous decisions, without adjustments for the specifics of the case at hand, gave rise to an appearance of prejudgment and bias. The tribunal’s reliance on prior awards, instead of thoroughly evaluating the unique aspects of the dispute, led to a conclusion that was not based on an independent assessment of the issues.

The Singapore Court of Appeal’s judgment emphasized that the integrity of the decision-making process had been compromised. By drawing from prior awards, the tribunal failed to ensure that the parties received a fair hearing. Moreover, since the president of the tribunal, Justice Misra, had prior knowledge of the parallel arbitration proceedings, the co-arbitrators were placed at a disadvantage, leading to unequal access to information.

This ruling is a significant reminder of the high standards expected in international arbitration, particularly in maintaining fairness and impartiality. It also raises important questions about the involvement of retired judges in arbitration proceedings, especially when they may have prior knowledge of related cases. The decision underscores the importance of ensuring that each case is considered independently, free from external influences or biases.

Read the Judgement Copy Here-


Indian Masterminds Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
NEWS
Calcutta HC
Calcutta High Court Issues Contempt Notice Against IPS Officer Vishal Garg and 6 Others
SBI_resized
SBI Declares Rs. 15.90 Dividend Per Share for FY 2024-25
IAS-Vikas-Anand-resized
IAS Officer Vikas Anand Repatriated to Join Delhi CM’s Office, Know More About Him
Dr
Centre Abruptly Terminates Dr. Krishnamurthy Subramanian’s Tenure as India’s ED to IMF
Oriental Insurance OICL
Sanjay Joshi Recommended as CMD of Oriental Insurance Company by FSIB
Gujarat-government resized
17 IAS Officers Transferred in Gujarat, D D Jadeja Appointed MD, Gujarat State Biotechnology Mission; Check Transfer Order Here
IAAS
Partha Sarathi Das Repatriated to Parent Cadre with Extended Cooling-Off; Know more about him
Uttar Pradesh Police (UP)_resized
UP: 4 PPS Officers Reshuffled in Sambhal; Anuj Chaudhary Shifted to Chandausi, Alok Kumar Appointed CO City
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IMG-20250429-WA0019
How Mission IAS is Transforming Dreams of Underprivileged UPSC Aspirants
Aakash Garg
Computer Engineer Aakash Garg Takes AIR-5 in UPSC CSE 2024 Through Sheer Discipline And Hard Work | Exclusive
Sandeep M Tamgadge
How IPS Sandeep M Tamgadge’s Journey Can Guide Your UPSC Preparation
ADVERTISEMENT
UPSC Stories
Shruti Maloo UPSC
From Reserve List to AIR 534: How Maharashtra's Shruti Maloo Reached the Interview Stage in All Her UPSC Attempts
Shruti Maloo’s UPSC journey is a story of perseverance, strategy, and resilience. After three attempts,...
Abhi-jain-IAS-story-2025-04-7912a774cc9e0c21ed0d6dfdc092c74d
A Farmer's Son, A Nation's Servant: Abhi Jain, AIR 34 in UPSC CSE 2024
Farmer’s son Abhi Jain cracked UPSC in his fifth attempt, securing AIR 34 without coaching—balancing...
WhatsApp Image 2025-05-03 at 15.43
Daughter of an Anganwadi Worker, Father Lost at 4 - Shivani Panchal Secures AIR-53 in UPSC
Raised by an anganwadi worker after losing her father at 4, Shivani Panchal from Bhodwal Majri cracked...
Social Media
Shakti Dubey AIR 1
UPSC Rank 1 Shakti Dubey's Success Sparks Debate on Civil Services Examination System, Ex-IPS Officer Raises Questions
Shakti Dubey’s UPSC Rank 1 success has sparked debate after ex-IPS officer Yashovardhan Azad questioned...
IAS Pulkit Garg
Central Jail Road Transforms into a Vibrant People-Centric Street in Varanasi
This road has been given a soul, the soul of a musical path, adorned with pink enamel folk art and every...
Rajan Singh Ex-IPS
Ex-IPS Officer Rajan Singh Shares Powerful Insight on Influence through Action
Mr. Rajan Singh is an ex-IPS officer of the 1997-batch (Kerala cadre) and founder of HabitStrong Org...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
Shruti Maloo UPSC
From Reserve List to AIR 534: How Maharashtra's Shruti Maloo Reached the Interview Stage in All Her UPSC Attempts
Calcutta HC
Calcutta High Court Issues Contempt Notice Against IPS Officer Vishal Garg and 6 Others
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Videos
IMG-20250429-WA0019
Aakash Garg
Sandeep M Tamgadge
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT