https://indianmasterminds.com

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

IAS Smita Sabharwal’s Opinion Against The ‘Necessity Of Disability Quotas’ In Bureaucracy Sparks Outrage

Officer Smita Sabharwal, affectionately endeared as "people's officer," is a 2001-batch Telangana cadre IAS officer, who became the first female IAS Officer to be appointed to the Chief Minister’s Office
Indian Masterminds Stories

IAS Smita Sabharwal has recently upped the ante on the contentious “Puja Khedkar Fake Disability Certificate Saga” through her controversial take on the ‘necessity’ of disability quotas in India’s premium government services. She opines that since ‘differently-abled’ individuals find it difficult to tend to the demanding conditions of work in All India Services, such a Quota should not exist in the first place.

Taking to X from her official handle (where she has over 4.3 lakh followers), Officer Sabharwal had written, “With all due respect to the Differently Abled. Does an Airline hire a pilot with disability? Or would you trust a surgeon with a disability. The nature of the #AIS ( IAS/IPS/IFoS) is field-work, long taxing hours, listening first hand to people’s grievances-which requires physical fitness. Why does this premier service need this Quota in the first place!”

This tweet made her the cynosure of intense banter between dissenters and supporters, alike. When an X-user lamented over the fact that ‘an IAS officer was fundamentally ignorant about disability’ and enunciated that “most disabilities have no impact on stamina or intelligence.” Officer Sabharwal, in her reply, stated, “I am fundamentally aware of the needs of the job. The issue here is about the suitability for a ground job. Also, I firmly believe other Services within the Govt such as desk/think-tank nature is well suited.”

In another instance, Ms. Priyanka Chaturvedi, a Rajya Sabha MP from Maharashtra, countered IAS Sabharwal and wrote on X, “This is such a pathetic and exclusionary view to have. Interesting to see how bureaucrats are showing their limited thoughts and their privilege too.” Officer Sabharwal was swift to respond and wrote, “If bureaucrats do not speak on pertinent issues of governance, then who will? My thoughts and concern, stem from a career of 24 odd years… no limited experience.”

Find the original tweet here:

Later, Officer Sabharwal took to X and expressed her final stand on the virtual debate by writing, “I suppose addressing the elephant in the room gets you that reaction. Would request the Rights Activists to also examine why this quota has still not been implemented in the IPS/ IFoS and certain sectors like defence. My limited point is that the IAS is no different.  To live in an inclusive society is a dream that we all subscribe to. Insensitivity has no place in my mind.”

IAS Sabharwal’s Feed Becomes A Hotbed For Discord:

Many individuals, mostly articulate netizens and even eminent personalities engaged in the debate and expressed their views on the matter.

One of those who opposed Ms. Sabharwal’s take wrote:

“Thanks to your understanding. Locomotor disability doesnt mean a person cant move without any support. Im my self a locomotor disabled and an Amputee. I have travelled 4 countries alone, I have travelled all south states. I run a business, I drive , I Swim. I walk with crutches.

And most of the modern day IAS and IPS are not into service they are treating themselves as Kings and Queens, they are enjoying luxurious life forgetting they are civil Servants.” Officer Sabharwal replied, “Hats off to you.”

Another dissenter wrote, “My daughter has loco motor issue with more issue of chronic neurological conditions. But she stood first in her class. Trying to swim, cycle, and wants me to teach driving. I wish we had automobile company who could come up to help with hand accelerator. With all respect Madam @SmitaSabharwal there is no quota for disabled in IPS, IFS and IFoS meaning these services have already been categorised as not suitable for disabled. Disabled people have been given access to only IAS out of three AIS.”

There were users who supported Officer Sabharwal’s take, too. One user wrote, “You are right madam , I think the disability quota can sometimes lead to tokenism rather than genuine empowerment and this can undermine the credibility of the services also. This is the big compromise with the efficiency and effectiveness of public administration.”

Another stated, “Support Smita madam views. She talks about particular services that can be avoided to get maximum efficiency. What’s wrong with this? It’s not about empowering differently abled.”

“You are absolutely right. All the virtue signalling folks will jump on you today. Quotas for disabled in high intensity jobs should be relooked. Many come to regret it later and are given lighter postings. The brilliant ones like Ms Singhal will get in without quotas,” observed another user.

Officer Smita Sabharwal, affectionately endeared as “people’s officer,” is a 2001-batch Telangana cadre IAS officer, who became the first female IAS Officer to be appointed to the Chief Minister’s Office.


Indian Masterminds Stories
Related Stories
NEWS
Suspended-IAS-Abhishek-Prakash-CM-YOGI
Departmental Inquiry Initiated Against Suspended IAS Abhishek Prakash
GAIL PSU
GAIL Launches ‘GAIL Pankh’ to Support Start-Ups
nmdc resized
NMDC Achieves Record 44.04 MnT Production and Highest-Ever Q4 Sales in FY25
Reserve-Bank-of-India_RBI_resized
RBI Reports 98.21% of Rs 2000 Notes Returned, Only Rs 6,366 Crore in Circulation
NHPC_resized_2
NHPC Begins Commercial Operations for 600 MW at Parbati-II Hydroelectric Project
BEL Bharat Electronics Limited
BEL Achieves Record Rs 23,000 Crore Turnover in FY 2024-25
UPPCS PSC New
UP DPC Meeting to Promote 27 PCS Officers to IAS Cadre; Central Govt Allocates Rs 236 Crore for Home Guard Reimbursement
Surendra-Singh-Yadav IPS
IPS Surendra Singh Yadav Appointed Deputy Inspector General in BSF, Relieved from Chandigarh DGP Post
Videos
Padmapani Bora IRS
The Rise of Assam as India’s Most Exciting Tourist Spot | Exclusive with IRS Padmapani Bora
Sajjan Yadav, IAS
The Policy Maker Who Turned India’s Vaccine Story and UPSC Struggles into Bestsellers
WhatsApp Image 2025-03-21 at 14.33
Training The Cops In Mastering The Technology Used By Criminals
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest
Suspended-IAS-Abhishek-Prakash-CM-YOGI
Departmental Inquiry Initiated Against Suspended IAS Abhishek Prakash
GAIL PSU
GAIL Launches ‘GAIL Pankh’ to Support Start-Ups
Videos
Padmapani Bora IRS
Sajjan Yadav, IAS
WhatsApp Image 2025-03-21 at 14.33
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT